Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets May 3: Picks on Riley Greene and Brandon Pfaadt

MLB prop bets

All 30 MLB teams are in action on Saturday and I’ve got three prop bets to share.

The pregame narrative: Riley Greene has been tearing the cover off the baseball and has an advantageous matchup. I also have picks starting pitchers Brandon Pfaadt and Patrick Corbin earlier in the evening.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 3.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Greene over 1.5 total bases (+117)

The Detroit Tigers slugger is on a tear right now, slashing .400/.455/.733 over the past eight games.

He’s 5-3 against this line over that time. But that’s not the only reason to back Greene.

Kyle Hendricks makes his sixth start of the season for the Los Angeles Angels, and things have been ugly.

  • 0-3
  • 6.65 ERA (1.39 WHIP)
  • .265 opponent xBA

Hendricks is not a strikeout arm, either. He’s in the 7th percentile for K rate (13.3%) and the 3rd percentile for whiff rate (16.0%), per Baseball Savant.

That can work in favour of Greene, who loves to hack. The outfielder has a 31.3% chase rate.

Most importantly, he’s a righty, and Greene is a player who can take advantage of the platoon advantage.

The lefty has a .298 average and .920 OPS against right-handed pitching this season (89 plate appearances).

Key stat: Greene leads the Tigers with 64 total bases.

Embed: #113361

Best MLB picks

Corbin under 15.5 outs (-130): Corbin got off to a fairly good start to the year, allowing three or fewer runs in each of his first four starts.

He hasn’t worked deep into ball games, though. Corbin’s cleared this line just once, mostly because his 1.58 WHIP has resulted in a high pitch count per inning.

I can’t completely ignore his 3.79 ERA, so I dug deeper, and I believe there is regression to come.

  • His 4.66 xERA is much higher than his actual number and ranks in the 28th percentile.
  • His opponent xBA of .296 is even worse, ranking in the 12th percentile.

Additionally, the Seattle Mariners have an xBA of .332 in 59 plate appearances against Corbin, who hasn’t had an ERA lower than 5.00 for an entire season since 2020.

Even if the righty continues to get lucky, it’ll take a lot of pitches to do so.

Pfaadt over 5.5 strikeouts (+112): On the other side of the narrative, there’s Pfaadt, who has the best head-to-head stats of any starter on Saturday.

In 35 plate appearances against the current Philadelphia Phillies lineup, Pfaadt has a 42.9% K rate and allows a measly .152 average.

He hasn’t been very effective as a strikeout thrower this season, going under this total in four of six games. But this is a matchup I cannot ignore.

Plus, he’s had six or more Ks in two of his past three starts, which is an indication that he is ramping up as the year progresses.

Pfaadt had a 9.17 K/9 last in 2024.

MLB prop picks made at 12:12 p.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop pick May 3: Fade Williams against Toronto

Blue Jays pick

The Toronto Blue Jays host the Cleveland Guardians for the second game of their weekend series on Saturday.

The pregame narrative: Toronto’s lineup is tough to strike out. Gavin Williams’ inconsistent punch-out skills make him a quality fade candidate in this matchup.

Check out my Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks for May 3.

Blue Jays pick vs. Guardians

Best Bet: Williams under 4.5 strikeouts (-106)

Williams possesses some strikeout skills.

  • 68th-percentile chase rate (30.2)
  • 74th-percentile whiff rate (29.1)

While those are solid numbers, they haven’t translated to elite punchout totals. He has a 56th-percentile strikeout rate (22.8), and he’s topped this total in only three of six games.

I’m skeptical of his chances of doing so in a difficult matchup. The Blue Jays have the second-lowest strikeout rate in MLB (7.09).

Additionally, shorter-than-usual outings are always in Williams’ range of possibilities. He’s pitched five innings or shorter in four of his last six outings, lasting three or fewer twice.

His 5.14 ERA and 4.88 FIP are worrisome in addition to his .275 opponent batting average.

The advanced numbers paint a similar picture, too. Williams enters this contest with a 12th-percentile expected ERA (5.91) and an eighth-percentile expected opponent batting average (.304).

Guardians vs. Blue Jays picks made at 10:49 a.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 3: Bet on Santana to deliver at plus-money odds

Blue Jays picks

I’m backing a hitter and fading a pitcher in my Cleveland Guardians vs. Toronto Blue Jays prop picks for Saturday.

The pregame narrative: Carlos Santana boasts an impressive track record against Toronto starter Kevin Gausman and is a solid pick to beat his plus-money bases prop. I’m fading Gavin Williams‘ strikeout prop against a stingy Blue Jays lineup.

Check out my Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks for May 3.

Blue Jays picks vs. Guardians

Best Bet: Santana over 1.5 total bases (+163)

This isn’t a line Santana beats with any sort of regularity.

The Guardians slugger has recorded two-plus bases in just seven games this season, and he hasn’t recorded an extra-base hit since April 9.

But there are several reasons to back him on this prop.

The first is his track record against Gausman. Santana has crushed the Blue Jays’ righty across 21 at-bats:

  • Seven hits
  • Five extra-base hits

Secondly, Gausman is having a tough go of things this season. He pairs a 4.50 ERA with a 3.91 FIP, and the advanced numbers suggest he may no longer possess elite stuff.

  • 48th-percentile expected ERA (3.88)
  • 40th-percentile whiff rate (23.8)
  • 47th-percentile strikeout rate (21.2)

Gausman’s most recent outing was his worst of the campaign. The Toronto star lasted just 2.2 innings, allowing six earned runs while walking five batters.

I expect his struggles to continue against a familiar face who has done well against him in the past.

Key stat: Santana has a .364 batting average across his last four games.

Embed: #113355

Quick pick

Williams under 4.5 strikeouts (-115): Williams possesses some strikeout skills.

  • 68th-percentile chase rate (30.2)
  • 74th-percentile whiff rate (29.1)

While those are solid numbers, they haven’t translated to elite punchout totals. He has a 56th-percentile strikeout rate (22.8), and he’s topped this total in only three of six games.

I’m skeptical of his chances of doing so in a difficult matchup. The Blue Jays have the second-lowest strikeout rate in MLB (7.09).

Additionally, shorter-than-usual outings are always in Williams’ range of possibilities. He’s pitched five innings or shorter in four of his last six outings, lasting three or fewer twice.

His 5.14 ERA and 4.88 FIP are worrisome in addition to his .275 opponent batting average.

The advanced numbers paint a similar picture, too. Williams enters this contest with a 12th-percentile expected ERA (5.91) and an eighth-percentile expected opponent batting average (.304).

Guardians vs. Blue Jays picks made at 10:49 a.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 2: Bet on Skubal to go deep against Angels, Ray to punch out Rockies

MLB prop picks

Tarik Skubal headlines Friday’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: The reigning AL Cy Young is off to a solid start and draws an A-plus matchup against the downtrodden Los Angeles Angels. I’m banking on Skubal pitching deep into that ballgame, and I also have prop bets on Alex Bregman and Robbie Ray.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 2.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Skubal over 18.5 outs (+137)

Pitching into the seventh inning isn’t commonplace in today’s game, but Skubal has the arsenal and matchup to make it happen tonight.

The fireballing lefty hasn’t missed a beat after an award-winning 2024. Skubal got roughed up by the Los Angeles Dodgers in his first start and has been stellar since.

  • 1.52 ERA in five starts
  • .223 opponent BA
  • 11.71 K/9

Skubal only cleared this line in one of those outings, throwing 7.0 shutout innings against the Milwaukee Brewers. But he had also landed on exactly 18 outs (6.0 IP) twice.

The Angels are one of baseball’s worst offensive teams, and they especially struggle against lefties. Los Angeles is batting .204 (27th) with a 59 wRC+ (29th) against LHP this season.

This seems like a smash spot for one of the game’s great pitchers to have a night.

Key stat: Los Angeles is 1-8 in its last nine games while averaging 2.4 runs.

Best MLB picks

Bregman over 1.5 bases (+110): Bregman has been hitting the cover off the ball for the Boston Red Sox lately. Just look at what he’s done over the last 10 games:

  • 16-for-40 (.400 BA)
  • 5 doubles, 2 home runs
  • 2+ bases in 7 of 10 games

The veteran righty has an extra-base hit in three straight games (one double, two HR) and now gets the benefit of facing a pitcher he’s dominated.

Bregman is 6-for-13 against Minnesota Twins righty Joe Ryan three doubles and two home runs. None of those at-bats ended in strikeouts, either, so the ball has consistently been put in play.

Ray over 7.5 strikeouts (-134): Ray has been erratic this season, but like Skubal, he has an opportunity to do damage against an awful team.

The southpaw starts at home against the Colorado Rockies, who are simply awful.

  • Colorado is 6-25 (on pace for 31 wins).
  • It has the highest K rate overall (28.1%) and against LHP (29.2%)

Ray doesn’t have a huge sample size against Colorado’s lineup, but the results are staggeringly strong. He has 13 strikeouts in 23 at-bats (54.2% K rate) while giving up just three hits.

The San Francisco Giants’ starter has cleared this line in two of his last three starts

MLB prop picks made at 2:10 p.m. ET on 05/02/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 2: Bet on Skubal to go deep against Angels, Ray to punch out Rockies

MLB prop picks

Tarik Skubal headlines Friday’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: The reigning AL Cy Young is off to a solid start and draws an A-plus matchup against the downtrodden Los Angeles Angels. I’m banking on Skubal pitching deep into that ballgame, and I also have prop bets on Alex Bregman and Robbie Ray.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 2.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Skubal over 18.5 outs (+128)

Pitching into the seventh inning isn’t commonplace in today’s game, but Skubal has the arsenal and matchup to make it happen tonight.

The fireballing lefty hasn’t missed a beat after an award-winning 2024. Skubal got roughed up by the Los Angeles Dodgers in his first start and has been stellar since.

  • 1.52 ERA in five starts
  • .223 opponent BA
  • 11.71 K/9

Skubal only cleared this line in one of those outings, throwing 7.0 shutout innings against the Milwaukee Brewers. But he had also landed on exactly 18 outs (6.0 IP) twice.

The Angels are one of baseball’s worst offensive teams, and they especially struggle against lefties. Los Angeles is batting .204 (27th) with a 59 wRC+ (29th) against LHP this season.

This seems like a smash spot for one of the game’s great pitchers to have a night.

Key stat: Los Angeles is 1-8 in its last nine games while averaging 2.4 runs.

Embed: #113340

Best MLB picks

Bregman over 1.5 bases (+123): Bregman has been hitting the cover off the ball for the Boston Red Sox lately. Just look at what he’s done over the last 10 games:

  • 16-for-40 (.400 BA)
  • 5 doubles, 2 home runs
  • 2+ bases in 7 of 10 games

The veteran righty has an extra-base hit in three straight games (one double, two HR) and now gets the benefit of facing a pitcher he’s dominated.

Bregman is 6-for-13 against Minnesota Twins righty Joe Ryan three doubles and two home runs. None of those at-bats ended in strikeouts, either, so the ball has consistently been put in play.

Ray over 7.5 strikeouts (-124): Ray has been erratic this season, but like Skubal, he has an opportunity to do damage against an awful team.

The southpaw starts at home against the Colorado Rockies, who are simply awful.

  • Colorado is 6-25 (on pace for 31 wins).
  • It has the highest K rate overall (28.1%) and against LHP (29.2%)

Ray doesn’t have a huge sample size against Colorado’s lineup, but the results are staggeringly strong. He has 13 strikeouts in 23 at-bats (54.2% K rate) while giving up just three hits.

The San Francisco Giants’ starter has cleared this line in two of his last three starts

MLB prop picks made at 2:10 p.m. ET on 05/02/2025.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 2: Back Vladimir Guerrero Jr., fade Chris Bassitt

Blue Jays picks

The Toronto Blue Jays open up a three-game homestand against the Cleveland Guardians on Friday.

The pregame narrative: Toronto rebounded from an ugly stretch with back-to-back comeback wins over the Boston Red Sox. The Jays hope to keep the good vibes rolling against a Guardians team leading the AL Central at 18-13.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Chris Bassitt are my Blue Jays prop picks for May 2.

Blue Jays picks vs. Guardians

Best Bet: Guerrero over 1.5 bases (-108)

Guerrero played the hero last night hitting a three-run blast in the eighth inning to put Toronto up and secure the series win.

And can we talk about where he hit that pitch from? Talk about shades of his old man.

Anyways, Guerrero is rounding into form with hits in six of his last seven games — three of those left the yard. He’s still slashing an underwhelming .267/.358/.422 this season but Baseball Savant’s advanced metrics paint a rosier picture:

  • .311 xBA (94th percnetile)
  • .518 xSLG (84th percentile)
  • 54.3% hard-hit rate (93rd percentile)

Guerrero is still mashing baseballs, but they just happen to be going right at fielders. Things are bound to start breaking his way sooner rather than later, and we’ve already seen that over the past week.

Tonight’s matchup against Cleveland’s Logan Allen presents a strong opportunity for Guerrero to stay hot.

The southpaw owns a 4.21 ERA through five starts and just got tagged for seven earned runs on nine hits against the Red Sox.

Key stat: Guerrero is slashing .308/.417/.538 against LHP since the start of last season.

Quick pick

Bassitt under 5.5 strikeouts (-138): The Bassitt Cy Young hype train has been derailed, at least for now. Toronto’s righty has gotten rocked in consecutive starts after posting a 0.77 ERA through his first four outings of the year:

  • April 22 vs. HOU: 5.1 IP, 7 H, 4 ER, 3 K
  • April 27 vs. NYY: 5.2 IP, 6 H, 4 ER, 5 K

I expect a better performance from Bassitt on Friday, but think this strikeout line is way too high, even if he works deep into the ballgame.

Why? Bassitt’s K rate was below the league average in three straight seasons heading into 2025. And while he has a 76th percentile K rate through six starts, we’re early on and have already seen a regression to the mean.

The righty is 1-3 against this line in his last four starts and has a 39th percentile whiff rate to boot.

Cleveland strikes out at the 10th-lowest rate vs. RHP, and its lineup has a 19.4% K rate against Bassitt in 35 combined plate appearances.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays picks made at 11:05 a.m. ET on 05/02/2025.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 2: Back Vladimir Guerrero Jr., fade Chris Bassitt

Blue Jays picks

The Toronto Blue Jays open up a three-game homestand against the Cleveland Guardians on Friday.

The pregame narrative: Toronto rebounded from an ugly stretch with back-to-back comeback wins over the Boston Red Sox. The Jays hope to keep the good vibes rolling against a Guardians team leading the AL Central at 18-13.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Chris Bassitt are my Blue Jays prop picks for May 2.

Blue Jays picks vs. Guardians

Best Bet: Guerrero over 1.5 bases (-118)

Guerrero played the hero last night hitting a three-run blast in the eighth inning to put Toronto up and secure the series win.

And can we talk about where he hit that pitch from? Talk about shades of his old man.

Anyways, Guerrero is rounding into form with hits in six of his last seven games — three of those left the yard. He’s still slashing an underwhelming .267/.358/.422 this season but Baseball Savant’s advanced metrics paint a rosier picture:

  • .311 xBA (94th percnetile)
  • .518 xSLG (84th percentile)
  • 54.3% hard-hit rate (93rd percentile)

Guerrero is still mashing baseballs, but they just happen to be going right at fielders. Things are bound to start breaking his way sooner rather than later, and we’ve already seen that over the past week.

Tonight’s matchup against Cleveland’s Logan Allen presents a strong opportunity for Guerrero to stay hot.

The southpaw owns a 4.21 ERA through five starts and just got tagged for seven earned runs on nine hits against the Red Sox.

Key stat: Guerrero is slashing .308/.417/.538 against LHP since the start of last season.

Embed: #113322

Quick pick

Bassitt under 5.5 strikeouts (-137): The Bassitt Cy Young hype train has been derailed, at least for now. Toronto’s righty has gotten rocked in consecutive starts after posting a 0.77 ERA through his first four outings of the year:

  • April 22 vs. HOU: 5.1 IP, 7 H, 4 ER, 3 K
  • April 27 vs. NYY: 5.2 IP, 6 H, 4 ER, 5 K

I expect a better performance from Bassitt on Friday, but think this strikeout line is way too high, even if he works deep into the ballgame.

Why? Bassitt’s K rate was below the league average in three straight seasons heading into 2025. And while he has a 76th percentile K rate through six starts, we’re early on and have already seen a regression to the mean.

The righty is 1-3 against this line in his last four starts and has a 39th percentile whiff rate to boot.

Cleveland strikes out at the 10th-lowest rate vs. RHP, and its lineup has a 19.4% K rate against Bassitt in 35 combined plate appearances.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays picks made at 11:05 a.m. ET on 05/02/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets May 1: Fade Chapman amid slump, back Torres with platoon advantage

MLB prop bets

There’s plenty of afternoon action around MLB, but I’m targeting the three latest starts for my MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: In Toronto, Alex Bregman looks to stay hot and has a nice price to record an RBI. On the West Coast, I’m looking to tail Gleyber Torres and fade Matt Chapman on their respective bases props.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 1.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Bregman over 0.5 RBI (+125)

Bregman is wielding a white-hot bat right now, and from the No. 3 spot in Boston’s order, I think this is a great way to back him.

  • The veteran third baseman has a 1.288 OPS in his past 13 games, totalling 12 RBI in that span.
  • He has 1+ RBI in 4 of 6 matchups since April 24.

Bregman has homered in both games so far this series, so obviously he can cash this on his own.

But RBI props are about opportunities with runners on base, and Bregman has had plenty of those, too.

Bregman has 70 plate appearances with runners on base so far, which is tied for the seventh-most in MLB.

In those PAs, Bregman has a .350/.429/.583 slash line (184 wRC+). That’s the ninth-highest wRC+ among players with 50-plus PAs with runners on.

Jose Berrios hasn’t been great in three home starts this year, allowing 17 hits and 11 runs in 16.2 innings.

I expect Jarren Duran to create some RBI opportunities for Bregman tonight. Boston’s leadoff man is 9-for-18 with eight extra-base hits against Berrios.

Key stat: Bregman is 7-for-29 with two doubles and two home runs (.517 SLG) against Berrios.

Best MLB picks

Torres over 1.5 bases (+125): Torres isn’t going to light up the radar gun with his batted-ball exit velocity, but his contact quality has been superb in the early stages of 2025.

Torres is below average in average exit velocity, barrel rate and hard-hit rate. But check out his rankings in some other notable categories, per Baseball Savant:

  • 96th-percentile squared-up rate
  • 87th-percentile chase rate
  • 87th-percentile xBA

Torres is on a prove-it contract, having signed a one-year deal with the Tigers just after Christmas. He’s off to a solid start and is worth backing whenever there’s a left-hander on the mound.

Tonight, Torres faces Angels southpaw Yusei Kikuchi. In their past matchups, Torres is 10-for-28 with two doubles and a homer.

Since 2023, Torres has a .274/.363/.505 slash line against LHPs. His 143 wRC+ against lefties in that span ranks 21st out of 127 qualified hitters.

Chapman under 1.5 bases (-143): I love this price on fading Chapman, who is 3-for-34 (.088) in his past 10 games.

Chapman will theoretically have a platoon advantage tonight against the left-handed Kyle Freeland, but that’s not a big part of his hitting profile.

Throughout his career, Chapman’s OPS against lefties (.818) is fewer than 40 points north of his OPS against righties (.779).

Also, it’s worth noting that Chapman is 1-for-8 lifetime against Freeland.

Chapman is a boom-or-bust hitter who hasn’t boomed in a while. He also leads the majors in walks (26 in 31 games), and any free passes issued tonight would be a plus for this pick.

MLB prop picks made at 2:10 p.m. ET on 05/01/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 1: Fade Chapman amid slump, back Torres with platoon advantage

MLB prop bets

There’s plenty of afternoon action around MLB, but I’m targeting the three latest starts for my MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: In Toronto, Alex Bregman looks to stay hot and has a nice price to record an RBI. On the West Coast, I’m looking to tail Gleyber Torres and fade Matt Chapman on their respective bases props.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 1.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Bregman over 0.5 RBI (+148)

Bregman is wielding a white-hot bat right now, and from the No. 3 spot in Boston’s order, I think this is a great way to back him.

  • The veteran third baseman has a 1.288 OPS in his past 13 games, totalling 12 RBI in that span.
  • He has 1+ RBI in 4 of 6 matchups since April 24.

Bregman has homered in both games so far this series, so obviously he can cash this on his own.

But RBI props are about opportunities with runners on base, and Bregman has had plenty of those, too.

Bregman has 70 plate appearances with runners on base so far, which is tied for the seventh-most in MLB.

In those PAs, Bregman has a .350/.429/.583 slash line (184 wRC+). That’s the ninth-highest wRC+ among players with 50-plus PAs with runners on.

Jose Berrios hasn’t been great in three home starts this year, allowing 17 hits and 11 runs in 16.2 innings.

I expect Jarren Duran to create some RBI opportunities for Bregman tonight. Boston’s leadoff man is 9-for-18 with eight extra-base hits against Berrios.

Key stat: Bregman is 7-for-29 with two doubles and two home runs (.517 SLG) against Berrios.

Embed: #113303

Best MLB picks

Torres over 1.5 bases (+130): Torres isn’t going to light up the radar gun with his batted-ball exit velocity, but his contact quality has been superb in the early stages of 2025.

Torres is below average in average exit velocity, barrel rate and hard-hit rate. But check out his rankings in some other notable categories, per Baseball Savant:

  • 96th-percentile squared-up rate
  • 87th-percentile chase rate
  • 87th-percentile xBA

Torres is on a prove-it contract, having signed a one-year deal with the Tigers just after Christmas. He’s off to a solid start and is worth backing whenever there’s a left-hander on the mound.

Tonight, Torres faces Angels southpaw Yusei Kikuchi. In their past matchups, Torres is 10-for-28 with two doubles and a homer.

Since 2023, Torres has a .274/.363/.505 slash line against LHPs. His 143 wRC+ against lefties in that span ranks 21st out of 127 qualified hitters.

Chapman under 1.5 bases (-124): I love this price on fading Chapman, who is 3-for-34 (.088) in his past 10 games.

Chapman will theoretically have a platoon advantage tonight against the left-handed Kyle Freeland, but that’s not a big part of his hitting profile.

Throughout his career, Chapman’s OPS against lefties (.818) is fewer than 40 points north of his OPS against righties (.779).

Also, it’s worth noting that Chapman is 1-for-8 lifetime against Freeland.

Chapman is a boom-or-bust hitter who hasn’t boomed in a while. He also leads the majors in walks (26 in 31 games), and any free passes issued tonight would be a plus for this pick.

MLB prop picks made at 2:10 p.m. ET on 05/01/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 30: Ride with Gunnar Henderson, fade Cristopher Sanchez

MLB prop bets

Gunnar Henderson hasn’t met expectations so far, but I think he’s worth backing on Wednesday night’s MLB prop market.

The pregame narrative: I like Henderson to take advantage of a lefty-on-righty matchup, which has been his bread and butter. I’m also backing Teoscar Hernandez to stay clutch at the plate while fading Cristopher Sanchez in his return from injury.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 30.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Hernandez over 0.5 RBI (+100)

As a cleanup hitter with three former MVPs batting ahead of him, Hernandez is in one of the most enviable spots in baseball.

It shouldn’t surprise anyone that he leads the league in RBI (31) given all the talent around him. But he’s doing his part, too.

  • Hernandez ranks fifth in MLB with a .613 SLG.
  • He’s 14-for-33 (.424) with runners in scoring position. And his 234 wRC+ with RISP ranks 11th in the majors.
  • Hernandez is batting .400 with nine extra-base hits during his current eight-game hit streak.

Though Hernandez has plenty of home run power — he has nine HRs already — RBI props are more often about traffic on the basepaths.

And the trio of Shohei Ohtani, Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman tend to provide that.

Ohtani and Freeman have been especially strong so far, posting a 159 and 172 wRC+, respectively. They’re also a combined 13-for-31 (.419) with seven walks and five extra-base hits against Miami starter Cal Quantrill.

Hernandez is 5-for-18 with a double and a homer against Quantrill. He should have opportunities to do more damage this afternoon.

Key stat: Hernandez has 1+ RBI in 13 of 28 games this season — including six of his past seven.

Best MLB picks

Henderson over 1.5 bases (+100): Henderson got hurt early in spring training and missed the first seven games of the season.

Is that an excuse for his slower-than-expected start? Not really, but it might be part of the reason that things haven’t quite clicked for last year’s fourth-place AL MVP finisher.

Henderson is still mashing the ball, ranking in the 99th percentile for average exit velocity and the 95th percentile for hard-hit rate, per Baseball Savant. He’s just not squaring it up often enough.

The left-hitting shortstop knows how to capitalize on a platoon advantage, though. He has a .932 OPS vs. righties this year (.901 career OPS vs. RHPs).

Henderson has cashed this bet in three of his past four games. And he’s 3-for-5 lifetime against Yankees right-hander Carlos Carrasco, who he’ll face tonight.

Sanchez under 5.5 Ks (-118): Sanchez was removed after 2.0 innings in his start last week due to tightness in his throwing arm.

It’s a good sign that he’s not missing a turn in the rotation, but I’m still a bit wary of a potential flare-up.

Furthermore, Sanchez hasn’t racked up strikeouts against the Washington Nationals in the past. The Nats’ active lineup has a paltry 13.0% K rate against Sanchez in 77 plate appearances (league average is 22.1%).

Sanchez was an all-star and a down-ballot Cy Young candidate last year with just a 7.6 K/9. He doesn’t need big strikeout numbers to succeed.

He went under this strikeout total in 19 of 31 starts last season, and I think he’ll do that again tonight.

MLB prop picks made at 1:30 p.m. ET on 04/30/2025.