Category: MLB

Angels vs. Dodgers prop picks May 16: Ohtani should continue to rake amid epic hot streak

Angels vs. Dodgers prop picks

It’s an all-L.A. showdown on Friday as the Dodgers host the Angels for the first time this season.

The pregame narrative: Shohei Ohtani isn’t back on an MLB mound yet, but he’s doing plenty of MVP-calibre stuff at the plate. Led by Ohtani, the NL-best Dodgers have scored 51 runs in their past six games.

Check out my Angels vs. Dodgers prop picks for May 16, featuring Ohtani and Luis Rengifo.

Angels vs. Dodgers prop picks

Best Bet: Ohtani over 2.5 bases (-103)

Which players could possibly entice me to bet the over on 2.5 bases? Ohtani, Aaron Judge … end of list.

Not even getting plus money on this prop stings, but Ohtani has been that good in recent games.

Here’s what he’s accomplished since April 26:

  • .375 BA
  • .477 OBP
  • .931 SLG
  • 67 bases (3.7/game)

Surely this is a fluky hot streak, right? Actually, no.

In that 18-game span, Ohtani’s expected slash line — based on Baseball Savant’s batted-ball data — is .397/.479/.977.

Somehow, that’s better across the board.

Stepping in the line of fire tonight is Angels starter Jack Kochanowicz (2-5, 5.23 ERA), who has never had the misfortune of facing Ohtani. But I have an idea of how it might go.

Kochanowicz has allowed a .527 SLG against left-hitting players this year. He throws four-seamers, sinkers and sliders to lefties roughly 90% of the time.

Ohtani is slugging .643 or better against each of those pitch types this season.

Taking the over on a 2.5-base prop is difficult to stomach, but there are a ton of compelling reasons why I like it tonight.

Key stat: Ohtani has gone over 2.5 bases in 12 of his past 18 games.

Embed: #113858

Prop predictions

Rengifo under 0.5 hits (+108): The switch-hitting Rengifo hasn’t been productive from either side of the plate, batting .209 with a measly .533 OPS.

Now he faces right-hander Dustin May, who has held lefties to a .196 BA this year (18-for-92 with 22 Ks).

Rengifo doesn’t strike out or walk much, but his contact quality has been consistently poor.

  • He ranks in the 20th percentile or worse in barrel rate, xSLG, hard-hit rate and average exit velocity.
  • Rengifo is hitless in 7 of his past 10 games, posting a .118/.211/.147 slash line in that span.

May has dominated lefty hitters this year, and he’s held Rengifo hitless in two previous plate appearances.

Angels vs. Dodgers prop picks made at 2:10 p.m. ET on 05/16/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets May 16: Back Freddie Freeman, Josh Smith and CJ Abrams

MLB prop bets

Four players are featured in Friday’s best MLB prop picks.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Freddie Freeman is tearing the cover off the ball and I expect that to continue in a plus matchup vs. the Los Angeles Angels. I have other recommendations on two hot leadoff hitters, as well as one starting pitcher.

My favourite MLB prop bets for May 16 include plays on CJ Abrams, Josh Smith and Ranger Suarez.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Abrams over 1.5 total bases (+120)

Abrams is an obvious target against the Baltimore Orioles, who are starting left-hander Cade Povich. 

The southpaw has been hammered this season and particularly obliterated at his hitter-friendly home park. 

  • 5.55 ERA (7.94 at home)
  • 1.54 WHIP
  • Below-average 18.4 K%
  • Above-average 1.77 HR/9 rate

As for Abrams, he’s swinging a hot stick as the Washington Nationals’ leadoff man.

The switch-hitter fared better vs. lefties last season for the first time in three years. This season, he’s bashing all pitchers, slugging north of .540 against both left-handers and righties. 

Overall, Abrams is batting .317 with a .926 OPS.

Abrams has routinely been topping this line and the former first-round pick appears poised for a breakout in his age-24 season.

Key stat: The shortstop has cleared 1.5 bases in seven of his last eight games, and at the second-highest rate in the National League (per Team Rankings).

Best MLB picks

Freeman over 1.5 bases (-120): This price feels like a steal with the way Freeman is swinging it right now.

  • .440/.474/.780 in May with four home runs.
  • That comes after an April in which he had a 1.031 OPS. On the season, his 1.132 OPS is second only to Aaron Judge.
  • Freeman is hitting .389 and slugging .733 vs. right-handers and sees Angels RHP Jack Kochanowicz tonight.

Lefties have tattooed Kochanowicz, hitting .308/.379/.527. Six of the seven homers Kochanowicz has allowed have been to LHBs.

Following Kochanowicz will be an Angels bullpen that has the highest ERA (6.97) in MLB.

Smith over 0.5 runs (+100): The Texas Rangers’ utility man has been batting leadoff for much of the month, and he’s been delivering all season. 

Smith is hitting .306 with an .833 OPS, numbers that are elevated against RHPs. 

  • BA: .323
  • OBP: 394
  • OPS: .910 
  • All 4 of his HRs

Smith’s Rangers host Lance McCullers Jr. and the division rival Houston Astros. McCullers, who hadn’t pitched since 2022, is making his third start of the season. 

He has walked three batters in each start, allowing seven runs his last time out.

McCullers is understandably throwing with diminished velocity and his struggles to find the zone (which has plagued him before) make him hard to trust.

Smith has posted above-average walk rates throughout his four-year career. His ability to get on via his bat and eye sets him up well vs. McCullers.

On top of that, Smith has raked at home: .377/.441/.566.

Friday’s best MLB pitching prop

Suarez over 5.5 Ks (-112): The Philadelphia Phillies lefty missed all of April with back soreness following a career year in 2024. But he threw exceptionally well over four rehab assignments and now has two starts under his belt. 

After getting lit up in his season debut against a tough Arizona Diamondbacks lineup, Suarez dominated the Cleveland Guardians his last time out. 

He fanned six vs. Arizona and five against Cleveland, throwing 82 pitches both outings.

Assuming Suarez will be allowed to reach the 90-pitch range, this looks like an outing that he can work deep in and amass a good amount of strikeouts against a weak Pittsburgh Pirates lineup.

Pittsburgh has the third-highest K rate in MLB vs. southpaws, ranking 25th in wRC+. 

MLB prop picks made at 2:05 p.m. ET on 05/16/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 16: Back Freddie Freeman, Josh Smith and CJ Abrams

MLB prop bets

Four players are featured in Friday’s best MLB prop picks.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Freddie Freeman is tearing the cover off the ball and I expect that to continue in a plus matchup vs. the Los Angeles Angels. I have other recommendations on two hot leadoff hitters, as well as one starting pitcher.

My favourite MLB prop bets for May 16 include plays on CJ Abrams, Josh Smith and Ranger Suarez.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Abrams over 1.5 total bases (+118)

Abrams is an obvious target against the Baltimore Orioles, who are starting left-hander Cade Povich. 

The southpaw has been hammered this season and particularly obliterated at his hitter-friendly home park. 

  • 5.55 ERA (7.94 at home)
  • 1.54 WHIP
  • Below-average 18.4 K%
  • Above-average 1.77 HR/9 rate

As for Abrams, he’s swinging a hot stick as the Washington Nationals’ leadoff man.

The switch-hitter fared better vs. lefties last season for the first time in three years. This season, he’s bashing all pitchers, slugging north of .540 against both left-handers and righties. 

Overall, Abrams is batting .317 with a .926 OPS.

Abrams has routinely been topping this line and the former first-round pick appears poised for a breakout in his age-24 season.

Key stat: The shortstop has cleared 1.5 bases in seven of his last eight games, and at the second-highest rate in the National League (per Team Rankings).

Embed: #113859

Best MLB picks

Freeman over 1.5 bases (-107): This price feels like a steal with the way Freeman is swinging it right now.

  • .440/.474/.780 in May with four home runs.
  • That comes after an April in which he had a 1.031 OPS. On the season, his 1.132 OPS is second only to Aaron Judge.
  • Freeman is hitting .389 and slugging .733 vs. right-handers and sees Angels RHP Jack Kochanowicz tonight.

Lefties have tattooed Kochanowicz, hitting .308/.379/.527. Six of the seven homers Kochanowicz has allowed have been to LHBs.

Following Kochanowicz will be an Angels bullpen that has the highest ERA (6.97) in MLB.

Smith over 0.5 runs (-112): The Texas Rangers’ utility man has been batting leadoff for much of the month, and he’s been delivering all season. 

Smith is hitting .306 with an .833 OPS, numbers that are elevated against RHPs. 

  • BA: .323
  • OBP: 394
  • OPS: .910 
  • All 4 of his HRs

Smith’s Rangers host Lance McCullers Jr. and the division rival Houston Astros. McCullers, who hadn’t pitched since 2022, is making his third start of the season. 

He has walked three batters in each start, allowing seven runs his last time out.

McCullers is understandably throwing with diminished velocity and his struggles to find the zone (which has plagued him before) make him hard to trust.

Smith has posted above-average walk rates throughout his four-year career. His ability to get on via his bat and eye sets him up well vs. McCullers.

On top of that, Smith has raked at home: .377/.441/.566.

Friday’s best MLB pitching prop

Suarez over 5.5 Ks (-114): The Philadelphia Phillies lefty missed all of April with back soreness following a career year in 2024. But he threw exceptionally well over four rehab assignments and now has two starts under his belt. 

After getting lit up in his season debut against a tough Arizona Diamondbacks lineup, Suarez dominated the Cleveland Guardians his last time out. 

He fanned six vs. Arizona and five against Cleveland, throwing 82 pitches both outings.

Assuming Suarez will be allowed to reach the 90-pitch range, this looks like an outing that he can work deep in and amass a good amount of strikeouts against a weak Pittsburgh Pirates lineup.

Pittsburgh has the third-highest K rate in MLB vs. southpaws, ranking 25th in wRC+. 

MLB prop picks made at 1 p.m. ET on 05/16/2025.

Juan Soto props for superstar’s return to Yankee Stadium: Bet on Mets outfielder to score in Bronx

Juan Soto props

After one magical year with the New York Yankees, Juan Soto returns to the Bronx on Friday night for the first time as a member of the crosstown Mets.

The pregame narrative: Soto was the second runner-up in AL MVP voting last year, and he posted a 1.101 OPS in 14 playoff games to help the Yankees reach the World Series. He’s on an all-star-calibre pace with his new club, but the Yankees — No. 2 in MLB in runs per game — are doing fine without him.

Check out these Juan Soto props for the May 16 matchup against the Yankees.

Juan Soto props vs. Yankees

Soto marketsBetting odds
Over 0.5 hits-180
Under 0.5 hits+138
Over 1.5 bases+130
Under 1.5 bases-182
Over 0.5 runs-115
Under 0.5 runs-118
To record an RBI+170
To hit a double+440
To hit a home run +335

Juan Soto prop odds as of 11:15 a.m. ET on 05/16/2025.

Best Soto prop bet

Best Bet: Over 0.5 runs (-115)

Embed: #113851

At +130, Soto over 1.5 bases is a tempting proposition. But his 98th-percentile walk rate (17.2%), per Baseball Savant, gives me pause.

I expect Soto to find his way on base one way or another, which is why his runs prop is where I’ve chosen to land for my best bet.

  • Soto, last year’s AL runs leader (128), has 1+ runs in 24 of 43 games. That’s a 55.8% success rate, which exceeds the 53.5% implied probability of this prop.
  • In May, Soto is 8-4 against this prop while posting a 1.077 OPS.

Soto hasn’t powered up as much as usual this year. His .465 SLG is tracking to be the second-lowest of his eight-year career. That still ranks 50th among 166 qualified hitters, though.

And Soto’s batted-ball quality suggests greater things are coming.

According to Baseball Savant, his xSLG is .616. That 151-point discrepancy is tied for the sixth-largest in the majors.

So when he’s not drawing walks, Soto is plenty capable of swinging his way into scoring position.

On Friday, he’ll face Carlos Rodon in a lefty-on-lefty matchup. That wouldn’t be ideal for most hitters … but Soto isn’t most hitters.

In 271 plate appearances vs. LHPs since the start of last season, Soto has a .290/.428/.542 slash line (176 wRC+). He is, simply, matchup-proof.

Key stat: Soto has reached base at least twice in nine of 12 games this month.

Tigers vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 16: Look for Detroit’s Greene to get to Francis

Blue Jays picks

The American League-leading Detroit Tigers are in Toronto on Friday night to face the Blue Jays at Rogers Centre.

The pregame narrative: Bowden Francis (2-5, 5.40 ERA) worked a quality start in his most recent outing, but it’ll likely be an uphill battle tonight against a Tigers team that is 15-5 in its past 20 games.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. the Tigers on May 16, featuring Francis, Jack Flaherty and Riley Greene.

Blue Jays picks vs. Tigers

Best Bet: Flaherty over 15.5 outs (-120)

The Tigers are one of the best early-season stories in baseball, as they’ve built off an unlikely postseason run from last year and currently own MLB’s best record (tied with the Dodgers).

Flaherty, who began 2024 with Detroit before getting traded, hasn’t done much to help the team the second time around.

In fact, he’s 0-5 in his past five starts, allowing 19 runs on 28 hits in that span (6.66 ERA).

This might seem like a good spot to fade him, but I’m going to zag because Flaherty is still seeing a decent innings workload despite his struggles.

  • He’s pitched into the sixth inning or deeper in 6 of 8 starts.
  • He’s averaging 15.4 outs per start.

In 18 starts with the Tigers last year (prior to the deadline deal to L.A.), Flaherty averaged 17.8 outs and went 15-3 against this prop line.

When he’s in a groove, I know Tigers manager A.J. Hinch trusts him to eat innings.

Toronto’s offence has been fine — 13th in wRC+ (101), 22nd in runs per game (3.98) — but not overpowering.

And though Detroit was off yesterday, its two best relievers had thrown on back-to-back days before that. Some length from Flaherty would be welcomed, and I think the Tigers will get it.

Key stat: Flaherty has held Toronto’s active lineup to 10-for-57 (.175) hitting with a .298 SLG and 20 Ks.

Embed: #113839

Quick pick

Greene over 1.5 bases (+100): Greene is red hot right now, and he’ll have a platoon advantage against a struggling pitcher on Friday night.

  • In his past 19 games, Greene has averaged 2.6 bases while posting a .342/.400/.671 slash line.
  • Greene, who bats from the left side, has a .921 OPS vs. right-handed pitchers this year.
  • Toronto’s Francis has allowed 28 hits and a .663 SLG in his past four starts (18.2 innings).

Greene’s weakness is that he’s a relatively high strikeout guy, with a 19th-percentile K rate, per Baseball Savant.

But Francis only has a 19th-percentile K rate as a pitcher — to go with a fifth-percentile xBA and xERA — so I’m not worried about him mowing Greene down.

Francis under 16.5 outs (-112): Francis is 4-4 against this outs prop, and I’ll gladly lean on the side of the under in a matchup like this.

Detroit is likely to deploy five or six lefties in its lineup tonight, creating plenty of mismatches for the struggling Francis.

Handedness isn’t a trump card in its own right, but keep in mind that the Tigers have wielded a superb offence so far this season. They rank third in runs per game (5.55) and wRC+ (117).

Francis has a 6.25 xERA while allowing a .311 xBA. He’s also in the 20th percentile or worse in K rate, chase rate, hard-hit rate, barrel rate and ground-ball rate. Woof.

Not a single Jays reliever has pitched on back-to-back days entering Friday, so there should be ample options to look to if Detroit starts roughing up Francis.

Tigers vs. Blue Jays picks made at 9:30 a.m. ET on 05/16/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 15: Fade Hunter Brown, bet on Freddie Freeman to continue mashing

MLB prop bets

There are only two night games on Thursday, but I’ve got three MLB prop bets to cover the action.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Hunter Brown and Jacob deGrom meet up in the Lone Star State for what should be a pitcher’s duel, but Brown has had so-so results against Texas in the past. Later on, Freddie Freeman looks to continue mashing against a pitcher with mediocre-at-best stuff.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 15, featuring Wyatt Langford.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Langford over 0.5 runs (+125)

There were some bumps in the road during Langford’s rookie season, but he still turned in a 111 OPS+ season thanks to a stellar final month.

The 2023 fourth-overall draftee has built on that nicely, posting a .262/.349/.500 slash line (142 OPS+) so far in Year 2.

From the No. 2 spot in the Rangers’ lineup, Langford has the power, patience and speed to be a constant threat to score (rankings via Baseball Savant):

  • 81st-percentile xSLG
  • 76th-percentile walk rate
  • 90th-percentile sprint speed

Astros starter Hunter Brown (6-1, 1.48 ERA) is on a tear, and that doesn’t help our cause. But if anyone on the Rangers is going to break through, I’m expecting it to be Langford.

Especially since there are a couple of hitters behind Langford who’ve succeeded against Brown in the past.

Adolis Garcia and Marcus Semien, who bat fourth and fifth for the Rangers, are 17-for-34 (.500) with two home runs and a double vs. Brown.

Key stat: Langford has scored six runs in his past five games and cashed this bet in six of his past 10.

Best MLB picks

Brown under 6.5 Ks (-138): It’s really tough to fade Brown based on the run he’s enjoying right now. But I think the buck stops here.

Brown has tallied nine strikeouts in four consecutive outings and is averaging 7.3 Ks per start so far.

But now he’s facing a Rangers squad that has been impressively stingy in the strikeout department — especially against Brown.

  • Texas’ active lineup only has 15 Ks in 99 plate appearances vs. Brown (15.2 K%).
  • Over the past two weeks, the Rangers have the third-lowest K rate in MLB (19.1%).

Brown went under 6.5 Ks in all three starts against Texas last season. He’s 13-8 to this under in 21 road starts since the beginning of 2024.

Freeman over 1.5 bases (-106): One of the many things to love about Freeman’s start to the season is that he’s mashing everything. No pitch group is spared.

  • Fastballs: .409 BA, .727 SLG
  • Breaking: .278 BA, .694 SLG
  • Off-speed: .400 BA, .700 SLG

How do you attack this guy? I haven’t figured that out, nor have most MLB pitchers.

Athletics righty Osvaldo Bido will try his hand tonight. He’s had a rough go in his past four outings, allowing a collective .286/.344/.631 slash line to opposing hitters.

Bido throws all three fastball types to lefties a combined 60.7% of the time. LHHs are batting .302 with a .558 SLG against those offerings.

Freeman has proven he can hit anything, but fastballs seem to be the preferred choice. He’s gone over 1.5 bases in 17 of 32 games so far this year.

MLB prop picks made at 2:30 p.m. ET on 05/15/2025

Best MLB prop bets May 15: Fade Hunter Brown, bet on Freddie Freeman to continue mashing

MLB prop bets

There are only two night games on Thursday, but I’ve got three MLB prop bets to cover the action.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Hunter Brown and Jacob deGrom meet up in the Lone Star State for what should be a pitcher’s duel, but Brown has had so-so results against Texas in the past. Later on, Freddie Freeman looks to continue mashing against a pitcher with mediocre-at-best stuff.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 15, featuring Wyatt Langford.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Langford over 0.5 runs (+112)

There were some bumps in the road during Langford’s rookie season, but he still turned in a 111 OPS+ season thanks to a stellar final month.

The 2023 fourth-overall draftee has built on that nicely, posting a .262/.349/.500 slash line (142 OPS+) so far in Year 2.

From the No. 2 spot in the Rangers’ lineup, Langford has the power, patience and speed to be a constant threat to score (rankings via Baseball Savant):

  • 81st-percentile xSLG
  • 76th-percentile walk rate
  • 90th-percentile sprint speed

Astros starter Hunter Brown (6-1, 1.48 ERA) is on a tear, and that doesn’t help our cause. But if anyone on the Rangers is going to break through, I’m expecting it to be Langford.

Especially since there are a couple of hitters behind Langford who’ve succeeded against Brown in the past.

Adolis Garcia and Marcus Semien, who bat fourth and fifth for the Rangers, are 17-for-34 (.500) with two home runs and a double vs. Brown.

Key stat: Langford has scored six runs in his past five games and cashed this bet in six of his past 10.

Embed: #113790

Best MLB picks

Brown under 6.5 Ks (-132): It’s really tough to fade Brown based on the run he’s enjoying right now. But I think the buck stops here.

Brown has tallied nine strikeouts in four consecutive outings and is averaging 7.3 Ks per start so far.

But now he’s facing a Rangers squad that has been impressively stingy in the strikeout department — especially against Brown.

  • Texas’ active lineup only has 15 Ks in 99 plate appearances vs. Brown (15.2 K%).
  • Over the past two weeks, the Rangers have the third-lowest K rate in MLB (19.1%).

Brown went under 6.5 Ks in all three starts against Texas last season. He’s 13-8 to this under in 21 road starts since the beginning of 2024.

Freeman over 1.5 bases (+102): One of the many things to love about Freeman’s start to the season is that he’s mashing everything. No pitch group is spared.

  • Fastballs: .409 BA, .727 SLG
  • Breaking: .278 BA, .694 SLG
  • Off-speed: .400 BA, .700 SLG

How do you attack this guy? I haven’t figured that out, nor have most MLB pitchers.

Athletics righty Osvaldo Bido will try his hand tonight. He’s had a rough go in his past four outings, allowing a collective .286/.344/.631 slash line to opposing hitters.

Bido throws all three fastball types to lefties a combined 60.7% of the time. LHHs are batting .302 with a .558 SLG against those offerings.

Freeman has proven he can hit anything, but fastballs seem to be the preferred choice. He’s gone over 1.5 bases in 17 of 32 games so far this year.

MLB prop picks made at 12:40 p.m. ET on 05/15/2025

Rays vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 15: Bet on Guerrero, Varsho and Gausman in series finale

Blue Jays picks

Kevin Gausman and the Toronto Blue Jays host the Tampa Bay Rays on Thursday for an afternoon rubber match.

The pregame narrative: After a ninth-inning meltdown on Tuesday night, Toronto responded last night with a low-scoring win. Gausman is 2-0 with a 2.00 ERA in three outings so far at Rogers Centre this year.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. the Rays on May 15, featuring Gausman, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Daulton Varsho.

Blue Jays picks vs. Rays

Best Bet: Gausman over 5.5 Ks (-138)

Two seasons ago, Gausman led the American League with 237 strikeouts. That marked his fifth consecutive season with a 10.0 K/9 or better.

Are we ever going to see that guy again? I’m not sure. But he still has the stuff to go over 5.5 Ks when the matchup is right.

That’s what I’m seeing here, as Gausman faces a strikeout-happy Rays squad.

  • There are 19 MLB players with a K rate of 30.0% or higher (minimum 100 plate appearances). Three of them — Christopher Morel, Jose Caballero, Kameron Misner — are on the Rays.
  • Tampa Bay has the 8th-highest K% vs. right-handed pitchers this season (23.3).

Gausman only has 40 Ks through 45.1 innings, which equates to a 7.9 K/9. That’d be his lowest since 2018.

But he cashed this bet in both starts against the Rays last year, during a season in which he had an 8.0 K/9. Opponents matter a lot when it comes to strikeout props.

Gausman is 4-2 against this prop in his past six starts, averaging exactly 6.0 Ks in those outings.

I think the price of this prop is fair, especially given the matchup.

Key stat: In the past two weeks, Tampa Bay has the fifth-highest K rate in MLB (24.3%).

Quick pick

Guerrero over 0.5 runs (-106): Jays fans are still waiting for a sustained power surge from Guerrero. But in the meantime, he’s finding ways on base and scoring at an impressive rate.

  • Guerrero has 1+ runs in 7 of his past 8 games.
  • Dating back to April 23, Guerrero has a .309/.400/.471 slash line, scoring 15 runs in 18 games.

The first baseman only has two extra-base hits in his past 11 games. That’s not exactly what you’d want to spend $500 million on.

But Guerrero has reached base 22 times in those 11 games. So he’s giving himself plenty of opportunities to come around.

Guerrero is 3-for-5 with two walks against Rays starter Zack Littell.

Varsho over 1.5 hits/runs/RBI (-106): I bet on Varsho to go hitless two nights ago. Instead, he homered twice.

Varsho can be a bit boom-or-bust, but today’s matchup is one worth buying in on.

  • So far this season, Varsho has five home runs and a .781 SLG versus RHPs (32 at-bats).
  • Against Littell, Varsho is 4-for-9 (.444) with a homer and a double.

The sample is still quite small, but Varsho has already made a habit of tattooing the baseball. He’s among the league’s elite class in xSLG (.592), average exit velocity (95.6 mph) and hard-hit rate (57.1%).

Rays vs. Blue Jays picks made at 9:10 a.m. ET on 05/15/2025.

Rays vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 15: Bet on Guerrero, Varsho and Gausman in series finale

Blue Jays picks

Kevin Gausman and the Toronto Blue Jays host the Tampa Bay Rays on Thursday for an afternoon rubber match.

The pregame narrative: After a ninth-inning meltdown on Tuesday night, Toronto responded last night with a low-scoring win. Gausman is 2-0 with a 2.00 ERA in three outings so far at Rogers Centre this year.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. the Rays on May 15, featuring Gausman, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Daulton Varsho.

Blue Jays picks vs. Rays

Best Bet: Gausman over 5.5 Ks (-114)

Two seasons ago, Gausman led the American League with 237 strikeouts. That marked his fifth consecutive season with a 10.0 K/9 or better.

Are we ever going to see that guy again? I’m not sure. But he still has the stuff to go over 5.5 Ks when the matchup is right.

That’s what I’m seeing here, as Gausman faces a strikeout-happy Rays squad.

  • There are 19 MLB players with a K rate of 30.0% or higher (minimum 100 plate appearances). Three of them — Christopher Morel, Jose Caballero, Kameron Misner — are on the Rays.
  • Tampa Bay has the 8th-highest K% vs. right-handed pitchers this season (23.3).

Gausman only has 40 Ks through 45.1 innings, which equates to a 7.9 K/9. That’d be his lowest since 2018.

But he cashed this bet in both starts against the Rays last year, during a season in which he had an 8.0 K/9. Opponents matter a lot when it comes to strikeout props.

Gausman is 4-2 against this prop in his past six starts, averaging exactly 6.0 Ks in those outings.

I think the price of this prop is fair, especially given the matchup.

Key stat: In the past two weeks, Tampa Bay has the fifth-highest K rate in MLB (24.3%).

Embed: #113778

Quick pick

Guerrero over 0.5 runs (-115): Jays fans are still waiting for a sustained power surge from Guerrero. But in the meantime, he’s finding ways on base and scoring at an impressive rate.

  • Guerrero has 1+ runs in 7 of his past 8 games.
  • Dating back to April 23, Guerrero has a .309/.400/.471 slash line, scoring 15 runs in 18 games.

The first baseman only has two extra-base hits in his past 11 games. That’s not exactly what you’d want to spend $500 million on.

But Guerrero has reached base 22 times in those 11 games. So he’s giving himself plenty of opportunities to come around.

Guerrero is 3-for-5 with two walks against Rays starter Zack Littell.

Varsho over 1.5 bases (+125): I bet on Varsho to go hitless two nights ago. Instead, he homered twice.

Varsho can be a bit boom-or-bust, but today’s matchup is one worth buying in on.

  • So far this season, Varsho has five home runs and a .781 SLG versus RHPs (32 at-bats).
  • Against Littell, Varsho is 4-for-9 (.444) with a homer and a double.

The sample is still quite small, but Varsho has already made a habit of tattooing the baseball. He’s among the league’s elite class in xSLG (.592), average exit velocity (95.6 mph) and hard-hit rate (57.1%).

Rays vs. Blue Jays picks made at 9:10 a.m. ET on 05/15/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets May 14: Bet on Jacob Wilson and Jackson Merrill to rake

MLB prop bets

A trio of hitters stand out to me as logical MLB prop targets on Wednesday night.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Brandon Nimmo faces a familiar foe amid a hot streak and seems to have plenty of value to go over 1.5 bases. Elsewhere, Jackson Merrill and Jacob Wilson are off to exceptional starts in their respective second seasons.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 14.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Nimmo over 1.5 bases (+137)

Lefty-on-lefty matchups almost always favour the pitcher. But there’s a rare exception in this matchup between Nimmo and Pirates starter Bailey Falter.

  • Nimmo vs. LHPs: 10-for-34 (.294), 3 HR, .588 SLG
  • Falter vs. LHHs: 13-for-37 (.351), 2 HR, .541 SLG

Neither sample is massive, but the contrast is stark compared to how these players fare against righties.

That’s especially true for Falter, who has allowed a .945 OPS to left-hitting players this year and a .610 OPS to right-hitting players.

When facing lefties, Nimmo has done basically all his damage on fastballs. He’s 9-for-20 with a .950 SLG against fastballs from LHPs, per Baseball Savant.

Falter’s four-pitch mix includes sinkers and four-seamers, and he throws those pitches to lefties a combined 58.9% of the time.

If Nimmo is hunting fastballs, he’ll likely find something to put the barrel to.

We’ve seen it before, as Nimmo is 5-for-12 with a home run against Falter.

To me, this price is almost too good to be true for the Mets’ cleanup man.

Key stat: Nimmo has gone over 1.5 bases in three straight games and has a 1.007 OPS since April 28.

Best MLB picks

Wilson over 1.5 bases (+130): Wilson has a Luis-Arraez-like hitter’s profile. Despite a dearth of power, he’s finding success by guiding the bat through the zone on the proper plane.

Wilson is third from the bottom in MLB in bat speed, but he’s in the 97th percentile in xBA (.319) and the 100th percentile in squared-up rate.

He also rarely walks and rarely strikes out, which makes him a great candidate to clear a bases prop.

Among 159 qualified hitters, Wilson has the …

  • 2nd-lowest K%
  • 11th-lowest BB%

The 2023 sixth-overall pick can still run into one, by the way. He homered twice last night in a 4-for-5 performance against the Los Angeles Dodgers.

Wilson has cashed this bet in eight of his past 12 games. As the leadoff man on a road team tonight, he’ll have plenty of opportunities to get this done.

Merrill over 1.5 bases (-134): Merrill, the National League Rookie of the Year runner-up from a season ago, has picked up right where he left off.

Not even a four-week absence due to a hamstring injury could slow him down. The outfielder is 14-for-27 (.519) this month with four extra-base hits.

On the season, Merrill has a 1.183 OPS and has cashed this bet in 11 of 16 games.

Now he’ll face right-hander Kyle Hendricks with a platoon advantage. The left-hitting Merrill has a .561 SLG in 446 at-bats against righties.

Hendricks has a 6.93 ERA in his past five starts, allowing 34 baserunners and 19 runs in that span.

MLB prop picks made at 1:20 p.m. ET on 05/14/2025