Category: MLB

Blue Jays vs. Angels prop picks May 6: Bet the over on Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s bases prop

Blue Jays picks

The Toronto Blue Jays hit the West Coast to open a series against the Los Angeles Angels on Tuesday night.

The pregame narrative: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is still struggling to find consistent power, but he knows how to mash against lefties — and particularly against Angels starter Tyler Anderson. In fact, Toronto’s offence as a whole has been among the best in the league against southpaws.

I’m backing Guerrero and fading Anderson in my Blue Jays picks vs. the Angels on May 6.

Blue Jays picks vs. Angels

Best Bet: Guerrero over 1.5 bases (+104)

Guerrero has been a frustrating player to back on his bases prop this season, but it hasn’t been as fruitless of a venture as you might think.

  • Guerrero has 2+ bases in 16 of 34 games (47.1%).
  • He’s averaging 1.6 bases this season.

Baseball Savant is still bullish on Guerrero’s batted ball quality, which matters to me. His .414 SLG is far below his .524 xSLG, for example.

The first baseman also ranks in the 89th percentile or better in xBA, xwOBA, average exit velocity, hard-hit rate and barrel rate.

Now he gets a lefty-righty matchup against L.A.’s Anderson. That’s a plus for the guy wielding the bat.

Guerrero has done serious damage against lefties since the start of last season, posting a .301/.404/.534 slash line. His 164 wRC+ against LHPs in that span ranks 14th among 137 qualified hitters.

A plus-money bases prop for Vladdy is still playable on most nights, and tonight is one of those.

Key stat: Guerrero is 6-for-11 with two doubles against Anderson. Last year in Anderson’s start at Angel Stadium, Vlad Jr. went 3-for-5 with a double.

Embed: #113461

Quick pick

Anderson under 17.5 outs (-109): The Blue Jays’ offence has been among the worst in the majors, but there’s a notable split in results depending on the handedness of the pitcher.

  • vs. LHP: .247/.339/.387, 112 wRC+, 10.7 BB%
  • vs. RHP: .235/.301/.340, 85 wRC+, 7.7 BB%

Toronto’s 112 wRC+ against lefties ranks sixth in MLB. Its 85 wRC+ against righties ranks 26th.

Anderson faced Toronto twice last season, going 0-2 while allowing nine earned runs on 10 hits in 10.2 innings. He went under this outs total both times.

The Angels are coming off a rest day and have a perfectly refreshed bullpen. None of their relievers have worked more than once in the past three days.

Blue Jays picks vs. Angels made at 11:09 a.m. ET on 05/06/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets May 5: Fade Seattle’s Bryce Miller, back sluggers James Wood and Oneil Cruz

MLB prop bets

I’m kicking off the new MLB week with two prop picks for the 10-game slate.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Pittsburgh Pirates stud Oneil Cruz rakes with a platoon advantage and has one tonight against Miles Mikolas and the St. Louis Cardinals.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 5, which includes a best bet on Seattle Mariners right-hander Bryce Miller.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Miller under 15.5 outs (-108)

Miller had minuscule walk rates in his first two seasons, but he’s been unable to find the zone this year. 

Only two pitchers who have thrown at least 30 innings have a higher walk rate than Miller (14.7%), whose BB% was 5.7 from 2023-24. 

The righty has walked multiple batters every start this season and nine over his last two outings. 

He’s been able to limit damage via strikeouts and by keeping the ball in the yard, but Miller’s tightrope act is sure to lead to more blowups until he corrects his control.

Tonight’s matchup isn’t a great one for him.

  • The Athletics have been a top 10 offence by wRC+.
  • Their home stadium has been the second-most hitter-friendly venue, per Baseball Savant’s park factors.
  • Seattle’s division rival has been walking at a respectable clip and striking out well-below average, sporting the fifth-lowest K rate in MLB. 

The Mariners are off this Thursday and were off last Thursday. Since then, they got six-plus innings in back-to-back starts and only needed two relievers yesterday. 

Their bullpen should start this series in good shape. 

Key stat: Miller has gone under this line in four consecutive starts. 

Best MLB picks

Cruz over 1.5 total bases (-110): The price is a bit steep, but this is a perfect matchup to target Cruz in. 

He faces St. Louis Cardinals starter Mikolas, an arm prone to contact who doesn’t miss bats. 

Mikolas has 17 Ks over six starts. He has the top contact rate among pitchers over the last three seasons, meaning a well-above average number of balls are put in play against him.

Cruz ambushes right-handers, clobbering seven of his eight homers against them.

Check out Cruz’s MLB ranks, via FanGraphs, vs. RHPs: 

  • Hard-hit rate: 54.7% (1st)
  • ISO: .338 (8th) 
  • OPS: 1.028 (11th) 

MLB prop picks made at 12:58 p.m. ET on 05/05/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 5: Fade Seattle’s Bryce Miller, back sluggers James Wood and Oneil Cruz

MLB prop bets

I’m kicking off the new MLB week with three prop picks for the 10-game slate.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Washington Nationals stud James Wood comes into Monday on fire and there’s big value on the 22-year-old to continue mashing. Oneil Cruz rakes with a platoon advantage and has one tonight.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 5, which includes a best bet on Seattle Mariners right-hander Bryce Miller.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Miller under 15.5 outs (-103)

Miller had minuscule walk rates in his first two seasons, but he’s been unable to find the zone this year. 

Only two pitchers who have thrown at least 30 innings have a higher walk rate than Miller (14.7%), whose BB% was 5.7 from 2023-24. 

The righty has walked multiple batters every start this season and nine over his last two outings. 

He’s been able to limit damage via strikeouts and by keeping the ball in the yard, but Miller’s tightrope act is sure to lead to more blowups until he corrects his control.

Tonight’s matchup isn’t a great one for him.

  • The Athletics have been a top 10 offence by wRC+.
  • Their home stadium has been the second-most hitter-friendly venue, per Baseball Savant’s park factors.
  • Seattle’s division rival has been walking at a respectable clip and striking out well-below average, sporting the fifth-lowest K rate in MLB. 

The Mariners are off this Thursday and were off last Thursday. Since then, they got six-plus innings in back-to-back starts and only needed two relievers yesterday. 

Their bullpen should start this series in good shape. 

Key stat: Miller has gone under this line in four consecutive starts. 

Embed: #113436

Best MLB picks

Cruz over 1.5 total bases (-125): The price is a bit steep, but this is a perfect matchup to target Cruz in. 

He faces St. Louis Cardinals starter Miles Mikolas, an arm prone to contact who doesn’t miss bats. 

Mikolas has 17 Ks over six starts. He has the top contact rate among pitchers over the last three seasons, meaning a well-above average number of balls are put in play against him.

Cruz ambushes right-handers, clobbering seven of his eight homers against them.

Check out Cruz’s MLB ranks, via FanGraphs, vs. RHPs: 

  • Hard-hit rate: 54.7% (1st)
  • ISO: .338 (8th) 
  • OPS: 1.028 (11th) 

Wood over 1.5 total bases (+132): The sophomore slugger has been tearing the cover off the ball but can still be had at big plus-money prices on this prop most nights. 

Wood enters the day with nine homers and a .273/.381/.545 batting line. 

He’s top 15 in the majors in home runs and OPS, producing well-above-average offence (157 wRC+) primarily out of the No. 2/3 spots in Washington’s lineup. 

Wood has been particularly dangerous at home with a 1.027 OPS.

Wood’s Nationals host Luis Ortiz and the Cleveland Guardians, whose bullpen has thrown the third-most innings in MLB over the last two weeks. 

Cleveland has played 10 days in a row, including a doubleheader, so fatigue is a concern with this group tonight.

MLB prop picks made at 12:58 p.m. ET on 05/05/2025.

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets May 5: Look for Alonso to rake, fade Carroll amid slump

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets

The Arizona Diamondbacks and New York Mets open a three-game series at Chase Field on Monday night.

The pregame narrative: Ryne Nelson gets his first start of the year for the Diamondbacks after seven relief appearances. He tossed 4.0 innings of shutout ball against the Mets in a bulk relief role last week, but there’s still a pair of Mets worth backing against him.

Pete Alonso and Brandon Nimmo are featured in my Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets for May 5, alongside Corbin Carroll.

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets

Best Bet: Alonso over 1.5 bases (-106)

I’m not shying away from Alonso just because Arizona’s starting pitcher had a strong outing in this matchup last week.

If anything, it’s a plus that Alonso gets to see Nelson for a second time in a seven-day span.

And given their overall head-to-head history — Alonso is 4-for-9 with three home runs — I’m sure the Mets’ No. 3 hitter doesn’t mind.

Alonso is taking on anybody and everybody right now, putting up one of the best early-season slash lines in the majors: .344/.468/.656.

Is that kind of line sustainable? I’d think not, but Alonso is coming by his early-season success honestly.

According to Baseball Savant, he ranks in the 99th percentile in xSLG (.690) and the 98th percentile in hard-hit rate (58.8%).

Having just seen Nelson last week, I think Alonso should have a leg up in tonight’s matchup. Not that he’s needed that this season.

Key Stat: Alonso is averaging 2.3 bases per game and is 18-17 against this line.

Best MLB picks

Nimmo over 0.5 RBI (+155): I think this is a great price for Nimmo, who bats cleanup for the Mets.

Thanks to the efforts of Alonso, Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor, Nimmo has had 81 plate appearances with runners on base so far. That’s 2.6 per game — second-most in MLB.

Alonso, Soto and Lindor are a combined 11-for-29 (.379) with nine extra-base hits and five walks against Nelson. So Nimmo’s RBI opportunities should keep on coming.

As for the man himself, Nimmo has cashed this prop in six of his past 12 games. And he’s 4-for-7 with a double and a triple against Nelson.

Carroll under 0.5 runs (+100): Carroll is in a mini slump right now, and I think it’s worth leaning into that trend with a thriving starter on the mound.

  • Carroll is 7-for-40 (.175) with 16 strikeouts in his past nine games. He has only scored twice in that span.
  • New York’s Griffin Canning is 3-0 with a 1.13 ERA in his past three starts. He has allowed two or fewer runs in 5 of 6 starts this year.

Carroll is 0-for-3 against Canning, and the D-backs are collectively batting .175 against him with a .275 SLG in 43 plate appearances.

Even from the leadoff or No. 2 spot in Arizona’s order, I don’t expect Carroll to make much noise tonight.

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop picks made at 12:30 p.m. ET on 05/05/2025.

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets May 5: Look for Alonso to rake, fade Carroll amid slump

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets

The Arizona Diamondbacks and New York Mets open a three-game series at Chase Field on Monday night.

The pregame narrative: Ryne Nelson gets his first start of the year for the Diamondbacks after seven relief appearances. He tossed 4.0 innings of shutout ball against the Mets in a bulk relief role last week, but there’s still a pair of Mets worth backing against him.

Pete Alonso and Brandon Nimmo are featured in my Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets for May 5, alongside Corbin Carroll.

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop bets

Best Bet: Alonso over 1.5 bases (-103)

I’m not shying away from Alonso just because Arizona’s starting pitcher had a strong outing in this matchup last week.

If anything, it’s a plus that Alonso gets to see Nelson for a second time in a seven-day span.

And given their overall head-to-head history — Alonso is 4-for-9 with three home runs — I’m sure the Mets’ No. 3 hitter doesn’t mind.

Alonso is taking on anybody and everybody right now, putting up one of the best early-season slash lines in the majors: .344/.468/.656.

Is that kind of line sustainable? I’d think not, but Alonso is coming by his early-season success honestly.

According to Baseball Savant, he ranks in the 99th percentile in xSLG (.690) and the 98th percentile in hard-hit rate (58.8%).

Having just seen Nelson last week, I think Alonso should have a leg up in tonight’s matchup. Not that he’s needed that this season.

Key Stat: Alonso is averaging 2.3 bases per game and is 18-17 against this line.

Embed: #113411

Best MLB picks

Nimmo over 0.5 RBI (+175): I think this price is a steal for Nimmo, who bats cleanup for the Mets.

Thanks to the efforts of Alonso, Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor, Nimmo has had 81 plate appearances with runners on base so far. That’s 2.6 per game — second-most in MLB.

Alonso, Soto and Lindor are a combined 11-for-29 (.379) with nine extra-base hits and five walks against Nelson. So Nimmo’s RBI opportunities should keep on coming.

As for the man himself, Nimmo has cashed this prop in six of his past 12 games. And he’s 4-for-7 with a double and a triple against Nelson.

Carroll under 0.5 runs (-108): Carroll is in a mini slump right now, and I think it’s worth leaning into that trend with a thriving starter on the mound.

  • Carroll is 7-for-40 (.175) with 16 strikeouts in his past nine games. He has only scored twice in that span.
  • New York’s Griffin Canning is 3-0 with a 1.13 ERA in his past three starts. He has allowed two or fewer runs in 5 of 6 starts this year.

Carroll is 0-for-3 against Canning, and the D-backs are collectively batting .175 against him with a .275 SLG in 43 plate appearances.

Even from the leadoff or No. 2 spot in Arizona’s order, I don’t expect Carroll to make much noise tonight.

Mets vs. Diamondbacks prop picks made at 12:00 p.m. ET on 05/05/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Dodgers vs. Braves Sunday Night Baseball prop bet: Bet on Freddie Freeman to deliver in primetimes

Dodgers vs. Braves prop bets

The Los Angeles Dodgers and Atlanta Braves wrap up their weekend series under the lights of Sunday Night Baseball.

The pregame narrative: The Braves have had a disappointing campaign and are coming off a lopsided 10-3 loss on Saturday. I’m not expecting things to get much better, and like a prop that works against Atlanta’s chances at bouncing back.

Freddie Freeman is featured in my Dodgers vs. Braves prop bets for Sunday Night Baseball on May 4.

Dodgers vs. Braves prop bets

Best Bet: Freeman over 1.5 total bases (-118)

Like usual, there’s a strong case to make when it comes to backing Freeman on this market.

The ex-Braves first baseman continues to torment his old team. He delivered three hits, including a home run, in Saturday’s dominant win.

Big performances have been the norm for Freeman as he has cashed this prop in 11 of 22 games this season, making this a very fair line for him.

The benefit of backing a hitter like Freeman on this prop is that he can get it done with both contact and power. He’s batting an impressive .338 this season with a .662 SLG.

The matchup also works in Freeman’s favour. The superstar has done well in seven at-bats against Elder, delivering three hits.

Elder has been giving up a lot of hard contact this season, too. The Atlanta righty has surrendered a .267 batting average and .514 SLG to opposing hitters this season.

Freeman should be able to find success in this matchup and deliver on this prop.

Key Stat: Freeman has a 99th-percentile expected batting average (.330) and expected SLG (.682), according to Baseball Savant.

Dodgers vs. Braves prop picks made at 2:32 p.m. ET on 05/04/2025.

Dodgers vs. Braves Sunday Night Baseball prop bets: Bet on Freddie Freeman to deliver in primetime

Dodgers vs. Braves prop bets

The Los Angeles Dodgers and Atlanta Braves wrap up their weekend series under the lights of Sunday Night Baseball.

The pregame narrative: The Braves have had a disappointing campaign and are coming off a lopsided 10-3 loss on Saturday. I’m not expecting things to get much better, and like a pair of props that work against Atlanta’s chances at bouncing back.

Freddie Freeman and Bryce Elder are featured in my Dodgers vs. Braves prop bets for Sunday Night Baseball on May 4.

Dodgers vs. Braves prop bets

Best Bet: Freeman over 1.5 total bases (+100)

Like usual, there’s a strong case to make when it comes to backing Freeman on this market.

The ex-Braves first baseman continues to torment his old team. He delivered three hits, including a home run, in Saturday’s dominant win.

Big performances have been the norm for Freeman as he has cashed this prop in 11 of 22 games this season, making this a very fair line for him.

The benefit of backing a hitter like Freeman on this prop is that he can get it done with both contact and power. He’s batting an impressive .338 this season with a .662 SLG.

The matchup also works in Freeman’s favour. The superstar has done well in seven at-bats against Elder, delivering three hits.

Elder has been giving up a lot of hard contact this season, too. The Atlanta righty has surrendered a .267 batting average and .514 SLG to opposing hitters this season.

Freeman should be able to find success in this matchup and deliver on this prop.

Key Stat: Freeman has a 99th-percentile expected batting average (.330) and expected SLG (.682), according to Baseball Savant.

Embed: #113396

Best MLB picks

Elder under 3.5 strikeouts (+107): The plus-money odds attached to this wager certainly pique my interest.

Elder doesn’t have great strikeout stuff. His seventh-percentile whiff rate and eighth-percentile K rate certainly aren’t going to blow anybody away.

His inability to generate swings-and-misses is why he’s failed to top this prop in three of his five starts this season.

Additionally, the Dodgers aren’t a team that’s prone to massive punch-out totals. They rank a very mediocre 16th in team strikeout rate this season (8.27).

Elder didn’t top this prop in his lone start against Los Angeles in 2025. He struck out only three batters and gave up two home runs in that contest.

Dodgers vs. Braves prop picks made at 2:32 p.m. ET on 05/04/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 4: Fade Nick Castellanos, back Ryan McMahon on Sunday

MLB prop bets

There’s something for everyone in my MLB prop bets as I’m targeting an over and an under.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Weekend series across MLB come to an end on Sunday. I’m looking to back an under in today’s clash between the Arizona Diamondbacks and Philadelphia Phillies, and an under in today’s battle between the Colorado Rockies and San Francisco Giants.

Nick Castellanos and Ryan McMahon feature in my MLB prop bets predictions on May 4.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Castellanos under 1.5 total bases (-137)

Castellanos is humming along with another solid season.

The Philadelphia star is slashing .270/.323/.410, getting on base at about his career average while providing a little less power than usual.

There are a few reasons why, however, I’ve uncovered him as a fade candidate on Sunday.

The outfielder hasn’t been delivering on this wager recently. Castellanos has only cashed this prop once in his last five games, providing zero extra-base hits during this stretch.

Secondly, and most importantly, Castellanos has struggled mightily against the pitcher he’ll face today.

He’ll square off against Diamondbacks starter Eduardo Rodriguez, and that is a matchup that doesn’t favour Castellanos.

Rodriguez has held Castellanos to just one hit in 17 plate appearances with six strikeouts.

The Arizona pitcher has struggled this season, entering today’s action with a 6.06 ERA. His 4.04 FIP, however, suggests he’s due for some positive results.

I’m buying into Castellanos’ woes against Rodriguez, however, and betting him to go under this prop at a very fair price.

Key stat: Castellanos has failed to cover this prop in 22 of 33 games (66.6%), a significantly higher rate than these implied odds suggest (57.8%).

Best MLB picks

McMahon over 0.5 hits (-130): This is a pretty palatable line for somebody to deliver just one hit.

There’s a reason why this line is hanging so low, however. McMahon is batting a lowly .153 with a .261 SLG percentage.

McMahon is showing some encouraging signs, though, as he has recorded a hit in two of three games in Colorado’s series against San Francisco.

Additionally, McMahon has dominated the typically strong Logan Webb in the past.

McMahon has 12 hits — including four extra-base hits — in 39 at-bats versus Webb.

The Giants starter is coming off his roughest outing of the season, too. He ceded nine hits and five runs in five innings of work against the San Diego Padres.

These odds and McMahon’s head-to-head success are worth backing.

MLB prop picks made at 12:51 p.m. ET on 05/04/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 4: Fade Nick Castellanos, back Ryan McMahon on Sunday

MLB prop bets

There’s something for everyone in my MLB prop bets as I’m targeting an over and an under.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Weekend series across MLB come to an end on Sunday. I’m looking to back an under in today’s clash between the Arizona Diamondbacks and Philadelphia Phillies, and an under in today’s battle between the Colorado Rockies and San Francisco Giants.

Nick Castellanos and Ryan McMahon feature in my MLB prop bets predictions on May 4.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Castellanos under 1.5 total bases (-137)

Castellanos is humming along with another solid season.

The Philadelphia star is slashing .270/.323/.410, getting on base at about his career average while providing a little less power than usual.

There are a few reasons why, however, I’ve uncovered him as a fade candidate on Sunday.

The outfielder hasn’t been delivering on this wager recently. Castellanos has only cashed this prop once in his last five games, providing zero extra-base hits during this stretch.

Secondly, and most importantly, Castellanos has struggled mightily against the pitcher he’ll face today.

He’ll square off against Diamondbacks starter Eduardo Rodriguez, and that is a matchup that doesn’t favour Castellanos.

Rodriguez has held Castellanos to just one hit in 17 plate appearances with six strikeouts.

The Arizona pitcher has struggled this season, entering today’s action with a 6.06 ERA. His 4.04 FIP, however, suggests he’s due for some positive results.

I’m buying into Castellanos’ woes against Rodriguez, however, and betting him to go under this prop at a very fair price.

Key stat: Castellanos has failed to cover this prop in 22 of 33 games (66.6%), a significantly higher rate than these implied odds suggest (57.8%).

Embed: #113390

Best MLB picks

McMahon over 0.5 hits (-130): This is a pretty palatable line for somebody to deliver just one hit.

There’s a reason why this line is hanging so low, however. McMahon is batting a lowly .153 with a .261 SLG percentage.

McMahon is showing some encouraging signs, though, as he has recorded a hit in two of three games in Colorado’s series against San Francisco.

Additionally, McMahon has dominated the typically strong Logan Webb in the past.

McMahon has 12 hits — including four extra-base hits — in 39 at-bats versus Webb.

The Giants starter is coming off his roughest outing of the season, too. He ceded nine hits and five runs in five innings of work against the San Diego Padres.

These odds and McMahon’s head-to-head success are worth backing.

MLB prop picks made at 12:51 p.m. ET on 05/04/2025.

Best MLB prop bets May 3: Picks on Riley Greene and Brandon Pfaadt

MLB prop bets

All 30 MLB teams are in action on Saturday and I’ve got three prop bets to share.

The pregame narrative: Riley Greene has been tearing the cover off the baseball and has an advantageous matchup. I also have a pick starting pitcher, Brandon Pfaadt, earlier in the evening.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 3.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Greene over 1.5 total bases (+120)

The Detroit Tigers slugger is on a tear right now, slashing .400/.455/.733 over the past eight games.

He’s 5-3 against this line over that time. But that’s not the only reason to back Greene.

Kyle Hendricks makes his sixth start of the season for the Los Angeles Angels, and things have been ugly.

  • 0-3
  • 6.65 ERA (1.39 WHIP)
  • .265 opponent xBA

Hendricks is not a strikeout arm, either. He’s in the 7th percentile for K rate (13.3%) and the 3rd percentile for whiff rate (16.0%), per Baseball Savant.

That can work in favour of Greene, who loves to hack. The outfielder has a 31.3% chase rate.

Most importantly, he’s a righty, and Greene is a player who can take advantage of the platoon advantage.

The lefty has a .298 average and .920 OPS against right-handed pitching this season (89 plate appearances).

Key stat: Greene leads the Tigers with 64 total bases.

Best MLB pick

Pfaadt over 5.5 strikeouts (+115): On the other side of the narrative, there’s Pfaadt, who has the best head-to-head stats of any starter on Saturday.

In 35 plate appearances against the current Philadelphia Phillies lineup, Pfaadt has a 42.9% K rate and allows a measly .152 average.

He hasn’t been very effective as a strikeout thrower this season, going under this total in four of six games. But this is a matchup I cannot ignore.

Plus, he’s had six or more Ks in two of his past three starts, which is an indication that he is ramping up as the year progresses.

Pfaadt had a 9.17 K/9 last in 2024.

MLB prop picks made at 12:12 p.m. ET on 05/03/2025.