Category: MLB

Phillies vs. Guardians Sunday Night Baseball prop bets: Kyle Schwarber looks to keep mashing from cleanup spot

Phillies vs. Guardians prop bets

The Philadelphia Phillies and Cleveland Guardians wrap up their season series in prime time on Sunday Night Baseball.

The pregame narrative: If these teams meet again, it’ll have to be in the World Series. The pair of 2024 division winners split the first two games of this series, and they enter Sunday with identical 23-16 records.

Check out my Phillies vs. Guardians prop bets for Sunday Night Baseball on May 11, featuring Kyle Schwarber and Bo Naylor.

Phillies vs. Guardians prop bets

Best Bet: Schwarber over 1.5 bases (+120)

Schwarber has been a leadoff hitter for most of his Phillies tenure, but he’s built like a heart-of-the-order slugger.

And since sliding into Philadelphia’s cleanup spot, Schwarber is really looking the part.

  • 1.030 OPS as the No. 4 hitter
  • 2+ bases in 11 of 25 games

The left-hitting Schwarber does particularly well against right-handed pitching, which is part of the calculus for this prop bet, too.

Throughout his career, his OPS against righties (.870) far exceeds his OPS against lefties (.758).

Schwarber will face Cleveland’s Luis Ortiz (2-3, 5.30 ERA), who has been giving up a ton of hard contact so far.

Ortiz ranks in the fifth percentile in average exit velocity (92.5 mph), per Baseball Savant, and the 8th percentile in barrel rate (13.2%).

On the offensive side, Schwarber ranks in the 94th percentile in average exit velo (93.8 mph) and the 78th percentile in barrel rate (13.3%).

Key Stat: Schwarber has gone over 1.5 bases in eight of his past 13 games, posting a .633 SLG in that span.

Embed: #113655

Best MLB picks

Naylor under 0.5 hits (-122): I tend not to dabble with this market when the under has odds this short, but I think Naylor is worth a fade with Zack Wheeler on the mound.

Wheeler has struck out Naylor in both previous plate appearances against him and is in quite a groove right now.

Over his past four starts (26.2 innings), Wheeler has a 12.8 K/9 and a .194 opponent batting average. If someone is going to break through against him, I just don’t expect it to be Naylor.

The Mississauga, Ontario native is batting .202 and has gone hitless in 12 of 26 starts.

Naylor’s poor results are backed by a .205 xBA. That ranks in the fifth percentile in MLB.

Phillies vs. Guardians prop picks made at 1:32 p.m. ET on 05/11/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets May 11: Jorge Polanco, Tony Gonsolin look to stay hot

MLB prop bets

There are four MLB games starting in the 4 p.m. ET window on Sunday, and I’ve got prop bets from three of them.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Jorge Polanco continues to enjoy an inexplicably successful start, and he’ll face a pitcher today that he’s tormented in the past. Elsewhere, Tony Gonsolin will face his biggest test of the early season on the road against the Arizona Diamondbacks.

See how I’m targeting Polanco, Gonsolin and Tyler O’Neill in my best MLB prop bets for May 11.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Polanco over 1.5 bases (+125)

If you haven’t been following the Seattle Mariners, you’re missing a truly shocking early-season surge from Polanco.

The 12th-year veteran, who has just one all-star appearance on his resume, is batting .327 with a 1.026 OPS through 30 games.

And his batted ball metrics — via Baseball Savant — back up those superb numbers:

  • 100th-percentile xBA (.350)
  • 98th-percentile xSLG (.622)
  • 88th-percentile barrel rate (15.4%)

Polanco has amassed 66 bases so far, which equates to 2.2 bases per game. He has cashed this bet in nine of his past 19 games (and in 12 of 30 overall).

The switch-hitting infielder is probably worth targeting regardless of which side of the plate he’s swinging from. But I’m particularly interested in backing him as a left-hitting player.

Against right-handed pitchers this year, Polanco is batting .337 with a 1.078 OPS. And he’s got an enticing matchup against Toronto RHP Jose Urena this afternoon.

Urena has allowed seven runs on 11 hits through 7.1 innings this year and has struggled to solve Polanco in the past.

Key stat: Polanco is 7-for-10 with a double against Urena.

More MLB picks

O’Neill under 0.5 hits (+137): The right-hitting O’Neill has a platoon advantage today, at least in theory, against Angels southpaw Tyler Anderson. But that hasn’t how things have played out so far this year.

  • O’Neill has an .889 career OPS vs. lefties and slashed .313/.430/.750 against them last year.
  • This year, though, he is just 2-for-22 (.091) vs. lefties with 11 strikeouts.

Anderson (2-0, 2.68 ERA) is off to a great start for L.A. this year, and right-hitting opponents haven’t seemed to figure him out. Righties are batting just .155 with a .497 OPS.

O’Neill, a Maple Ridge, BC native, is hitless in eight of his past 12 games. He’s batting just 4-for-40 in that span.

Given Anderson’s reverse splits and O’Neill’s recent slide, I’m a fan of fading the Baltimore outfielder at a decent price.

Gonsolin over 4.5 Ks (+115): Gonsolin missed all of last season recovering from Tommy John surgery, but he’s enjoyed a triumphant return in the early stages of 2025.

Through two outings, Gonsolin has 17 Ks in 11.0 innings. He generated a 42.7% whiff rate and a 37.7% chase rate in those starts, which would be in the upper tier of the league if extrapolated over a greater data set.

I don’t want to make too much out of a pair of starts, but I do see this as an enticing plus-money price for a pretty low strikeout total.

The Diamondbacks, who Gonsolin will face today, have the fourth-lowest K% in the majors (19.7). But their 21.4 K% in the past two weeks ranks 15th in MLB.

I don’t think this is as daunting of a matchup as it may seem on the surface. Especially since Gonsolin has 17 Ks against the current D-backs lineup already (28.3 K%).

MLB prop picks made at 11:32 a.m. ET on 05/11/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 11: Jorge Polanco, Tony Gonsolin look to stay hot

MLB prop bets

There are four MLB games starting in the 4 p.m. ET window on Sunday, and I’ve got prop bets from three of them.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Jorge Polanco continues to enjoy an inexplicably successful start, and he’ll face a pitcher today that he’s tormented in the past. Elsewhere, Tony Gonsolin will face his biggest test of the early season on the road against the Arizona Diamondbacks.

See how I’m targeting Polanco, Gonsolin and Tyler O’Neill in my best MLB prop bets for May 11.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Polanco over 1.5 bases (+130)

If you haven’t been following the Seattle Mariners, you’re missing a truly shocking early-season surge from Polanco.

The 12th-year veteran, who has just one all-star appearance on his resume, is batting .327 with a 1.026 OPS through 30 games.

And his batted ball metrics — via Baseball Savant — back up those superb numbers:

  • 100th-percentile xBA (.350)
  • 98th-percentile xSLG (.622)
  • 88th-percentile barrel rate (15.4%)

Polanco has amassed 66 bases so far, which equates to 2.2 bases per game. He has cashed this bet in nine of his past 19 games (and in 12 of 30 overall).

The switch-hitting infielder is probably worth targeting regardless of which side of the plate he’s swinging from. But I’m particularly interested in backing him as a left-hitting player.

Against right-handed pitchers this year, Polanco is batting .337 with a 1.078 OPS. And he’s got an enticing matchup against Toronto RHP Jose Urena this afternoon.

Urena has allowed seven runs on 11 hits through 7.1 innings this year and has struggled to solve Polanco in the past.

Key stat: Polanco is 7-for-10 with a double against Urena.

Embed: #113648

More MLB picks

O’Neill under 0.5 hits (+143): The right-hitting O’Neill has a platoon advantage today, at least in theory, against Angels southpaw Tyler Anderson. But that hasn’t how things have played out so far this year.

  • O’Neill has an .889 career OPS vs. lefties and slashed .313/.430/.750 against them last year.
  • This year, though, he is just 2-for-22 (.091) vs. lefties with 11 strikeouts.

Anderson (2-0, 2.68 ERA) is off to a great start for L.A. this year, and right-hitting opponents haven’t seemed to figure him out. Righties are batting just .155 with a .497 OPS.

O’Neill, a Maple Ridge, BC native, is hitless in eight of his past 12 games. He’s batting just 4-for-40 in that span.

Given Anderson’s reverse splits and O’Neill’s recent slide, I’m a fan of fading the Baltimore outfielder at a decent price.

Gonsolin over 4.5 Ks (+110): Gonsolin missed all of last season recovering from Tommy John surgery, but he’s enjoyed a triumphant return in the early stages of 2025.

Through two outings, Gonsolin has 17 Ks in 11.0 innings. He generated a 42.7% whiff rate and a 37.7% chase rate in those starts, which would be in the upper tier of the league if extrapolated over a greater data set.

I don’t want to make too much out of a pair of starts, but I do see this as an enticing plus-money price for a pretty low strikeout total.

The Diamondbacks, who Gonsolin will face today, have the fourth-lowest K% in the majors (19.7). But their 21.4 K% in the past two weeks ranks 15th in MLB.

I don’t think this is as daunting of a matchup as it may seem on the surface. Especially since Gonsolin has 17 Ks against the current D-backs lineup already (28.3 K%).

MLB prop picks made at 11:32 a.m. ET on 05/11/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Mariners prop pick May 10: Bet on Seattle’s Polanco to shine

Blue Jays picks

The Toronto Blue Jays go for their third consecutive win and a series win over the Seattle Mariners on Saturday.

The pregame narrative: Toronto’s bats are beginning to heat up. The team has scored 18 runs across its last three contests. A pitching duel between Bowden Francis and Logan Evans should invite offensive production from both teams.

I’m backing Jorge Polanco in my Blue Jays picks vs. the Mariners on May 10.

Blue Jays picks vs. Mariners

Best Bet: Polanco to record 1+ RBI (+185)

Polanco isn’t in the ideal spot in Seattle’s lineup to drive in runs, but that hasn’t stopped him from racking up RBI.

The middle infield hits second for the Mariners and is absolutely crushing it this season.

Polanco is batting .340 with a .680 SLG on the campaign. The advanced numbers, per Baseball Savant, paint an equally impressive picture:

  • 100th percentile expected batting average (.353)
  • 98th percentile expected SLG (.635)
  • 90th percentile barrel rate (16.1)
  • 95th percentile squared up rate (35.4)

These elite metrics are leading to extremely impressive results at the plate. Polanco is tied for 11th among all players in RBI (28).

J.P. Crawford is batting in front of Polanco, and he should be able to get on against Francis. Crawford is hitting .303 with a .404 on-base percentage against righties.

Bet on Polanco to deliver at juicy plus-money odds.

Key stat: Polanco has a RBI in three of his last five games and seven of his last 12.

Blue Jays picks vs. Mariners made at 2:31 p.m. ET on 05/10/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Mariners prop picks May 10: Bet on Seattle’s Polanco, Tellez to shine

Blue Jays picks

The Toronto Blue Jays go for their third consecutive win and a series win over the Seattle Mariners on Saturday.

The pregame narrative: Toronto’s bats are beginning to heat up. The team has scored 18 runs across its last three contests. A pitching duel between Bowden Francis and Logan Evans should invite offensive production from both teams.

I’m backing Jorge Polanco and Rowdy Tellez in my Blue Jays picks vs. the Mariners on May 10.

Blue Jays picks vs. Mariners

Best Bet: Polanco to record 1+ RBI (+180)

Polanco isn’t in the ideal spot in Seattle’s lineup to drive in runs, but that hasn’t stopped him from racking up RBI.

The middle infield hits second for the Mariners and is absolutely crushing it this season.

Polanco is batting .340 with a .680 SLG on the campaign. The advanced numbers, per Baseball Savant, paint an equally impressive picture:

  • 100th percentile expected batting average (.353)
  • 98th percentile expected SLG (.635)
  • 90th percentile barrel rate (16.1)
  • 95th percentile squared up rate (35.4)

These elite metrics are leading to extremely impressive results at the plate. Polanco is tied for 11th among all players in RBI (28).

J.P. Crawford is batting in front of Polanco, and he should be able to get on against Francis. Crawford is hitting .303 with a .404 on-base percentage against righties.

Bet on Polanco to deliver at juicy plus-money odds.

Key stat: Polanco has a RBI in three of his last five games and seven of his last 12.

Embed: #113630

Quick pick

Tellez to record 1+ hit (-118): These odds are certainly palatable when all that’s needed of Tellez is a hit.

The left-handed hitter isn’t having a banner year by any means. Tellez is batting an uninspiring .203 on the campaign.

He has been better as of late, however, hitting .318 across seven games in May.

Tellez should be able to reach base with a hit at least once against Francis. The Toronto righty enters Saturday’s game with a rough 5.66 ERA and an even more troubling 6.79 FIP.

Opposing batters are hitting to the tune of .282 against Francis this year.

Francis’ Baseball Savant page does a good job of summing up how dreadful he has been in 2025. He has a third percentile expected ERA (6.92) and expected batting average (.319).

Tellez took Francis deep in his lone at-bat against the righty. The sample size is small, but encouraging, for the ex-Blue Jay.

Blue Jays picks vs. Mariners made at 2:31 p.m. ET on 05/10/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 10: Back Goldschmidt, Machado and Henderson on Saturday

MLB prop bets

I’m backing a trio of big bats to do damage in today’s MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Manny Machado and Gunnar Henderson are heating up, and face a pair of struggling arms. Meanwhile, Paul Goldschmidt has been delivering for the New York Yankees and is playing in the most hitter-friendly park in baseball.

See how I’m backing them in my best MLB prop bets for May 10.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Goldschmidt over 1.5 bases (-125)

Filling the Juan Soto hole is impossible, but Goldschmidt has been as advertised and then some for the Yankees.

The first baseman is slashing an incredible .345/.395/.486 in his first year with New York. He has the fourth-best batting average in baseball, and this is a perfect matchup for him to hit for power.

  • Goldschmidt’s .501 xSLG, ranks in the 79th percentile, according to Baseball Savant.
  • He has three home runs in his last 10 games, clearing this line five times.
  • Sutter Health Park, where the Athletics play, is the second-most hitter-friendly park in baseball, according to Baseball Savant’s park factor.

Goldschmidt is going up against lefty JP Sears, who has had a solid season.

The lefty sports a 2.92 ERA but has struggled to miss bats, ranking in the 36th percentile for K rate and ninth percentile for Whiff rate.

Key stat: Goldschmidt is batting an absurd .581 against LHP this year with eight extra-base hits in 31 at-bats (1.032 SLG).

More MLB picks

Henderson over 1.5 bases (-134): This is a steep price to pay for a bases prop, but it’s worth it.

Henderson is heating up after a slow start to the season, batting .342 with a .605 SLG in his last 10 games. He’s cleared this mark in five of those contests and hit a home run and a triple in yesterday’s win over the Los Angeles Angels.

Tonight, he goes up against Jack Kochanowicz, who has been getting torched all season.

  • 5.79 ERA
  • .294 opponent BA
  • 1.7 HR/9
  • 79 ERA+

Kochanowicz has given up a home run in four straight starts and will turn the ball over to a bullpen with the second-highest ERA (6.99) in MLB.

Machado 1+ RBI (-120): This seems like incredible value on Machado, who is red hot, and going up against an awful pitcher in a hitter-friendly environment.

Machado is batting .319 this season and has a hit in nine straight games. He has six RBI in that span, batting behind Fernando Tatis and Luis Arraez, both of whom are getting aboard at or above a .333 clip.

Bradley Blalock gets the ball for the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field, and that’s good news for the San Diego Padres.

The righty has an 8.03 ERA after posting a 6.07 ERA last year.

MLB prop picks made at 11:42 a.m. ET on 05/10/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 10: Back Goldschmidt, Machado and Henderson on Saturday

MLB prop bets

I’m backing a trio of big bats to do damage in today’s MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Manny Machado and Gunnar Henderson are heating up, and face a pair of struggling arms. Meanwhile, Paul Goldschmidt has been delivering for the New York Yankees and is playing in the most hitter-friendly park in baseball.

See how I’m backing them in my best MLB prop bets for May 10.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Goldschmidt over 1.5 bases (-122)

Filling the Juan Soto hole is impossible, but Goldschmidt has been as advertised and then some for the Yankees.

The first baseman is slashing an incredible .345/.395/.486 in his first year with New York. He has the fourth-best batting average in baseball, and this is a perfect matchup for him to hit for power.

  • Goldschmidt’s .501 xSLG, ranks in the 79th percentile, according to Baseball Savant.
  • He has three home runs in his last 10 games, clearing this line five times.
  • Sutter Health Park, where the Athletics play, is the second-most hitter-friendly park in baseball, according to Baseball Savant’s park factor.

Goldschmidt is going up against lefty JP Sears, who has had a solid season.

The lefty sports a 2.92 ERA but has struggled to miss bats, ranking in the 36th percentile for K rate and ninth percentile for Whiff rate.

Key stat: Goldschmidt is batting an absurd .581 against LHP this year with eight extra-base hits in 31 at-bats (1.032 SLG).

Embed: #113621

More MLB picks

Henderson over 1.5 bases (-136): This is a steep price to pay for a bases prop, but it’s worth it.

Henderson is heating up after a slow start to the season, batting .342 with a .605 SLG in his last 10 games. He’s cleared this mark in five of those contests and hit a home run and a triple in yesterday’s win over the Los Angeles Angels.

Tonight, he goes up against Jack Kochanowicz, who has been getting torched all season.

  • 5.79 ERA
  • .294 opponent BA
  • 1.7 HR/9
  • 79 ERA+

Kochanowicz has given up a home run in four straight starts and will turn the ball over to a bullpen with the second-highest ERA (6.99) in MLB.

Machado 1+ RBI (-125): This seems like incredible value on Machado, who is red hot, and going up against an awful pitcher in a hitter-friendly environment.

Machado is batting .319 this season and has a hit in nine straight games. He has six RBI in that span, batting behind Fernando Tatis and Luis Arraez, both of whom are getting aboard at or above a .333 clip.

Bradley Blalock gets the ball for the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field, and that’s good news for the San Diego Padres.

The righty has an 8.03 ERA after posting a 6.07 ERA last year.

MLB prop picks made at 11:42 a.m. ET on 05/10/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 9: Back bats Ryan O’Hearn, Jacob Wilson and Spencer Torkelson

MLB prop bets

I have prop picks on four players for Friday’s busy slate, which sees all 30 MLB teams in action.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Detroit Tigers slugger Spencer Torkelson is on fire and looks like a terrific bet again tonight against the Texas Rangers. My other three targets all have good matchups, too.

The top MLB prop bets for May 9 feature a best bet on Torkelson and plays on Jacob Wilson, Ryan O’Hearn and Max Meyer.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Torkelson over 1.5 total bases (+100)

This is excellent value. And will still be playable throughout the day as the price likely moves.

Torkelson is hot, has been obliterating left-handers, and his Tigers face one of the most hittable southpaws in the game: Patrick Corbin. 

Let’s start with Torkelson…

  • His 10 home runs are tied for third in MLB.
  • Torkelson is top 10 in ISO (.297), and top 20 in slugging (.551) and wRC+ (151).
  • The Tiger has 21 extra-base hits, trailing only four players. 

Torkelson’s numbers are even better vs. lefties: .419 ISO, .698 SLG, 194 wRC+. 

He’s a power hitter in a plus matchup and has cleared this line in five of seven games this month. 

As for Corbin, his surface stats look good in his debut season with Texas. But he doesn’t miss bats (bottom-15 percentile in K rate) and has an expected ERA of 4.69 (1.40 higher than his actual mark). 

He’s also the guy who posted an ERA north of 5.00 in each of the last four seasons and couldn’t keep the ball in the yard. 

Corbin is someone I’m looking to fade in some capacity every outing, and backing Torkelson is one way I’m doing it tonight. 

Key stat: Torkelson has cleared 1.5 bases in 54.1% of his starts, the fifth-best mark in MLB.

Best MLB picks

Wilson over 0.5 runs (+115): Where Wilson hits will be key here, but I’m good getting in at this price vs. struggling New York Yankees right-hander Will Warren.

Wilson has only hit out of the leadoff spot five times this season. But three of them were this month, and one of them was the Athletics’ last contest. Rotowire projects him to bat leadoff again tonight.

Here’s what to like:

  • Wilson enters with a .357/.383/.476 batting line. In May, he’s hitting a sizzling .483/.545/.552.
  • If he hits leadoff, he’ll be in front of Brent Rooker, a dangerous power bat. And Tyler Soderstrom, who stopped hitting homers but has a .913 OPS vs. RHPs (lefties have an .849 OPS vs. Warren).
  • Sutter Health Park, the Athletics’ home stadium, has been the most hitter-friendly stadium in MLB this season (per Baseball Savant).

Warren has struggled with control and has a 7.07 ERA in four road starts. Wilson is batting .371 with a .926 OPS at home and has the lowest K rate in the American League.

The 23-year-old shortstop is a good bet to get on base tonight.

O’Hearn over 1.5 total bases (+125): The Baltimore Orioles are arguably the most disappointing team in baseball, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t stuff to like.

O’Hearn vs. a righty is one of them.

  • .308/.386/.603 with all seven of his homers.
  • O’Hearn’s career OPS is nearly 200 points higher vs. RHPs.

Los Angeles Angels starter Kyle Hendricks has a 5.28 ERA and misses bats at one of the lowest rates in MLB.

Hendricks has been a punching bag for the majority of the past five seasons and has allowed a homer in all but one start this year.

The veteran has the second-highest ERA in baseball since the start of 2024 (minimum 120 innings).

MLB prop bets: Today’s best pitcher prop

Meyer over 5.5 Ks (-143): Meyer’s last two outings might create pause (certainly his last one).

  • He went five innings and punched out a season-low zero batters, surrendering a season-high 10 hits.
  • That marked the second straight start he allowed five runs.
  • Before that, the Miami Marlins right-hander did this: Six scoreless innings in a 14-K performance.

He topped this line in three of four starts ahead of that dominant gem.

Meyer has 80th-percentile K and whiff rates and has been able to go deep, working into the sixth inning in five of seven outings.

All signs point to that happening against the Chicago White Sox. Chicago has the fourth-highest K rate in MLB and is 29th in wRC+.

MLB prop picks made at 1:30 p.m. ET on 05/09/2025

Best MLB prop bets May 9: Back bats Ryan O’Hearn, Jacob Wilson and Spencer Torkelson

MLB prop bets

I have prop picks on four players for Friday’s busy slate, which sees all 30 MLB teams in action.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Detroit Tigers slugger Spencer Torkelson is on fire and looks like a terrific bet again tonight against the Texas Rangers. My other three targets all have good matchups, too.

The top MLB prop bets for May 9 feature a best bet on Torkelson and plays on Jacob Wilson, Ryan O’Hearn and Max Meyer.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Torkelson over 1.5 total bases (-103)

This is excellent value. And will still be playable throughout the day as the price likely moves.

Torkelson is hot, has been obliterating left-handers, and his Tigers face one of the most hittable southpaws in the game: Patrick Corbin. 

Let’s start with Torkelson…

  • His 10 home runs are tied for third in MLB.
  • Torkelson is top 10 in ISO (.297), and top 20 in slugging (.551) and wRC+ (151).
  • The Tiger has 21 extra-base hits, trailing only four players. 

Torkelson’s numbers are even better vs. lefties: .419 ISO, .698 SLG, 194 wRC+. 

He’s a power hitter in a plus matchup and has cleared this line in five of seven games this month. 

As for Corbin, his surface stats look good in his debut season with Texas. But he doesn’t miss bats (bottom-15 percentile in K rate) and has an expected ERA of 4.69 (1.40 higher than his actual mark). 

He’s also the guy who posted an ERA north of 5.00 in each of the last four seasons and couldn’t keep the ball in the yard. 

Corbin is someone I’m looking to fade in some capacity every outing, and backing Torkelson is one way I’m doing it tonight. 

Key stat: Torkelson has cleared 1.5 bases in 54.1% of his starts, the fifth-best mark in MLB.

Embed: #113600

Best MLB picks

Wilson over 0.5 runs (+100): Where Wilson hits will be key here, but I’m good getting in at this price vs. struggling New York Yankees right-hander Will Warren.

Wilson has only hit out of the leadoff spot five times this season. But three of them were this month, and one of them was the Athletics’ last contest. Rotowire projects him to bat leadoff again tonight.

Here’s what to like:

  • Wilson enters with a .357/.383/.476 batting line. In May, he’s hitting a sizzling .483/.545/.552.
  • If he hits leadoff, he’ll be in front of Brent Rooker, a dangerous power bat. And Tyler Soderstrom, who stopped hitting homers but has a .913 OPS vs. RHPs (lefties have an .849 OPS vs. Warren).
  • Sutter Health Park, the Athletics’ home stadium, has been the most hitter-friendly stadium in MLB this season (per Baseball Savant).

Warren has struggled with control and has a 7.07 ERA in four road starts. Wilson is batting .371 with a .926 OPS at home and has the lowest K rate in the American League.

The 23-year-old shortstop is a good bet to get on base tonight.

O’Hearn over 1.5 total bases (+120): The Baltimore Orioles are arguably the most disappointing team in baseball, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t stuff to like.

O’Hearn vs. a righty is one of them.

  • .308/.386/.603 with all seven of his homers.
  • O’Hearn’s career OPS is nearly 200 points higher vs. RHPs.

Los Angeles Angels starter Kyle Hendricks has a 5.28 ERA and misses bats at one of the lowest rates in MLB.

Hendricks has been a punching bag for the majority of the past five seasons and has allowed a homer in all but one start this year.

The veteran has the second-highest ERA in baseball since the start of 2024 (minimum 120 innings).

MLB prop bets: Today’s best pitcher prop

Meyer over 5.5 Ks (-129): Meyer’s last two outings might create pause (certainly his last one).

  • He went five innings and punched out a season-low zero batters, surrendering a season-high 10 hits.
  • That marked the second straight start he allowed five runs.
  • Before that, the Miami Marlins right-hander did this: Six scoreless innings in a 14-K performance.

He topped this line in three of four starts ahead of that dominant gem.

Meyer has 80th-percentile K and whiff rates and has been able to go deep, working into the sixth inning in five of seven outings.

All signs point to that happening against the Chicago White Sox. Chicago has the fourth-highest K rate in MLB and is 29th in wRC+.

MLB prop picks made at 11:15 a.m. ET on 05/09/2025

Best MLB prop bets May 8: Bet on Yamamoto and Betts to star in Dodgers vs. Diamondbacks

MLB prop bets

There’s a handful of afternoon ballgames in MLB on Thursday, but my primary focus is on the nightcap between the Los Angeles Dodgers and Arizona Diamondbacks.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Yoshinobu Yamamoto looks to continue his glistening start to 2025 against Brandon Pfaadt and the D-backs. Yamamoto won both of his starts against Arizona a season ago.

In addition to Yamamoto, my best MLB prop bets for May 8 also feature plays on Freddie Freeman and Danny Jansen.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Jansen under 0.5 hits (+105)

Plenty of Blue Jays fans were surely sour when Jansen was traded at last year’s deadline, but the early returns from his post-Toronto days justify the move.

Between last year’s stint with the Red Sox and this year’s tenure with the Phillies, here’s what Jansen has put together offensively:

  • 54 games
  • .163 BA
  • .572 OPS
  • 74 wRC+
  • 17.3 BB%

The basement-level batting average and the sky-high walk rate both matter for a hits prop.

On one hand, Jansen isn’t generating a lot of quality contact when he puts bat to ball … and on the other hand, he’s content to keep the bat on his shoulder and simply take a free base.

Tonight, Jansen faces Phillies left-hander Jesus Luzardo, who is 3-0 with a 1.94 ERA through seven starts.

Luzardo, who is Peruvian-born but raised in Florida, has held opponents to a .219 BA when pitching on the road this year.

You might think the right-hitting Jansen would have a leg up on Luzardo in a lefty-on-righty matchup. But that isn’t true.

Jansen is just 2-for-25 (.080) against LHPs this season and has a career .197 BA against southpaws overall.

Key stat: Jansen ranks in the third percentile in xBA (.197), per Baseball Savant. He’s also in the bottom-15th percentile in xSLG (.335) and average exit velocity (86.6 mph).

Dodgers MLB picks

Betts over 0.5 runs (-110): How can you not like Betts to score at this price?

He bats in the No. 2 spot in the Dodgers’ order, with the hottest hitter in baseball — Freddie Freeman — right behind.

In his past 10 games, Freeman is batting .500 with seven extra-base hits and 17 RBI. I thought about just taking Freeman over 1.5 bases (-121), but Betts’ price to score is even better.

L.A. faces Arizona starter Brandon Pfaadt tonight, and there’s a lot of positive history there on the Dodgers’ side of things.

  • Betts has reached base in 6 of 13 plate appearances against Pfaadt (.462 OBP).
  • Freeman and L.A. cleanup hitter Will Smith are a combined 7-for-21 with four doubles and a home run vs. Pfaadt.

Oh, and Betts has scored in seven consecutive starts.

Yamamoto over 17.5 outs (-120): Yamamoto is off to a remarkable start in Year 2 with the Dodgers. Through seven outings, he owns the lowest ERA in the majors (0.90).

Without Shohei Ohtani, Tyler Glasnow or Blake Snell available to pitch right now, Yamamoto is the de facto ace of the squad. And the Dodgers aren’t treating the 26-year-old with kid gloves.

  • He’s averaging 17.1 outs and is 4-3 against this line.
  • Yamamoto has thrown 90+ pitches in six straight starts.

Last year, Yamamoto cashed this bet in both outings against the Diamondbacks, allowing two runs while striking out 13 batters over 12.1 innings.

He’s also catching the D-backs at a decent time. Over the past two weeks, the typically potent offence ranks 15th in runs and 18th in wRC+.

MLB prop picks made at 1:15 p.m. ET on 05/08/2025.