Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets May 20: Bet on Trea Turner to pile up hits vs. Rockies

MLB prop bets

Trea Turner is the headliner of Tuesday’s MLB prop bets, featured alongside one lesser-known player.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Turner has the benefit of playing in the offensive haven of Coors Field tonight, which is a great spot to keep a hot streak rolling.

Check out my MLB prop bets for May 20, which also includes a prediction on Ivan Herrera.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Turner over 1.5 hits (+115)

In a vacuum, this is a pretty tough price to pay for a multi-hit performance. But the ingredients are all there for Turner tonight.

  • He’s swinging a hot stick, batting .368 over his past 20 games. Turner has 11 multi-hit games in that span.
  • Rockies starter Antonio Senzatela (1-7, 6.39 ERA) has really been going through it. He’s allowing 8.2 hits per start this year.
  • Technically, Senzatela has a platoon advantage in this righty-on-righty matchup. But he has allowed a .366 BA and 1.073 OPS to right-hitting opponents this year, so … the advantage definitely falls to Turner.

Turner is 7-for-15 with a double against Senzatela.

Also, Turner has a 36th-percentile walk rate (7.0%), so I’m not super worried about him foiling this pick with any free passes.

Key stat: In eight pro outings this year (six at the Triple-A level), Henderson has 5+ Ks in all eight games and 6+ Ks in six games.

Best MLB picks

Herrera over 0.5 hits (-154): The sample is still tiny, but Herrera has been superb for the Cardinals this year and should be well worth a juiced-up price like this.

  • 23-for-54 (.426) batting on the season
  • 1+ hits in 9 of 9 games this month
  • .324 xBA
  • .655 xSLG

Reigning AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal is on the mound for Detroit, and I don’t expect him to make things easy.

But Herrera has an .822 career OPS against lefties, and one hit from the right-hitting catcher/designated hitter shouldn’t be too much of an ask.

MLB prop picks made at 11:40 a.m. ET on 05/20/2025.

Padres vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 20: Look for Dylan Cease to dominate in Toronto

Blue Jays picks

After Monday’s off-day, the Toronto Blue Jays are back in action Tuesday night with a home matchup against the San Diego Padres.

The pregame narrative: Despite going 2-4 on their recent homestand, the Padres (27-18) still have the fifth-best record in MLB. Dylan Cease gets the ball for the visiting Padres, looking to build off back-to-back quality starts.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. the Padres on May 20, featuring Cease and George Springer.

Blue Jays picks vs. Padres

Best Bet: Cease over 5.5 Ks (-113)

Cease has command issues at times, but no one can question the nastiness of his pitch arsenal.

The seventh-year vet plays off an upper-90s fastball with a slider that has a 43.1% whiff rate (14th-highest among all MLB pitches, per Baseball Savant, min. 50 plate appearances).

Aside from the COVID-shortened 2020 season, Cease has posted a double-digit K/9 rate every year of his career.

A simple way to contextualize that is to say Cease averages more than one strikeout per inning. And on most nights, over 5.5 Ks is going to be an attainable number.

That has proven true this year, as Cease is averaging 6.4 Ks per outing. He is 7-2 vs. this prop.

The Blue Jays aren’t a plus matchup for strikeout props, but they aren’t impervious to the efforts of an ace-calibre arm. Over the past 14 days, Toronto has the 18th-highest K rate (21.4%).

Cease has crested the 200-strikeout mark in each of the past four seasons, and he’s on track to do it again. Coming off a season-high 10 Ks, I expect another solid outing from him.

Key stat: The Jays’ active lineup has struck out 21 times against Cease in 64 plate appearances (32.8 K%).

Embed: #113990

Quick pick

Springer under 0.5 hits (+116): Springer has arguably been the Jays’ best bat so far in 2025, but his numbers have really dropped off following a scorching start.

  • First 21 games: .349/.425/.556
  • Past 22 games: .189/.333/.378

Most recently, Springer has gone hitless in seven of his past 13 starts. And I really don’t like this matchup for him against Cease.

As mentioned, Cease has a nasty slider. He throws it 55.5% of the time to right-hitting opponents, garnering a .185 BA against the pitch.

Springer is 4-for-27 (.148) with a 48.0% whiff rate against sliders this season. And he’s just 1-for-6 with three Ks against Cease.

Padres vs. Blue Jays picks made at 11:00 a.m. ET on 05/20/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 20: Bet on Trea Turner to pile up hits vs. Rockies

MLB prop bets

Trea Turner is the headliner of Tuesday’s MLB prop bets, flanked by a pair of lesser-known players.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Turner has the benefit of playing in the offensive haven of Coors Field tonight, which is a great spot to keep a hot streak rolling. In Milwaukee, rookie right-hander Logan Henderson faces the reeling Orioles in search of another bounty of strikeouts.

Check out my MLB prop bets for May 20, which also includes a prediction on Ivan Herrera.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Henderson over 5.5 Ks (-114)

You probably don’t know who Henderson is (I certainly didn’t), but there’s a lot to like about his opportunity tonight against the Baltimore Orioles.

Henderson, a fourth-round pick by the Brewers in 2021, has been mowing down hitters at every level of pro ball. He just made his MLB debut in April and has kept up his high-strikeout ways.

  • Henderson has 16 Ks through two MLB starts (11.0 innings). Last week, he fanned seven batters in 5.0 innings against the Cleveland Guardians.
  • He has a 12.1 K/9 in 214.2 career innings of pro ball. In each of the four individual seasons, his K/9 has always been 11.5 or above.

Most of Henderson’s work this year has come against lesser competition, but the Orioles (15-31) are doing their best impression of a minor league club right now.

They’ve lost seven in a row and are striking out in droves.

Baltimore has the second-highest K rate over the past 30 days (25.0%). The O’s also have the fourth-lowest chase contact rate this season (51.5%), per Baseball Savant.

I think Henderson has a chance to give the Brewers some length tonight despite throwing fewer than 85 pitches in both MLB starts this year.

He has worked up to 96 pitches in the minors (back on May 2), and Milwaukee’s bullpen could really use a breather. Four of its relievers — including its top-three leverage guys — have pitched on back-to-back days.

Key stat: In eight pro outings this year (six at the Triple-A level), Henderson has 5+ Ks in all eight games and 6+ Ks in six games.

Embed: #113987

Best MLB picks

Herrera over 0.5 hits (-143): The sample is still tiny, but Herrera has been superb for the Cardinals this year and should be well worth a juiced-up price like this.

  • 23-for-54 (.426) batting on the season
  • 1+ hits in 9 of 9 games this month
  • .324 xBA
  • .655 xSLG

Reigning AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal is on the mound for Detroit, and I don’t expect him to make things easy.

But Herrera has an .822 career OPS against lefties, and one hit from the right-hitting catcher/designated hitter shouldn’t be too much of an ask.

Turner over 1.5 hits (+112): In a vacuum, this is a pretty tough price to pay for a multi-hit performance. But the ingredients are all there for Turner tonight.

  • He’s swinging a hot stick, batting .368 over his past 20 games. Turner has 11 multi-hit games in that span.
  • Rockies starter Antonio Senzatela (1-7, 6.39 ERA) has really been going through it. He’s allowing 8.2 hits per start this year.
  • Technically, Senzatela has a platoon advantage in this righty-on-righty matchup. But he has allowed a .366 BA and 1.073 OPS to right-hitting opponents this year, so … the advantage definitely falls to Turner.

Turner is 7-for-15 with a double against Senzatela.

Also, Turner has a 36th-percentile walk rate (7.0%), so I’m not super worried about him foiling this pick with any free passes.

MLB prop picks made at 9:40 a.m. ET on 05/20/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 19: Fade Schwarber, look for Ray and Greene to shine on Monday

MLB prop bets

Half of MLB is in action on Monday evening to kick off a new week.

Today’s MLB props narrative: The Toronto Blue Jays aren’t playing, but Jays fans can catch Robbie Ray on the mound as the Giants host the Royals out west. In the game with the highest projected total on the slate, Kyle Schwarber and the Phillies visit the Rockies.

Check out my MLB prop bets for May 19, featuring Ray, Schwarber and Riley Greene.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Ray over 5.5 Ks (-134)

Ray has been the quintessential effectively wild pitcher so far in 2025.

The veteran southpaw leads the NL in walks (26), yet he’s 6-0 with a 3.04 ERA.

And his FIP (3.74) is practically identical to what it was when he earned 2021 AL Cy Young honours with Toronto (3.69).

Though he ranks in the 12th percentile in walk rate, per Baseball Savant, Ray has overcome that issue by ranking in the 75th and 77th percentiles in K rate and whiff rate, respectively.

He has a knack for putting out his own fires. As his opponent tonight knows too well.

Against the active Kansas City Royals lineup, Ray has racked up 28 Ks in just 66 plate appearances — good for a staggering 42.4 K%.

The Royals have the second-lowest K rate in the majors (18.9%), which is why this number is set fairly low for someone of Ray’s pedigree.

Still, the head-to-head history against KC’s lineup is encouraging. As are Ray’s recent outings.

In his past seven starts, Ray is 5-2 vs. this prop while averaging 7.0 Ks.

Key stat: The average MLB whiff rate is 25.2%. Three of Ray’s four pitch offerings have a whiff rate of 34.5% or greater.

Best MLB picks

Schwarber under 0.5 runs (+125): The Phillies are facing a struggling pitcher (Kyle Freeland, 6.15 ERA) tonight in the very welcoming offensive environment of Coors Field. Still, this price has piqued my interest.

Schwarber is no longer the Phillies’ leadoff man, where his run-scoring potential was maximized. In early April, he was moved down in the order, and now he consistently bats third or fourth.

That’s still a great spot to mash, but it makes him less likely to cross the plate himself.

In his past 25 games — all as the No. 3 or 4 hitter — Schwarber has gone under 0.5 runs 13 times.

This is a dangerous play, but I think there’s serious upside based on the price.

Also, Schwarber is just 2-for-15 with seven Ks and zero walks against Colorado’s Freeland.

Greene over 1.5 bases (+115): Against right-handed pitching, Greene is absolutely worth a flier on his bases prop right now.

  • The left-hitting outfielder has a .317/.354/.618 slash line against RHPs this season (compared to a .182/.274/.273 line vs. LHPs).
  • Greene has 2+ bases in 6 of his past 8 games. In the two outliers, he went 0-for-5 with three Ks against lefty pitchers.

Greene will face right-hander Sonny Gray tonight, and Gray isn’t exactly coming in hot.

Over his past four starts, Gray has allowed 26 hits and a .500 SLG over 21.0 innings.

With a 91st-percentile barrel rate (16.3%), Greene has made a habit of delivering the highest-possible contact quality for the Tigers. When he has the platoon advantage, watch out.

MLB prop picks made at 11:20 a.m. ET on 05/19/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 19: Fade Schwarber, look for Ray and Greene to shine on Monday

MLB prop bets

Half of MLB is in action on Monday evening to kick off a new week.

Today’s MLB props narrative: The Toronto Blue Jays aren’t playing, but Jays fans can catch Robbie Ray on the mound as the Giants host the Royals out west. In the game with the highest projected total on the slate, Kyle Schwarber and the Phillies visit the Rockies.

Check out my MLB prop bets for May 19, featuring Ray, Schwarber and Riley Greene.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Ray over 5.5 Ks (-113)

Ray has been the quintessential effectively wild pitcher so far in 2025.

The veteran southpaw leads the NL in walks (26), yet he’s 6-0 with a 3.04 ERA.

And his FIP (3.74) is practically identical to what it was when he earned 2021 AL Cy Young honours with Toronto (3.69).

Though he ranks in the 12th percentile in walk rate, per Baseball Savant, Ray has overcome that issue by ranking in the 75th and 77th percentiles in K rate and whiff rate, respectively.

He has a knack for putting out his own fires. As his opponent tonight knows too well.

Against the active Kansas City Royals lineup, Ray has racked up 28 Ks in just 66 plate appearances — good for a staggering 42.4 K%.

The Royals have the second-lowest K rate in the majors (18.9%), which is why this number is set fairly low for someone of Ray’s pedigree.

Still, the head-to-head history against KC’s lineup is encouraging. As are Ray’s recent outings.

In his past seven starts, Ray is 5-2 vs. this prop while averaging 7.0 Ks.

Key stat: The average MLB whiff rate is 25.2%. Three of Ray’s four pitch offerings have a whiff rate of 34.5% or greater.

Embed: #113965

Best MLB picks

Schwarber under 0.5 runs (+155): The Phillies are facing a struggling pitcher (Kyle Freeland, 6.15 ERA) tonight in the very welcoming offensive environment of Coors Field. Still, this price looks off to me.

Schwarber is no longer the Phillies’ leadoff man, where his run-scoring potential was maximized. In early April, he was moved down in the order, and now he consistently bats third or fourth.

That’s still a great spot to mash, but it makes him less likely to cross the plate himself.

In his past 25 games — all as the No. 3 or 4 hitter — Schwarber has gone under 0.5 runs 13 times.

This is a dangerous play, but I think there’s serious upside based on the price.

Also, Schwarber is just 2-for-15 with seven Ks and zero walks against Colorado’s Freeland.

Greene over 1.5 bases (+120): Against right-handed pitching, Greene is absolutely worth a flier on his bases prop right now.

  • The left-hitting outfielder has a .317/.354/.618 slash line against RHPs this season (compared to a .182/.274/.273 line vs. LHPs).
  • Greene has 2+ bases in 6 of his past 8 games. In the two outliers, he went 0-for-5 with three Ks against lefty pitchers.

Greene will face right-hander Sonny Gray tonight, and Gray isn’t exactly coming in hot.

Over his past four starts, Gray has allowed 26 hits and a .500 SLG over 21.0 innings.

With a 91st-percentile barrel rate (16.3%), Greene has made a habit of delivering the highest-possible contact quality for the Tigers. When he has the platoon advantage, watch out.

MLB prop picks made at 11:20 a.m. ET on 05/19/2025.

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop picks May 19: Bet on Freddie Freeman, Corbin Carroll to deliver

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets

The Arizona Diamondbacks and Los Angeles Dodgers close out Monday’s MLB slate.

The pregame narrative: Los Angeles (29-18) paces the deep NL West and can create more separation between itself and fourth-place Arizona (25-22) during this three-game series. The Dodgers are slight home favourites with Landon Knack pitching opposite Brandon Pfaadt.

Check out my Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets, featuring Corbin Carroll and Freddie Freeman.

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets

Best Bet: Carroll over 1.5 bases (+100)

Three of the top five players on the NL MVP odds board are playing in this series, including Carroll (+550), who is sandwiched between Shohei Ohtani (+110) and Freeman (+1,200).

Arizona’s right fielder has returned to form after a sophomore slump, posting a stellar .279/.352/.589 slash line with equally impressive batted-ball metrics.

  • 98th percentile xSLG (.620)
  • 95th percentile barrel rate (17.4%)
  • 94th percentile hard-hit rate (54.9%)

Carroll is crushing the ball this season, ranking fifth in home runs (14) and third in total bases (116), and there is plenty of evidence pointing to another strong outing tonight.

Knack has been thrust into a starting role for the Dodgers due to injuries, and the second-year righty has gotten lit up to the tune of a 6.61 ERA across four starts:

  • April 9 vs. Nationals: 2.1 IP, 5 H, 5 ER
  • April 15 vs. Rockies: 4.1 IP, 4 H, 2 ER
  • May 7 vs. Marlins: 5.0 IP, 4 H, 0 ER
  • May 13 vs. Athletics: 4.2 IP, 7 H, 5 ER

Outside of a strong outing against the Marlins, Knack has been hit hard by three pretty bad teams.

The left-batting Carroll wields a platoon advantage in this matchup, and I expect him to deliver.

Key Stat: Carroll’s SLG vs. RHP (.662) is notably higher than his SLG vs. LHP (.438).

Embed: #113942

Best MLB picks

Freeman to record an RBI (+135): This seems like tremendous value given the way Freeman is playing and where he’s situated in L.A.’s lineup.

The 35-year-old is batting a scorching .371 this season, typically hitting third behind Ohtani and Mookie Betts when the Dodgers face RHPs.

Freeman ranks 10th in RBI (34) and is batting .412 with RISP (ninth-best in MLB).

Pfaadt has had Ohtani’s number (2-for-9, three Ks), but I still expect the generational hitter to find his way on base. Betts, meanwhile, has gotten aboard in 7-of-16 at-bats against the righty (.437 OBP).

Arizona’s starter has also been unspectacular this season. Pfaadt’s 5.53 xERA is much higher than his 3.73 standard ERA, indicating some regression is on the horizon.

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets made at 10:42 a.m. ET on 05/19/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop picks May 19: Bet on Freddie Freeman, Corbin Carroll to deliver

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets

The Arizona Diamondbacks and Los Angeles Dodgers close out Monday’s MLB slate.

The pregame narrative: Los Angeles (29-18) paces the deep NL West and can create more separation between itself and fourth-place Arizona (25-22) during this three-game series. The Dodgers are slight home favourites with Landon Knack pitching opposite Brandon Pfaadt.

Check out my Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets, featuring Corbin Carroll and Freddie Freeman.

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets

Best Bet: Carroll over 1.5 bases (-106)

Three of the top five players on the NL MVP odds board are playing in this series, including Carroll (+550), who is sandwiched between Shohei Ohtani (+110) and Freeman (+1,200).

Arizona’s right fielder has returned to form after a sophomore slump, posting a stellar .279/.352/.589 slash line with equally impressive batted-ball metrics.

  • 98th percentile xSLG (.620)
  • 95th percentile barrel rate (17.4%)
  • 94th percentile hard-hit rate (54.9%)

Carroll is crushing the ball this season, ranking fifth in home runs (14) and third in total bases (116), and there is plenty of evidence pointing to another strong outing tonight.

Knack has been thrust into a starting role for the Dodgers due to injuries, and the second-year righty has gotten lit up to the tune of a 6.61 ERA across four starts:

  • April 9 vs. Nationals: 2.1 IP, 5 H, 5 ER
  • April 15 vs. Rockies: 4.1 IP, 4 H, 2 ER
  • May 7 vs. Marlins: 5.0 IP, 4 H, 0 ER
  • May 13 vs. Athletics: 4.2 IP, 7 H, 5 ER

Outside of a strong outing against the Marlins, Knack has been hit hard by three pretty bad teams.

The left-batting Carroll wields a platoon advantage in this matchup, and I expect him to deliver.

Key Stat: Carroll’s SLG vs. RHP (.662) is notably higher than his SLG vs. LHP (.438).

Best MLB picks

Freeman to record an RBI (+137): This seems like tremendous value given the way Freeman is playing and where he’s situated in L.A.’s lineup.

The 35-year-old is batting a scorching .371 this season, typically hitting third behind Ohtani and Mookie Betts when the Dodgers face RHPs.

Freeman ranks 10th in RBI (34) and is batting .412 with RISP (ninth-best in MLB).

Pfaadt has had Ohtani’s number (2-for-9, three Ks), but I still expect the generational hitter to find his way on base. Betts, meanwhile, has gotten aboard in 7-of-16 at-bats against the righty (.437 OBP).

Arizona’s starter has also been unspectacular this season. Pfaadt’s 5.53 xERA is much higher than his 3.73 standard ERA, indicating some regression is on the horizon.

Diamondbacks vs. Dodgers prop bets made at 10:30 a.m. ET on 05/19/2025.

Mets vs. Yankees Sunday Night Baseball prop bets: Fade Max Fried and back Aaron Judge

Mets vs. Yankees prop bets

The rubber match of this season’s first Subway Series will be decided on Sunday Night Baseball.

The pregame narrative: New York is favoured to win at Yankee Stadium behind Max Fried, who is leading MLB in ERA and gaining steam as an early-season Cy Young contender. The Mets counter a steady southpaw of their own, David Peterson.

Check out my Mets vs. Yankees prop bets, featuring Fried and Aaron Judge.

Mets vs. Yankees prop bets

Best Bet: Fried under 5.5 strikeouts (+100)

Fried has been a maestro this season, but there is good reason to fade him on tonight’s strikeout total.

  • The lefty’s 3.59 xERA is 2.48 higher than his 1.11 ERA. That’s the 13th-largest difference in MLB, per Baseball Savant.
  • Fried doesn’t miss a ton of bats. He has a 34th percentile whiff rate (22.6) and 35th percentile chase rate (26.2).

I have to give Fried his flowers for a hot start, but those underlying numbers suggest he’s been quite lucky. And now he goes up against a team which has excellent plate discipline and hits lefties for power.

The Mets have the fifth-lowest K rate (19.4%) and seventh-highest slugging percentage (.423) against southpaws this season.

Fried has gone under this total in four of eight starts, landing on exactly six strikeouts twice.

I don’t expect him to overindex in a tough matchup.

Key Stat: Fried has gone under this mark in four of his last six starts against the Mets, averaging 5.16 Ks in those outings.

Best MLB picks

Judge over 1.5 bases (-125): Judge has been hitting the cover off the ball this season, leading MLB in batting average (.402), slugging percentage (.753), and total bases (131).

He’s a good bet to clear this total on any given night against any pitcher, and Peterson is no different.

Judge’s splits against lefties are downright absurd:

  • .480 BA
  • 1.280 SLG
  • Eight XBH in 25 at-bats

Peterson surrenders hard contact (95 mph+ exit velocity) on 51.9% of balls put in play. That ranks in the fourth percentile among all MLB pitchers.

I expect Judge to put one into the seats tonight.

Mets vs. Yankees prop picks made at 12:53 p.m. ET on 05/18/2025.

Mets vs. Yankees Sunday Night Baseball prop bets: Fade Max Fried and back Aaron Judge

Mets vs. Yankees prop bets

The rubber match of this season’s first Subway Series will be decided on Sunday Night Baseball.

The pregame narrative: New York is favoured to win at Yankee Stadium behind Max Fried, who is leading MLB in ERA and gaining steam as an early-season Cy Young contender. The Mets counter a steady southpaw of their own, David Peterson.

Check out my Mets vs. Yankees prop bets, featuring Fried and Aaron Judge.

Mets vs. Yankees prop bets

Best Bet: Fried under 5.5 strikeouts (+100)

Fried has been a maestro this season, but there is good reason to fade him on tonight’s strikeout total.

  • The lefty’s 3.59 xERA is 2.48 higher than his 1.11 ERA. That’s the 13th-largest difference in MLB, per Baseball Savant.
  • Fried doesn’t miss a ton of bats. He has a 34th percentile whiff rate (22.6) and 35th percentile chase rate (26.2).

I have to give Fried his flowers for a hot start, but those underlying numbers suggest he’s been quite lucky. And now he goes up against a team which has excellent plate discipline and hits lefties for power.

The Mets have the fifth-lowest K rate (19.4%) and seventh-highest slugging percentage (.423) against southpaws this season.

Fried has gone under this total in four of eight starts, landing on exactly six strikeouts twice.

I don’t expect him to overindex in a tough matchup.

Key Stat: Fried has gone under this mark in four of his last six starts against the Mets, averaging 5.16 Ks in those outings.

Embed: #113919

Best MLB picks

Judge over 1.5 bases (-122): Judge has been hitting the cover off the ball this season, leading MLB in batting average (.402), slugging percentage (.753), and total bases (131).

He’s a good bet to clear this total on any given night against any pitcher, and Peterson is no different.

Judge’s splits against lefties are downright absurd:

  • .480 BA
  • 1.280 SLG
  • Eight XBH in 25 at-bats

Peterson surrenders hard contact (95 mph+ exit velocity) on 51.9% of balls put in play. That ranks in the fourth percentile among all MLB pitchers.

I expect Judge to put one into the seats tonight.

Mets vs. Yankees prop picks made at 12:53 p.m. ET on 05/18/2025.

Best MLB prop bet May 18: Back Cardinals’ Arenado in plus-money prop

MLB prop bets

A healthy dose of the Subway Series makes its way into my MLB prop bets for Saturday.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Nolan Arenado is having an uncharacteristically poor season, but he should be able to take advantage of a plus matchup.

Check out my MLB prop bets for May 18.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Arenado over 1.5 total bases (+125)

This isn’t the type of season people have come to expect from Arenado.

The Cardinals slugger’s .242 batting average and .379 OPS are the lowest marks of his career, and way below his career averages of .284 and .853, respectively.

If there’s anything that can get the third baseman going, though, it’s a date with Kansas City Royals pitcher Michael Wacha.

Wacha is enjoying a solid campaign, combining a 2.96 ERA with a 3.10 FIP. But he has struggled mightily in the past versus Arenado.

In 19 at-bats versus Wacha, Arenado is batting:

  • .474 AVG
  • 4 home runs

Those are undeniable numbers.

Key stat: No batter has more career home runs against the pitcher they’re facing today than Arenado.

MLB prop picks made at 12:04 p.m. ET on 05/18/2025.