Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets May 14: Bet on Jacob Wilson and Jackson Merrill to rake

MLB prop bets

A trio of hitters stand out to me as logical MLB prop targets on Wednesday night.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Brandon Nimmo faces a familiar foe amid a hot streak and seems to have plenty of value to go over 1.5 bases. Elsewhere, Jackson Merrill and Jacob Wilson are off to exceptional starts in their respective second seasons.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 14.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Nimmo over 1.5 bases (+150)

Lefty-on-lefty matchups almost always favour the pitcher. But there’s a rare exception in this matchup between Nimmo and Pirates starter Bailey Falter.

  • Nimmo vs. LHPs: 10-for-34 (.294), 3 HR, .588 SLG
  • Falter vs. LHHs: 13-for-37 (.351), 2 HR, .541 SLG

Neither sample is massive, but the contrast is stark compared to how these players fare against righties.

That’s especially true for Falter, who has allowed a .945 OPS to left-hitting players this year and a .610 OPS to right-hitting players.

When facing lefties, Nimmo has done basically all his damage on fastballs. He’s 9-for-20 with a .950 SLG against fastballs from LHPs, per Baseball Savant.

Falter’s four-pitch mix includes sinkers and four-seamers, and he throws those pitches to lefties a combined 58.9% of the time.

If Nimmo is hunting fastballs, he’ll likely find something to put the barrel to.

We’ve seen it before, as Nimmo is 5-for-12 with a home run against Falter.

To me, this price is almost too good to be true for the Mets’ cleanup man.

Key stat: Nimmo has gone over 1.5 bases in three straight games and has a 1.007 OPS since April 28.

Embed: #113756

Best MLB picks

Wilson over 1.5 bases (+133): Wilson has a Luis-Arraez-like hitter’s profile. Despite a dearth of power, he’s finding success by guiding the bat through the zone on the proper plane.

Wilson is third from the bottom in MLB in bat speed, but he’s in the 97th percentile in xBA (.319) and the 100th percentile in squared-up rate.

He also rarely walks and rarely strikes out, which makes him a great candidate to clear a bases prop.

Among 159 qualified hitters, Wilson has the …

  • 2nd-lowest K%
  • 11th-lowest BB%

The 2023 sixth-overall pick can still run into one, by the way. He homered twice last night in a 4-for-5 performance against the Los Angeles Dodgers.

Wilson has cashed this bet in eight of his past 12 games. As the leadoff man on a road team tonight, he’ll have plenty of opportunities to get this done.

Merrill over 1.5 bases (-113): Merrill, the National League Rookie of the Year runner-up from a season ago, has picked up right where he left off.

Not even a four-week absence due to a hamstring injury could slow him down. The outfielder is 14-for-27 (.519) this month with four extra-base hits.

On the season, Merrill has a 1.183 OPS and has cashed this bet in 11 of 16 games.

Now he’ll face right-hander Kyle Hendricks with a platoon advantage. The left-hitting Merrill has a .561 SLG in 446 at-bats against righties.

Hendricks has a 6.93 ERA in his past five starts, allowing 34 baserunners and 19 runs in that span.

MLB prop picks made at 12:40 p.m. ET on 05/14/2025

Rays vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 14: Bet on Bo Bichette, Brandon Lowe to power up

Blue Jays picks

A high-scoring series opener didn’t go the Toronto Blue Jays’ way, but they’re back at it on Wednesday night against the Tampa Bay Rays.

The pregame narrative: Tampa scored five runs in the ninth to claw out an 11-9 victory at Rogers Centre on Tuesday. I expect a decent amount of offence tonight as well, despite the over/under being set at just 8 runs.

I’m backing Brandon Lowe and Bo Bichette to shine in my Blue Jays picks vs. the Rays on May 14.

Blue Jays picks vs. Rays

Best Bet: Lowe over 0.5 runs (+135)

Lowe’s 2025 season has been shaky to say the least. But I love this price for a guy who wields a platoon advantage and bats two spots ahead of the red-hot Jonathan Aranda (fifth in MLB with a .995 OPS).

As a left-hitting player, Lowe will have a leg up on Toronto right-hander Chris Bassitt.

  • Lowe has an .821 career OPS against righties.
  • Since 2023, lefty batsmen have posted a .284/.360/.492 slash line against Bassitt.
  • Furthermore, Bassitt has been touched up quite a bit in recent outings. In his past four starts, the veteran has allowed 16 runs on 28 hits (6.04 ERA) over 22.1 innings.

Head-to-head results aren’t everything, but they certainly don’t hurt in this case. Bassitt is reeling, and Lowe should be in a prime position to score from Tampa’s No. 2 spot.

Key stat: Against Bassitt, Lowe is 5-for-11 with three home runs, a double and a walk.

Quick pick

Bichette over 1.5 bases (+105): Bichette is in a rhythm right now, and a better-than-even-money price on multiple bases has my attention.

Check out what the shortstop has accomplished since April 29:

  • 16-for-55 (.291)
  • .545 SLG
  • 2+ bases in 8 of 13 games
  • 2.3 bases/game

Bichette’s .322 xBA ranks in the 98th percentile in MLB, and his .515 xSLG ranks in the 82nd percentile.

He has more doubles (13) than walks (12), so you know he’s up there to swing the bat.

Tampa Bay starter Ryan Pepiot has allowed a .494 SLG to opponents this year. And his xERA (4.43) is notably higher than his actual ERA (3.86).

Bichette has never faced Pepiot, but I’m not expecting this matchup to slow the Jays’ star down.

Rays vs. Blue Jays picks made at 11:21 a.m. ET on 05/14/2025.

Rays vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 14: Bet on Bo Bichette, Jonathan Aranda to power up

Blue Jays picks

A high-scoring series opener didn’t go the Toronto Blue Jays’ way, but they’re back at it on Wednesday night against the Tampa Bay Rays.

The pregame narrative: Tampa scored five runs in the ninth to claw out an 11-9 victory at Rogers Centre on Tuesday. I expect a decent amount of offence tonight as well, despite the over/under being set at just 8 runs.

I’m backing Jonathan Aranda, Brandon Lowe and Bo Bichette to shine in my Blue Jays picks vs. the Rays on May 14.

Blue Jays picks vs. Rays

Best Bet: Aranda over 1.5 bases (+123)

Aranda cashed this bet in the third inning last night, sending a 433-foot blast into the seats in right field at Rogers Centre.

I see plenty of reasons to go back to the well with Aranda, whose .996 OPS ranks fifth in MLB.

If you missed yesterday’s breakdown of this very same pick, here’s a quick summary: Aranda has some of the best bat-to-ball production in the majors so far, and he’s particularly lethal against right-handed pitching.

  • According to Baseball Savant, Aranda ranks in 95th percentile or better in xBA, xSLG, average exit velocity and hard-hit rate.
  • He has a .372/.444/.660 slash line vs. RHPs this season.
  • In his career, Aranda has an .820 OPS vs. RHPs and a .511 OPS vs. LHPs.

So far, Toronto righty Chris Bassitt has held Aranda (0-for-6, three Ks) in check. But that’s a tiny sample.

Bassitt’s numbers against left-hitting opponents are suspect. Since 2023, lefty batsmen have posted a .284/.360/.492 slash line against him.

Furthermore, Bassitt has been touched up quite a bit in recent outings. In his past four starts, the veteran has allowed 16 runs on 28 hits (6.04 ERA) over 22.1 innings.

Key stat: In 31 starts, Aranda has gone over 1.5 bases 16 times this season.

Embed: #113744

Quick pick

Lowe over 0.5 runs (+140): Lowe’s 2025 season has been shaky to say the least. But I love this price for a guy who wields a platoon advantage and bats two spots ahead of Aranda.

As a left-hitting player, Lowe will have the same leg up on Bassitt that Aranda does. Lowe has an .821 career OPS against righties.

Against Bassitt in particular, Lowe is 5-for-11 with three home runs, a double and a walk.

Head-to-head results aren’t everything, but they certainly don’t hurt in this case. Bassitt is reeling, and Lowe should be in a prime position to score from Tampa’s No. 2 spot.

Bichette over 1.5 bases (+105): Bichette is in a rhythm right now, and a better-than-even-money price on multiple bases has my attention.

Check out what the shortstop has accomplished since April 29:

  • 16-for-55 (.291)
  • .545 SLG
  • 2+ bases in 8 of 13 games
  • 2.3 bases/game

Bichette’s .322 xBA ranks in the 98th percentile in MLB, and his .515 xSLG ranks in the 82nd percentile.

He has more doubles (13) than walks (12), so you know he’s up there to swing the bat.

Tampa Bay starter Ryan Pepiot has allowed a .494 SLG to opponents this year. And his xERA (4.43) is notably higher than his actual ERA (3.86).

Bichette has never faced Pepiot, but I’m not expecting this matchup to slow the Jays’ star down.

Rays vs. Blue Jays picks made at 11:11 a.m. ET on 05/14/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets May 13: Back Arizona’s Pfaadt and Twins’ Buxton, Lewis

MLB prop bets

All 30 MLB teams are in action for Tuesday’s busy baseball slate.

Today’s MLB props narrative: The red-hot Minnesota Twins have won eight in a row to move over .500, and I like a pair of their players to deliver against the Baltimore Orioles tonight. I’m rounding out the night with a play on Arizona Diamondbacks starter Brandon Pfaadt.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 13, featuring picks on Byron Buxton and Royce Lewis.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Buxton over 0.5 runs (-106)

This is a great matchup for Twins hitters, particularly their right-handed batters.

Orioles starter Cade Povich has been punished by righty bats, and Rotowire projects Minnesota to stack its lineup exclusively of RHBs and switch-hitters.

Povich could be in for a long night. Righties are hitting .322/.371/.557 off the southpaw. He’s allowed seven homers, all of them to right-handers.

There are several props I’m interested in for this game. This looks like a great option to me, and it’s priced well. I have a longer-shot recommendation, too, but let’s start with Buxton.

  • Buxton is second in the American League in runs scored (30), trailing only Aaron Judge.
  • The outfielder has hit leadoff in seven straight contests, which is where he should be again vs. an Orioles team allowing an AL-worst 5.44 runs per game.
  • Buxton has gotten on base multiple times in seven of 10 May games.

The oft-injured 31-year-old has been hitting for solid power this season, but he’s been especially dynamic against lefties and is an excellent bet to get on base in a plus matchup.

Key stat: Buxton enters the night with a robust .346/.370/.692 mark vs. LHPs.

Best MLB picks

Lewis over 0.5 RBI (+180): Sticking with the Twins, this looks like strong value for the slumping Lewis.

Another injury-plagued Twin, Lewis missed all of April with a hamstring strain before a return in early May.

He proceeded to go hitless in five straight games to start the season before a two-hit game on Sunday.

The former No. 1 overall pick is likely a middle-of-the-order bat when clicking. It’s tough to say where he’ll bat tonight, but he has slotted seventh in four of his six games.

Higher up and directly behind Carlos Correa would be nice (1.119 OPS vs. LHPs), but Lewis should still find himself in run-producing situations if lower in the lineup.

I have little trust in Povich or Baltimore’s bullpen (5.05 ERA), and the right-handed hitting Lewis has well-above average power (career 124 wRC+, .222 ISO).

Pfaadt over 17.5 outs (-143): Pfaadt is off to a strong start, taking a 3.28 ERA and career-low walk rate into tonight’s outing vs. the San Francisco Giants.

The righty is 6-2 vs. this line and cleared it in 19 of 32 starts in last year’s sophomore season.

He runs into a Giants team that’s scuffling at the dish, producing below-average offence with the fifth-highest K rate in baseball over the last two weeks.

Some other reasons I’m bullish on the Arizona starter:

  • Pfaadt will get the Giants at pitcher-friendly Oracle Park in San Francisco.
  • Merrill Kelly, Pfaadt’s teammate, twirled seven innings with eight strikeouts vs. the Giants last night.
  • Kelly was the fourth straight righty to clear this line against San Francisco.

MLB prop picks made at 1:00 p.m. ET on 05/13/2025

Best MLB prop bets May 13: Back Arizona’s Pfaadt and Twins’ Buxton, Lewis

MLB prop bets

All 30 MLB teams are in action for Tuesday’s busy baseball slate.

Today’s MLB props narrative: The red-hot Minnesota Twins have won eight in a row to move over .500, and I like a pair of their players to deliver against the Baltimore Orioles tonight. I’m rounding out the night with a play on Arizona Diamondbacks starter Brandon Pfaadt.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 13, featuring picks on Byron Buxton and Royce Lewis.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Buxton over 0.5 runs (-112)

This is a great matchup for Twins hitters, particularly their right-handed batters.

Orioles starter Cade Povich has been punished by righty bats, and Rotowire projects Minnesota to stack its lineup exclusively of RHBs and switch-hitters.

Povich could be in for a long night. Righties are hitting .322/.371/.557 off the southpaw. He’s allowed seven homers, all of them to right-handers.

There are several props I’m interested in for this game. This looks like a great option to me, and it’s priced well. I have a longer-shot recommendation, too, but let’s start with Buxton.

  • Buxton is second in the American League in runs scored (30), trailing only Aaron Judge.
  • The outfielder has hit leadoff in seven straight contests, which is where he should be again vs. an Orioles team allowing an AL-worst 5.44 runs per game.
  • Buxton has gotten on base multiple times in seven of 10 May games.

The oft-injured 31-year-old has been hitting for solid power this season, but he’s been especially dynamic against lefties and is an excellent bet to get on base in a plus matchup.

Key stat: Buxton enters the night with a robust .346/.370/.692 mark vs. LHPs.

Embed: #113716

Best MLB picks

Lewis over 0.5 RBI (+175): Sticking with the Twins, this looks like strong value for the slumping Lewis.

Another injury-plagued Twin, Lewis missed all of April with a hamstring strain before a return in early May.

He proceeded to go hitless in five straight games to start the season before a two-hit game on Sunday.

The former No. 1 overall pick is likely a middle-of-the-order bat when clicking. It’s tough to say where he’ll bat tonight, but he has slotted seventh in four of his six games.

Higher up and directly behind Carlos Correa would be nice (1.119 OPS vs. LHPs), but Lewis should still find himself in run-producing situations if lower in the lineup.

I have little trust in Povich or Baltimore’s bullpen (5.05 ERA), and the right-handed hitting Lewis has well-above average power (career 124 wRC+, .222 ISO).

Pfaadt over 17.5 outs (-134): Pfaadt is off to a strong start, taking a 3.28 ERA and career-low walk rate into tonight’s outing vs. the San Francisco Giants.

The righty is 6-2 vs. this line and cleared it in 19 of 32 starts in last year’s sophomore season.

He runs into a Giants team that’s scuffling at the dish, producing below-average offence with the fifth-highest K rate in baseball over the last two weeks.

Some other reasons I’m bullish on the Arizona starter:

  • Pfaadt will get the Giants at pitcher-friendly Oracle Park in San Francisco.
  • Merrill Kelly, Pfaadt’s teammate, twirled seven innings with eight strikeouts vs. the Giants last night.
  • Kelly was the fourth straight righty to clear this line against San Francisco.

MLB prop picks made at 11:40 a.m. ET on 05/13/2025

Rays vs. Blue Jays best bet May 13: Fade Daulton Varsho at home

Blue Jays picks

The Toronto Blue Jays and Tampa Bay Rays open up their season series on Tuesday night at Rogers Centre.

The pregame narrative: Toronto lost three, then won three, then lost four. Now the Jays have won four in a row, and a win tonight would mark their longest win streak of the season. Last year, Toronto went 4-9 against Tampa Bay.

I’m backing fading Daulton Varsho in my Blue Jays best bet vs. the Rays on May 13.

Blue Jays best bet vs. Rays

Best Bet: Varsho under 0.5 hits (+105)

Varsho’s 2025 sample size is still quite small after he started the year on the injured list. But the early returns have been mixed at best.

The stocky outfielder is 6-for-31 (.194), going hitless in five of eight starts.

Varsho hasn’t had enough plate appearances to be a qualified hitter. But if he did, his .197 xBA would rank near the bottom of MLB, while his 22.2% barrel rate would rank near the top.

It’s an odd dichotomy, to say the least. But keep in mind that Varsho also isn’t putting the ball in play much. Half of his 36 PAs have resulted in a strikeout (15) or walk (three).

Facing Tampa Bay right-hander Shane Baz, the left-hitting Varsho should have a platoon advantage.

But Baz is holding LHHs to a .194 average this year, and Varsho is just a .215 hitter in his career against RHPs.

Key stat: Varsho is hitless in four of his past five games, going 3-for-21 in that span.

Rays vs. Blue Jays best bet made at 12:21 p.m. ET on 05/13/2025.

Rays vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 13: Ride with Aranda, fade Varsho

Blue Jays picks

The Toronto Blue Jays and Tampa Bay Rays open up their season series on Tuesday night at Rogers Centre.

The pregame narrative: Toronto lost three, then won three, then lost four. Now the Jays have won four in a row, and a win tonight would mark their longest win streak of the season. Last year, Toronto went 4-9 against Tampa Bay.

I’m backing Jonathan Aranda and fading Daulton Varsho in my Blue Jays picks vs. the Rays on May 13.

Blue Jays picks vs. Rays

Best Bet: Aranda over 1.5 bases (+128)

Hand up, I did not know who Aranda was when the season began.

As a former Baseball America top-100 prospect (pre-2023), though, he’s not a complete unknown in the baseball world. And he’s putting everybody on notice right now.

The 26-year-old infielder has a .342/.429/.553 slash line, good for the fifth-best OPS in the majors (.982).

Baseball Savant loves Aranda’s batted ball profile, too. He ranks in the 94th percentile or better in xBA, xSLG, average exit velocity and hard-hit rate.

Aranda is a severe splits guy, and he’ll have the platoon advantage tonight against Toronto right-hander Jose Berrios.

So far in his young career, Aranda’s OPS against righties (.814) is more than 300 points north of his OPS against lefties (.511).

Berrios shrugged off a rough season debut and has a 3.02 ERA since. But he hasn’t been dominant.

Opposing hitters are tagging plenty of Berrios’ offerings, evidenced by his 12.2% barrel rate (12th percentile in MLB) and 90.2 mph average exit velocity (34th percentile).

Aranda is 4-for-8 with two home runs against Berrios.

Key stat: In 30 starts, Aranda has gone over 1.5 bases 15 times this season.

Embed: #113704

Quick pick

Varsho under 0.5 hits (+110): Varsho’s 2025 sample size is still quite small after he started the year on the injured list. But the early returns have been mixed at best.

The stocky outfielder is 6-for-31 (.194), going hitless in five of eight starts.

Varsho hasn’t had enough plate appearances to be a qualified hitter. But if he did, his .197 xBA would rank near the bottom of MLB, while his 22.2% barrel rate would rank near the top.

It’s an odd dichotomy, to say the least. But keep in mind that Varsho also isn’t putting the ball in play much. Half of his 36 PAs have resulted in a strikeout (15) or walk (three).

Facing Tampa Bay right-hander Shane Baz, the left-hitting Varsho should have a platoon advantage.

But Baz is holding LHHs to a .194 average this year, and Varsho is just a .215 hitter in his career against RHPs.

Rays vs. Blue Jays picks made at 10:41 a.m. ET on 05/13/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets May 12: Back Aaron Judge and Michael King on Monday

MLB prop bets

Aaron Judge headlines Monday’s MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Judge is amid a herculean start to the season, and is coming off a four-hit game against the Athletics. The reigning AL MVP has an opportunity to do more damage against the Seattle Mariners and Emerson Hancock tonight.

See how I’m targeting Judge alongside Christian Walker in my best MLB prop bets for May 12.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Judge 1+ RBI (+110)

Judge is barreling toward the AL Triple Crown, leading MLB in batting average (.409), home runs (14), and RBI (39).

If that’s not enough to convince you, just take a look at his batted-ball metrics, courtesy of Baseball Savant:

  • 100th percentile barrel rate (25.0%)
  • 99th percentile average exit velocity (95.9 mph)
  • 97th percentile hard-hit rate (57.8%)

Judge’s 100th percentile xSLG (.785) is actually five points higher than his real slugging percentage (.779), so this hot start is nowhere near a fluke.

I looked long and hard at backing the two-time MVP to record multiple bases at -148.

That’s playable, considering he’s reached that threshold in an MLB-best 70.0% of his starts — 23% more than second-place Bobby Witt Jr.

But I’m value hunting, and will instead take him to record an RBI at plus money.

The New York Yankees go up against Hancock, who sports a 5.70 ERA through five starts. The righty ranks in the 16th percentile for xBA (.282), and I trust the bottom of New York’s order to get aboard for Judge.

Key stat: Judge has an RBI in eight of his last 13 games (13 total).

Another MLB pick

Walker over 1.5 bases (+110): Walker is on a heater after a horrible start to the season, and I want in.

  • First 19 games: .159 BA, .232 SLG, 2+ bases 4 times
  • Last 19 games: .288 BA, .507 SGL, 2+ bases 11 times

Walker is batting .317 in May, recording a hit in eight of nine games, with three going for extra bases.

Tonight, the Houston Astros face Michael Wacha and the Kansas City Royals, and that’s a pitcher Walker has dominated.

The veteran first baseman is 5-for-8 against Walker with two doubles and a home run.

MLB prop picks made at 1:21 p.m. ET on 05/12/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 12: Back Aaron Judge and Michael King on Monday

MLB prop bets

Aaron Judge headlines Monday’s MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Judge is amid a herculean start to the season, and is coming off a four-hit game against the Athletics. The reigning AL MVP has an opportunity to do more damage against the Seattle Mariners and Emerson Hancock tonight.

See how I’m targeting Judge alongside Christian Walker and Michael King in my best MLB prop bets for May 12.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Judge 1+ RBI (+112)

Judge is barreling toward the AL Triple Crown, leading MLB in batting average (.409), home runs (14), and RBI (39).

If that’s not enough to convince you, just take a look at his batted-ball metrics, courtesy of Baseball Savant:

  • 100th percentile barrel rate (25.0%)
  • 99th percentile average exit velocity (95.9 mph)
  • 97th percentile hard-hit rate (57.8%)

Judge’s 100th percentile xSLG (.785) is actually five points higher than his real slugging percentage (.779), so this hot start is nowhere near a fluke.

I looked long and hard at backing the two-time MVP to record multiple bases at -148.

That’s playable, considering he’s reached that threshold in an MLB-best 70.0% of his starts — 23% more than second-place Bobby Witt Jr.

But I’m value hunting, and will instead take him to record an RBI at plus money.

The New York Yankees go up against Hancock, who sports a 5.70 ERA through five starts. The righty ranks in the 16th percentile for xBA (.282), and I trust the bottom of New York’s order to get aboard for Judge.

Key stat: Judge has an RBI in eight of his last 13 games (13 total).

Embed: #113685

More MLB picks

Walker over 1.5 bases (+110): Walker is on a heater after a horrible start to the season, and I want in.

  • First 19 games: .159 BA, .232 SLG, 2+ bases 4 times
  • Last 19 games: .288 BA, .507 SGL, 2+ bases 11 times

Walker is batting .317 in May, recording a hit in eight of nine games, with three going for extra bases.

Tonight, the Houston Astros face Michael Wacha and the Kansas City Royals, and that’s a pitcher Walker has dominated.

The veteran first baseman is 5-for-8 against Walker with two doubles and a home run.

King over 18.5 outs (+130): New York is doing fine without Juan Soto, but I’m sure it would love to have King right now.

The righty has been lights out for the San Diego Padres since the trade and ranks top 15 in ERA (2.22) and WHIP (0.99) in 2025.

He’s only gone over 18.0 outs once this season, but flashed his workhorse-like ability throwing a complete game against the lowly Colorado Rockies.

Tonight’s opponent, the Los Angeles Angels, is another bottom-feeder.

L.A. has the second-worst batting average (.216) and highest K rate (27.0%) in MLB.

MLB prop picks made at 1:21 p.m. ET on 05/12/2025.

Phillies vs. Guardians Sunday Night Baseball prop bets: Kyle Schwarber looks to keep mashing from cleanup spot

Phillies vs. Guardians prop bets

The Philadelphia Phillies and Cleveland Guardians wrap up their season series in prime time on Sunday Night Baseball.

The pregame narrative: If these teams meet again, it’ll have to be in the World Series. The pair of 2024 division winners split the first two games of this series, and they enter Sunday with identical 23-16 records.

Check out my Phillies vs. Guardians prop bets for Sunday Night Baseball on May 11, featuring Kyle Schwarber and Bo Naylor.

Phillies vs. Guardians prop bets

Best Bet: Schwarber over 1.5 bases (+120)

Schwarber has been a leadoff hitter for most of his Phillies tenure, but he’s built like a heart-of-the-order slugger.

And since sliding into Philadelphia’s cleanup spot, Schwarber is really looking the part.

  • 1.030 OPS as the No. 4 hitter
  • 2+ bases in 11 of 25 games

The left-hitting Schwarber does particularly well against right-handed pitching, which is part of the calculus for this prop bet, too.

Throughout his career, his OPS against righties (.870) far exceeds his OPS against lefties (.758).

Schwarber will face Cleveland’s Luis Ortiz (2-3, 5.30 ERA), who has been giving up a ton of hard contact so far.

Ortiz ranks in the fifth percentile in average exit velocity (92.5 mph), per Baseball Savant, and the 8th percentile in barrel rate (13.2%).

On the offensive side, Schwarber ranks in the 94th percentile in average exit velo (93.8 mph) and the 78th percentile in barrel rate (13.3%).

Key Stat: Schwarber has gone over 1.5 bases in eight of his past 13 games, posting a .633 SLG in that span.

Best MLB picks

Naylor under 0.5 hits (-130): I tend not to dabble with this market when the under has odds this short, but I think Naylor is worth a fade with Zack Wheeler on the mound.

Wheeler has struck out Naylor in both previous plate appearances against him and is in quite a groove right now.

Over his past four starts (26.2 innings), Wheeler has a 12.8 K/9 and a .194 opponent batting average. If someone is going to break through against him, I just don’t expect it to be Naylor.

The Mississauga, Ontario native is batting .202 and has gone hitless in 12 of 26 starts.

Naylor’s poor results are backed by a .205 xBA. That ranks in the fifth percentile in MLB.

Phillies vs. Guardians prop picks made at 2:30 p.m. ET on 05/11/2025.