Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 15: Bet on Zac Gallen to shine vs. Brewers

MLB prop bets

Bryce Harper headlines today’s MLB prop bets, and there are two additional plays in the 4 p.m. window.

The pregame narrative: Harper faces a familiar pitcher today and should be able to do some serious damage. Later on, I’m fading Randy Arozarena and Cal Raleigh in a plus-money parlay while also tailing Zac Gallen’s strikeout prop.

Check out these MLB prop bets for Sept. 15.

MLB prop bets

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Best bet: Harper over 1.5 bases (+130)

Embed: #94645

Backing a hitter in a lefty-on-lefty matchup is typically not the move, but this one isn’t as daunting as you might think.

From the pitching side of things, Mets starter David Peterson has yielded only marginally better power results to righty hitters (.364 SLG) than to lefties (.343 SLG).

As for Harper, his OPS against lefties (.927) is actually better this year than his OPS against righties (.906). And both are stellar, obviously, which is why he was named to his eighth all-star team this summer.

Harper has already seen — and crushed — Peterson in the past, too.

The two-time MVP is 7-for-15 (.467) with a home run, a double and two walks against Peterson.

In fairness to Peterson, he’s done well to limit damage in recent outings. Since the start of August, he has a 2.39 ERA and a .315 opponent SLG. But if anyone is going to power up against him, I like my chances with Harper.

Coming off a two-homer game last night, look for Harper to stay hot in a familiar matchup.

Key stat: Harper has gone over 1.5 bases in 13 of his past 21 games, posting a .385/.455/.626 slash line in that span.

Quick picks

Parlay: Arozarena, Raleigh under 1.5 bases each (+128): I view this as a solid price to fade two players who’ve really struggled against Rangers left-hander Andrew Heaney.

Embed: #94650

Let’s start with Arozarena, whose main risk is that he tends to hit lefties better than righties. On the bright side (for us), the former Ray hasn’t been hitting anyone well lately.

Arozarena has gone under 1.5 bases in 21 of his past 29 games, batting .209 in that span. He is 1-for-7 with three strikeouts against Heaney.

Raleigh, meanwhile, is hitless in 11 at-bats against Heaney.

Embed: #94651

The catcher known by some as “Big Dumper” is also hitless in seven of his past 16 games. And although he’s a switch-hitter by trade, Raleigh’s numbers from the left side are well below league average (.156 BA, .633 OPS).

Gallen over 6.5 Ks (-106): The Milwaukee Brewers aren’t a particularly strikeout-heavy team, but this isn’t a particularly arduous strikeout line for Gallen.

Embed: #94654

The talented right-hander has gotten into a groove lately, riding a 16.1-inning scoreless streak into today’s outing. He also has gone over 6.5 Ks in four consecutive starts.

Milwaukee has the 13th-highest K rate against righties this year (23.4%). And the current lineup has struck out against Gallen at an even higher rate — 26.1% over 46 plate appearances, per Baseball Savant.

Picks made at 9:55 a.m. ET on 09/15/2024.

Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks Sept. 14: Back Gilbert, Scherzer and fade Semien

Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks

The Texas Rangers play the Seattle Mariners in the second game of their series.

The pregame narrative: Max Scherzer takes the mound for the Rangers as the Mariners counter with Logan Gilbert. I’m taking the over on a prop for each starter while fading one of Texas’ star hitters.

Check out my Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks for Sept. 14.

Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Best Bet: Gilbert over 18.5 outs (-110)

Embed: #94578

The Mariners’ starter has been reliable this season and ups his play when going against the Rangers.

Gilbert’s cleared this line in both starts against Texas this season, throwing a total of 14.2 innings without giving up a single run.

He accumulated 15 strikeouts and simply dominates this Rangers offence. In 172 plate appearances, the current lineup has 29 hits (.169 batting average) with 42 Ks.

With that kind of sample size, I would feel like a fool not to try and take advantage in the prop markets.

Key stat: Gilbert has cashed this bet in six of his last seven starts.

Quick picks

Scherzer over 4.5 strikeouts (-138): Scherzer is still battling a nagging shoulder injury but that hasn’t stopped him from tallying up the strikeouts.

Embed: #94579

He’s recorded five or more Ks in four of his last five starts despite only pitching more than four innings twice.

That demonstrates his ability to fan batters even if he isn’t working late into ballgames.

Baseball Savant displays his chase rate at 36.3% which would rank in the 99th percentile if he threw enough innings to qualify.

Additionally, Seattle strikes out the most per game in the majors (10.14).

Semien under 0.5 hits (+148): Going back to Gilbert’s success, Marcus Semien has been one of the biggest contributors.

Embed: #94580

in 29 career meetings, Semien has just two hits (.069 BA) and has struck out six times.

The second baseman is hot right now, recording hits in seven of his last nine starts but that just gives us a better number to play.

I can’t ignore the disastrous history against Gilbert so I’m willing to take a shot here at some nice odds.

Picks made at 11:00 a.m. ET 09/14/2024.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 14: Bet on Kyle Tucker and Corbin Burnes

MLB prop bets

Kyle Tucker and Corbin Burnes headline today’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Tucker is back from the IL and is primed to mash against a pitcher he’s dominated in the past. Burnes was slumping in August but has turned a corner and should pitch deep into his start against the Detroit Tigers.

Check out these MLB prop bets for September 14.

MLB prop bets

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Best bet: Tucker over 1.5 bases (+104)

Embed: #94502

Will the real Kyle Tucker please stand up?

Houston’s slugger demolished lefties last season, posting a .300/.367/.567 slash line in 210 plate appearances. This year hasn’t been quite the same.

Tucker is batting .209 against southpaws in 2024 and is .154 since returning from the IL earlier this month.

That’s not exactly a ringing endorsement but tonight presents a perfect opportunity for some positive regression. He faces a struggling Tyler Anderson who gets the ball for the Los Angeles Angels.

Anderson has a 5.40 ERA across his last seven outings and has routinely been lit up by Tucker and the Houston Astros.

Tucker is 7-for-12 against Anderson with a double, two triples, and a home run.

And it’s not like Tucker is completely floundering at the plate. He has a hit in three straight games with one going for extra bases and is batting .263 in August.

This is a player who is in MVP conversations when healthy. Now that he’s got a handful of games under his belt I expect him to heat up heading into the postseason.

Key stat: Anderson has a 4.67 ERA at home this season and has given up 14 earned runs in his last three starts at Angel Stadium.

Quick picks

Burnes over 17.5 outs (-150): A -150 price tag isn’t pretty but this is a rare case where I believe it’s well worth it.

Embed: #94581

Burnes was right in the mix for the AL Cy Young award before falling apart in August.

The first year Baltimore Oriole brought a 2.47 ERA into that month and raised it to 3.23 after a string of bad starts.

But he’s looked good in September, giving up one earned run to the Chicago White Sox in 5.0 IP and two earned runs to the Tampa Bay Rays in 6.0 IP.

The Tigers are running hot but aren’t a good team offensively. They rank 21st in batting average (.235) with the eighth-highest K rate (24.1%) against righties.

Burnes has cleared this line in 21 of 29 of his starts.

Diaz over 1.5 bases (-106): Yandy Diaz has murdered lefties this year and today he goes up against a struggling rookie.

Embed: #94583

Joey Cantillo has a 6.38 ERA for the Cleveland Guardians in five career major-league starts. That’s not a huge sample but the southpaw also posted an underwhelming 4.54 ERA in the minors this season.

Diaz is batting .347 against lefties with a 165 wRC+.

He also has a hit in five straight games, clearing this line three times.

Picks made at 10:06 a.m. ET on 09/14/2024.

Sept. 14 MLB odds, schedule and matchups: Chris Sale makes start against the Dodgers

MLB odds

Saturday brings with it a loaded MLB slate to dive into.

The latest: The Atlanta Braves and Los Angeles Dodgers send two top-tier pitchers to the mound in an exciting evening game. Following that is Max Scherzer and the Texas Rangers vs. Logan Gilbert and the Seattle Mariners to close out a great day of baseball.

Check out the latest MLB odds for Saturday, Sept. 14.

MLB odds: Sept. 14

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Boston Red Sox vs. New York Yankees

Embed: #94549

Kansas City Royals vs. Pittsburgh Pirates

Embed: #94559

St. Louis Cardinals vs. Toronto Blue Jays

Embed: #94561

New York Mets vs. Philadelphia Phillies

Embed: #94562

Miami Marlins vs. Washington Nationals

Embed: #94563

Tampa Bay Rays vs. Cleveland Guardians

Embed: #94564

Baltimore Orioles vs. Detroit Tigers

Embed: #94565

Oakland Athletics vs. Chicago White Sox

Embed: #94566

Cincinnati Reds vs. Minnesota Twins

Embed: #94567

Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Atlanta Braves

Embed: #94568

Chicago Cubs vs. Colorado Rockies

Embed: #94569

Milwaukee Brewers vs. Arizona Diamondbacks

Embed: #94570

San Diego Padres vs. San Francisco Giants

Embed: #94571

Houston Astros vs. Los Angeles Angels

Embed: #94572

Texas Rangers vs. Seattle Mariners

Embed: #94573

Betting insights

  • Michael Wacha (3.34 ERA) is the definition of consistency. The Royals’ starter has given up two or fewer runs in 15 of his last 18 starts and is 4-1 since the beginning of August. Kansas City plays Pittsburgh this afternoon.
  • How good is Sale? The NL Cy Young favourite is 16-3 with a 2.38 ERA this season. He finds himself in a blockbuster matchup against Jack Flaherty (2.86) and the Dodgers tonight.
  • In the final game of the day, Scherzer (3.89 ERA) and Gilbert (3.15 ERA) take the mound as the Rangers visit the Mariners. The lowest total of the day (6.5) indicates this should be a pitcher’s duel and I don’t think anyone would be surprised.

Blue Jays props vs. Cardinals Sept. 14: Back Berrios and Guerrero Jr.

Blue Jays props

The Toronto Blue Jays and St. Louis Cardinals are back at it for an afternoon game at Rogers Centre.

The pregame narrative: Alejandro Kirk played hero when the Blue Jays walked off the Cardinals last night. Today, I’m looking to back Jose Berrios and Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

Check out the best Blue Jays props vs. the Cardinals on Sept. 14.

Blue Jays props vs. Cardinals

MLB markets: Click Here | MLB stats: Click Here

Best Bet: Berrios over 4.5 strikeouts (-139)

Embed: #94545

There is some juice to contend with here but I believe it’s worth the squeeze.

Berrios has steadied the ship after a tough start to the season. He has a 2.36 ERA since the start of August and has recorded five-plus strikeouts in all seven of those starts.

He’s averaging 20.3 outs in that span which is roughly 6.2 IP. Berrios isn’t an elite swing-and-miss guy by any means but working deep into ballgames gives him a better chance of racking up Ks.

The Cardinals managed to keep Kevin Gausman to just three strikeouts in 7.0 IP yesterday but his K rate has fallen off a cliff.

Berrios has seen parts of this Cardinals lineup a few times and the results speak for themselves.

In 26 combined plate appearances, he has a monster 46.2% K rate, according to Baseball Savant. That includes striking out Paul Goldschmidt six times in nine at-bats and Brendan Donovan three times in six at-bats.

He should be able to clear this modest total.

Key stat: Berrios recorded seven strikeouts the last two times he played the Cards (both in 2022).

Quick pick

Guerrero over 1.5 bases (-106): We might be running the risk of sounding like a broken record over here … but Vladdy is really, really good.

Embed: #94546

In his last 70 games, he’s hitting .361 with a 1.116 OPS. He has 50 extra-base hits in that span and went 1-for-4 last night with a double.

He’s having a mini-slump this month, if you can even call it that, batting .270 across nine games. But he’s still got a hit in seven of those contests and has cleared this line three times.

Tonight’s matchup against St. Louis starter Kyle Gibson should be favourable.

The righty has a 4.20 ERA and ranks in the bottom-third percentile for xERA, xBA, barrel rate and fastball velocity (90.9 mph).

Vladdy is batting .402 with a .632 xSLG against fastballs under 93 mph and is 5-for-14 with a double against Gibson.

Picks made at 8:53 a.m. on 09/14/24.

Blue Jays picks vs. Cardinals Sept. 13: Bet on Guerrero to help drive offence

Blue Jays picks

After Thursday’s off-day, the Toronto Blue Jays continue their homestand with a three-game series against the St. Louis Cardinals.

The pregame narrative: Tonight’s pitching matchup isn’t scaring me off of taking the over on a modest game total. In the player prop market, I like Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s plus-money price to score a run.

Check out the best Blue Jays picks vs. the Cardinals on Sept. 13.

Blue Jays picks vs. Cardinals

MLB markets: Click Here | MLB stats: Click Here

Best Bet: Over 8 runs (-104)

Embed: #94521

One thing that really jumped out to me about tonight’s matchup are the home/road splits for Cardinals starter Erick Fedde since he joined his new club.

Fedde, who was shipped to St. Louis in a three-team trade at the end of July, has done a lot better within the pitcher-friendly confines of Busch Stadium than elsewhere:

SituationERAFIPSLG
Home (3 starts)2.353.96.339
Road (4 starts)5.645.86.494

These are small enough samples that Fedde could have some luck working for or against him, but it’s still a stark difference.

One way to approach that trend would be to take the over on the Blue Jays’ 3.5-run team total (-141), but that’s juiced up enough that I’d rather take a stab at the game total instead. Plus, I think either of tonight’s starting pitchers is capable of coughing up at least a handful of runs.

Kevin Gausman wasn’t officially announced as Toronto’s starter at the time of this writing, but he is next in line to pitch (make sure to monitor any news on that front ahead of game time). Here’s how both teams’ respective lineups have performed against Fedde and Gausman:

  • TOR vs. Fedde: 6-for-25 (.240), .480 SLG, 9.7% K rate
  • STL vs. Gausman: 16-for-51 (.314), .490 SLG, 14.3% K rate

Again, fairly modest samples we’re working with. But the K rates tell a story that neither pitcher has baffled these lineups in the past.

The over is 41-29-2 (58.6%) in Toronto’s home games this year, which is the sixth-highest home overs rate in baseball, per Team Rankings. Knowing that, I’ll ride with the over again tonight.

Key stat: Kevin Gausman has a 4.09 ERA over his past 14 starts, and this over is 9-4-1 in those outings.

Quick pick

Guerrero over 0.5 runs (+110): Vladdy’s run prop is priced better than his bases prop. And I think it’s a better bet, too.

Embed: #94535

Fedde has issued multiple walks in 10 of his past 11 starts and has a 3.7 BB/9 in that span. Over a full season, that would be the second-highest among qualified MLB pitchers.

Vladdy is an ultra-dangerous slugger who also has a strong sense of the strike zone and rarely goes down swinging. He’s exactly the type of guy Fedde should be looking to pitch around.

In fact, we’ve seen that already. Guerrero is 2-for-7 with three walks against Fedde.

With that in mind, I’m not as bullish to bet the over on 1.5 bases for Guerrero. But I do expect him to find a way on base, after which he’ll have a solid chance to score.

Guerrero has scored in 29 of his past 49 games (59.2%) and has posted a .463 on-base percentage in that span.

Picks made at 2:30 p.m. on 09/13/24.

Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks Sept. 13: Bet the over on Jacob deGrom’s strikeout prop in season debut

Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks

For the first time in 16 and a half months, Jacob deGrom will pitch in a meaningful MLB game. He’s starting tonight for the Texas Rangers on the road against the Seattle Mariners.

The pregame narrative: Regardless of what kind of pitch limit deGrom might be on, his return to the majors is exciting for anyone who loves elite pitching. In his season debut, the two-time Cy Young winner has a strikeout line set at 6.5 and I’m riding with the over as my best bet.

Check out my Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks for Sept. 13.

Rangers vs. Mariners prop picks

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Best Bet: deGrom over 6.5 Ks (-109)

Embed: #94495

deGrom will almost certainly be on a pitch count tonight, which is the only way to explain why this line isn’t higher.

The Mariners have the highest K rate in the majors (27.3%), the second-highest whiff rate and the third-lowest chase contact rate. The past five starters who faced them posted an 11.9 K/9 collectively.

That includes Rangers rookie Kumar Rocker, who fanned seven Mariners last night in just 4.0 innings of work.

Rocker is a right-hander with an upper-90s fastball and a devastating slider. deGrom fits that exact profile, only with a harder fastball and several years of strikeout dominance under his belt.

Since 2020, the four-time all-star has posted a 14.0 K/9. That equates to just under 7.8 Ks for every five innings of work.

We may only see four or five innings of work from deGrom tonight, and the Rangers’ potential restrictiveness with him is where most of the risk lies for this wager.

But his proven efficiency as a strikeout producer — not to mention the Mariners’ strikeout efficiency from the offensive side — gives me confidence that he can hit this over on a limited workload.

Key stat: deGrom struck out 15 batters over 10.2 innings in his four rehab starts. He built up to 49 pitches over 4.0 innings in his most recent outing (Sept. 7 for Triple-A Frisco).

Quick pick

Parlay: Josh Jung, Victor Robles 1+ hits each (+117): Seattle hadn’t announced its starting pitcher at the time of this writing, but I’m willing to put Jung up against pretty much anyone right now.

Embed: #94510

With a home run last night, Jung is now batting .342 with a .998 OPS so far this month. He also has at least one hit in 27 of his past 35 games.

On Seattle’s side, Robles has had the benefit (or arguably, the misfortune) of seeing deGrom a fair amount in the past. The outfielder is 4-for-17 with a pair of doubles in those encounters.

Embed: #94509

Those numbers aren’t flashy, but it’s nice that Robles will know what he’s getting himself into tonight. Also, he’s on a wild run right now, batting 27-for-67 (.403) over his past 20 games.

Picks made at 12:00 p.m. ET 09/13/2024.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 13: Back starting pitchers Peralta, Knack and Ober

MLB prop bets

Three starting pitchers are featured in today’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: A play on Los Angeles Dodgers right-hander Landon Knack is my favourite pick, while Freddy Peralta and Bailey Ober make up the remaining recommendations.

Check out these MLB prop bets for September 13.

MLB prop bets

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Best bet: Knack over 4.5 Ks (-114)

Embed: #94502

I have a hard time seeing this light line staying at this price throughout the day. 

Knack has a 28.1% K rate at Triple-A Oklahoma City this season and a 24.0 K% across 11 MLB appearances (nine starts).

His strikeout numbers weren’t impressive at Triple-A last season, but he fanned more than 27% of the batters he faced in Double-A last year and 2022.

While those aren’t elite numbers, they are well above average and provide a good outlook ahead of tonight’s start versus the Atlanta Braves.

Atlanta hitters get punched out often, ranking top 10 in K rate on the season and during the second half, while fanning at the sixth-highest clip against right-handers.

Knack struck out eight batters last week against the Cleveland Guardians, a club with significantly less swing and miss than the Braves.

The 27-year-old recorded five-plus Ks in five of his eight MLB starts before that.

Key stat: Across MLB and Triple-A, Knack has topped this line in each of his last seven starts.

Quick picks

Peralta over 15.5 outs (-106): This line required a double-take despite Peralta’s pedestrian stretch.

Embed: #94503

The Milwaukee Brewers’ ace, known for his high strikeout upside, has not been missing bats.

He has a measly 18.9% K rate since the start of August, a span of seven starts in which he’s issued multiple walks each outing and has a 5.33 FIP.

Not only are the walks and lack of Ks concerning (though the latter could help keep his pitch count down), but he’ll be facing an elite offence.

The Arizona Diamondbacks rank first in MLB in wRC+ (143) in the second half, and recently returned all-star Ketel Marte. 

That said, this is not a play on his K prop. Peralta has topped this line in 18 of 29 starts, including seven of his last 10.

Ober over 5.5 Ks (-137): This is an excellent price to back Ober on a 5.5 line.

Embed: #94504

The righty has a career-high K rate (26.5%) and gives the playoff-hopeful Minnesota Twins innings.

Ober has worked at least six frames in 13 of his last 14 starts, but you’re not going to find any 17.5 lines out there at a playable price. But the innings mean more opportunity to rack up Ks.

Over that 14-start stretch, Ober has cleared this 10 times. He faced two teams that are difficult to retire on strikes in his last outings, punching out seven Royals and eight Blue Jays.

The Cincinnati Reds are not like those clubs. Cincinnati ranks fifth in the majors in K rate and fourth against right-handers.

Perhaps I’d give pause if this game was being played in Cincinnati’s homer-happy park. But it’s in Minnesota where Ober has a 10.18 K/9 rate.

Picks made at 11:49 a.m. ET on 09/13/2024.

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 12: Back Brewers’ Frankie Montas in juicy matchup vs. Giants

MLB prop bets

There are only eight baseball games today but that still leaves us plenty of MLB prop options.

The pregame narrative: My favourite bet is a play on Milwaukee Brewers starter Frankie Montas. I’m also backing Washington Nationals lefty Mitchell Parker, as well as Seattle Mariners outfielder Victor Robles.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for Sept. 12.

MLB prop bets

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Best bet: Montas over 5.5 Ks (-117)

Embed: #94415

I thought Colin Rea could take advantage of a light line and prime matchup last night but he was instead rocked for 10 runs on 11 hits and came away with one strikeout. 

But tonight, I like Montas to top his K line for many of the reasons I liked Rea. 

Getting out of Cincinnati appears to have done Montas some good. And perhaps more reps have helped him shake some rust after he missed all of last season outside of one September appearance due to shoulder surgery. 

Here’s a look at Montas’ numbers with the Reds vs. the Brewers:

  • With CIN: 5.01 ERA, 1.43 WHIP, 7.5 K/9
  • With MIL: 3.92 ERA, 1.20 WHIP, 9.7. K/9

Montas has a 25.6 K% over his seven starts with Milwaukee and has cleared this line in four of his last six outings. He recorded a season-high 10 punchouts in his last start.

The right-hander has also been eating innings, working at least six frames in four consecutive starts. And tonight he’ll be throwing in a great pitcher’s venue at Oracle Park in San Francisco.

Key stat: The Giants have the second-highest K rate in MLB in the second half.

Quick picks

Parker over 16.5 outs (-107): The Nationals left-hander has a plus matchup against the division-rival Miami Marlins tonight.

Embed: #94416

Miami is second-last in MLB in wRC+ versus left-handers. And the club ranks bottom five in ISO, batting average and on-base percentage.

Parker threw well when he faced the Marlins in June, spinning six innings of one-run ball. He also faced them in April when he made his third career start. Although he logged only four innings, Parker limited Miami’s offence to a run.

The southpaw has enjoyed a solid first year in the bigs. His K rate is hovering around league average, his walk rate is better than league average and he has a 3.89 FIP (better than average and an improvement from his 4.43 ERA).

Against a bottom-of-the-barrel lineup, that package should allow him to work deep (which this line doesn’t even ask for). Parker has topped this number in 14 of 26 starts. 

Robles over 0.5 runs (+125): Robles has eight runs in as many games this month, and is hitting a blistering .400/.515/.560 in September.

Embed: #94417

Seattle’s leadoff hitter has been strong in the second half, leading the Mariners with a .305 average and .369 OBP.

The big storyline for tonight’s game is the debut of top Texas Rangers prospect Kumar Rocker, who has been dominating in the minors (43 Ks over his last 26.2 innings, a span of six starts).

Rocker hasn’t gone more than five innings once, though, so he’ll likely be limited. Following him will be a Rangers bullpen that has been dreadful this season.

Picks made at 2:14 p.m. ET on 09/12/2024.

Red Sox vs. Yankees prop picks Sept. 12: Bet on Duran to score, fade Soto

Red Sox vs. Yankees prop picks

The Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees open a four-game set tonight at Yankee Stadium.

The pregame narrative: I’m fading Juan Soto tonight as the riskiest of my three plus-money prop bets in this matchup. On Boston’s side of things, I like Jarren Duran and Rob Refsnyder to do some damage.

Check out my Red Sox vs. Yankees prop picks for Sept. 12.

Red Sox vs. Yankees prop picks

MLB Markets: Click Here | MLB Stats: Click Here

Best Bet: Duran over 0.5 runs (+115)

Embed: #94392

Why is Duran, who has 102 runs this season, getting such a juicy price to score for Boston from the leadoff spot tonight?

Well, he’s a lefty hitter who struggles against lefty pitching. And southpaw Nestor Cortes is typically at his best in left-on-left matchups.

But this price is good enough to catch my interest. And upon taking a closer look, I think there’s some real value.

Duran has scored in 76 of 144 games this year (52.8%), and he really turned up the heat in June to land his first all-star bid.

From June 1 onward, Duran has scored in 50 of 86 games (58.1%) with a .310/.362/.560 slash line. He’s also an above-average hitter against LHPs in that span, posting a .283 BA and a 107 wRC+.

All of a sudden, that platoon disadvantage doesn’t look so bleak, does it?

If Cortes was cruising in the run-up to this start, I might be a bit hesitant. But he’s been all over the map.

In his past 10 outings, Cortes has a 5.16 ERA and an .803 opponent OPS. He’s had three shutout performances in that span, but also four games with five-plus runs allowed.

Boston’s lineup has hit Cortes well, so if Duran can find a way on base, there should be someone capable of driving him home.

Key stat: The Red Sox are 25-for-79 (.316) with a .595 SLG against Cortes.

Quick picks

Refsnyder over 1.5 bases (+155): Refsnyder isn’t an everyday player, but he should absolutely be in the lineup tonight — and he should crush.

Embed: #94395

The journeyman outfielder is a menace against lefty pitching, especially over the past few years. Since 2022, he owns a .317/.412/.502 slash line and a 153 wRC+ against LHPs.

And it just so happens that Refsnyder has been a menace in this particular matchup. He’s 8-for-16 with three doubles against Nestor Cortes.

When he’s in the lineup, Refsnyder usually bats No. 3 for Boston. He should have plenty of chances to clear this total tonight.

Soto under 0.5 hits (+180): Soto is one of the best hitters in the game, but he’s arguably even better at drawing a walk.

Embed: #94396

Soto’s 18.0% walk rate is second behind only Aaron Judge in the majors. He’s led the majors in walks in three consecutive seasons and is only two off Judge’s league-best pace this year.

It’s never going to be a comfortable feeling betting on Soto to go hitless. But he’s done so in 12 of his past 24 games and is batting just .200 in that span.

With a particularly keen eye, Soto could easily find his way on once or twice without even lifting the bat off his shoulder.

Picks made at 1:20 p.m. ET 09/12/2024.