Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets April 17: Bet on Witt to score, fade Canning vs. Cardinals

MLB prop bets

Bobby Witt Jr. is on a roll right now, and I think he can keep that going on Thursday night against the Detroit Tigers.

The pregame narrative: Witt is an elite hitter who also possesses top-tier speed, and that combo makes him a compelling play to score a run. I’m also taking the over on Taj Bradley‘s strikeouts prop and fading Griffin Canning in the same market.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 17.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Canning under 4.5 strikeouts (-115)

Canning isn’t a flashy guy to have a bet on, but don’t let the lack of brand recognition get in the way of a logical fade.

A perennial back-of-rotation starter, Canning used to at least hover around the 9.0 K/9 rate on an annual basis. But he dipped to a 6.8 K/9 last year, and I’m not confident in him to bump the rate back up.

Canning is trying to simplify things in 2025, cutting the curveball out of his arsenal and sticking to a three-pitch mix. His fastball has below-average velocity (93.3 mph, versus 94.5 mph as the MLB average for righties).

His slider is his out pitch, and he’s throwing it more than 40.0% of the time, per Baseball Savant.

But given that the St. Louis Cardinals — tonight’s opponent — have the fourth-lowest whiff rate on sliders (27.9%), I doubt we’ll see him rack up strikeouts.

St. Louis also has the fifth-lowest K rate in the majors (19.5%). Five consecutive starters have gone under 4.5 Ks against the Cardinals.

Expect Canning to be the sixth.

Key stat: Since the start of last season, Canning has gone under 4.5 Ks in 23 of 34 starts (67.6%).

Best MLB picks

Bradley over 6.5 Ks (-112): Three starts into 2025, Bradley has deployed a balanced attack from the mound, and it’s been effective.

  • All four of his pitches have a whiff rate between 25.0% and 28.6%. That means none of them have been elite, but each of them (four-seamer, cutter, splitter, curveball) can be called upon based on feel.
  • Bradley has exactly seven Ks in all three starts.
  • His 30.9% K rate ranks in the 84th percentile.

I’m not blown away by Bradley’s pitch metrics, but I am inclined to back him in a plus matchup against the free-swinging New York Yankees.

The Yankees have the sixth-highest K rate (24.6%) and the third-highest whiff rate (28.3%) in MLB.

Bradley struck out seven over 6.0 innings when he faced the Yankees at home a season ago.

Witt over 0.5 runs (+114): Witt is really, really good. Let’s start there.

Last year’s AL MVP runner-up ranks in the 99th percentile in xBA (.349) and 95th percentile in xwOBA (.423).

So far this season, Witt is batting .310 and currently owns a nine-game hit streak. He has also scored in eight of his past 13 games.

What really pushes this pick over the line for me is Witt’s history against Detroit Tigers starter Reese Olson:

  • 6-for-11 (.545)
  • 4 extra-base hits (2 HRs)
  • .926 xSLG
  • 99.5 mph average exit velocity

MLB prop picks made at 9:31 a.m. ET on 04/17/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets April 17: Bet on Witt to score, fade Canning vs. Cardinals

MLB prop bets

Bobby Witt Jr. is on a roll right now, and I think he can keep that going on Thursday night against the Detroit Tigers.

The pregame narrative: Witt is an elite hitter who also possesses top-tier speed, and that combo makes him a compelling play to score a run. I’m also taking the over on Taj Bradley‘s strikeouts prop and fading Griffin Canning in the same market.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 17.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Canning under 4.5 strikeouts (-118)

Canning isn’t a flashy guy to have a bet on, but don’t let the lack of brand recognition get in the way of a logical fade.

A perennial back-of-rotation starter, Canning used to at least hover around the 9.0 K/9 rate on an annual basis. But he dipped to a 6.8 K/9 last year, and I’m not confident in him to bump the rate back up.

Canning is trying to simplify things in 2025, cutting the curveball out of his arsenal and sticking to a three-pitch mix. His fastball has below-average velocity (93.3 mph, versus 94.5 mph as the MLB average for righties).

His slider is his out pitch, and he’s throwing it more than 40.0% of the time, per Baseball Savant.

But given that the St. Louis Cardinals — tonight’s opponent — have the fourth-lowest whiff rate on sliders (27.9%), I doubt we’ll see him rack up strikeouts.

St. Louis also has the fifth-lowest K rate in the majors (19.5%). Five consecutive starters have gone under 4.5 Ks against the Cardinals.

Expect Canning to be the sixth.

Key stat: Since the start of last season, Canning has gone under 4.5 Ks in 23 of 34 starts (67.6%).

Best MLB picks

Bradley over 6.5 Ks (-118): Three starts into 2025, Bradley has deployed a balanced attack from the mound, and it’s been effective.

  • All four of his pitches have a whiff rate between 25.0% and 28.6%. That means none of them have been elite, but each of them (four-seamer, cutter, splitter, curveball) can be called upon based on feel.
  • Bradley has exactly seven Ks in all three starts.
  • His 30.9% K rate ranks in the 84th percentile.

I’m not blown away by Bradley’s pitch metrics, but I am inclined to back him in a plus matchup against the free-swinging New York Yankees.

The Yankees have the sixth-highest K rate (24.6%) and the third-highest whiff rate (28.3%) in MLB.

Bradley struck out seven over 6.0 innings when he faced the Yankees at home a season ago.

Witt over 0.5 runs (+100): Witt is really, really good. Let’s start there.

Last year’s AL MVP runner-up ranks in the 99th percentile in xBA (.349) and 95th percentile in xwOBA (.423).

So far this season, Witt is batting .310 and currently owns a nine-game hit streak. He has also scored in eight of his past 13 games.

What really pushes this pick over the line for me is Witt’s history against Detroit Tigers starter Reese Olson:

  • 6-for-11 (.545)
  • 4 extra-base hits (2 HRs)
  • .926 xSLG
  • 99.5 mph average exit velocity

MLB prop picks made at 11:31 a.m. ET on 04/17/2025.

Rockies vs. Dodgers SGP predictions April 16: Back Mookie Betts in +510 SGP

Rockies vs. Dodgers predictions

The Los Angeles Dodgers and Colorado Rockies close out Wednesday’s MLB slate.

The pregame narrative: Los Angeles is the clear-cut World Series favourite, and Colorado is a no-doubt bottom-feeder. But I’ll still take the Rockies to cover a +2.5 run line alongside Mookie Betts and Kyle Farmer props in this +510 SGP.

Check out my Rockies vs. Dodgers SGP predictions for April 16.

Rockies vs. Dodgers predictions

Parlay: Rockies +2.5 | Betts over 1.5 bases | Farmer 1+ hits (+510)

Embed: #112600

Rockies +2.5 (-136): Backing the Rockies in any capacity is scary, let alone against a juggernaut like the Dodgers.

Colorado is 3-14 with a league-worst -50 run differential and has been outscored 27-5 on aggregate during its five-game losing streak.

Okay, let’s take a deep breath.

Los Angeles has one of the best rotations in baseball when healthy, but Blake Snell is on the injured list and Shohei Ohtani isn’t quite ready to toe the rubber. That means Bobby Miller gets the ball for the Dodgers tonight.

Miller made 13 starts for L.A. in 2024 and posted an unsightly 8.52 ERA in 56.0 IP. That includes a start against Colorado where he allowed nine baserunners and five runs in 6.1 IP.

Rockies starter German Marquez, meanwhile, has held this current Dodgers lineup to a .216 batting average in 189 plate appearances.

Let’s hope that pitching mismatch is enough to get this over the line.

MLB SGP legs

Betts over 1.5 bases (+114): I don’t expect L.A.’s bats to go completely quiet on Wednesday.

Betts is one of the few Dodgers who has gotten after Marquez, and I want to tap into that. He’s 7-for-22 against the righty (.318) with one home run.

And the shortstop’s .377 xBA and .583 xSLG, courtesy of Baseball Savant, indicate he should be even more successful.

Betts went 0-for-5 last night but was 2-for-4 with a double and a home run the game before that. I’ll happily bank a perennial MVP candidate to go over 1.5 bases at plus money.

Farmer 1+ hit (-175): I’ll be pretty upset if Farmer is the one to sink this wager.

  • Farmer is batting .340 away from the hitter-friendly confines of Coors Field this season.
  • He has a knock in 11 of 16 games in 2025.

Farmer went 0-for-4 last night but hasn’t gone hitless in back-to-back games this season.

Rockies vs. Dodgers predictions made at 3:16 p.m. ET on 04/16/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 16: Bet on Trevor Story, Taylor Ward and Bobby Witt Jr.

MLB prop bets

I’m targeting three hitters in Wednesday’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Taylor Ward has a plus matchup against one of the league’s biggest punching bags. I’m betting on him to mash alongside Bobby Witt Jr. and Trevor Story.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 16.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Ward over 1.5 bases (-121)

Everyone in the Los Angeles Angels’ clubhouse should be salivating at tonight’s matchup.

Patrick Corbin is on the mound for the Texas Rangers, and it’s a miracle he’s still playing in the big leagues. Check out the lefty’s numbers over the last four seasons:

  • 5.71 ERA
  • .295 opponent BA
  • 4.99 FIP
  • 1.62 HR/9

His 5.71 ERA and .295 opponent BA are the worst among 156 qualified pitchers, according to FanGraphs. Corbin’s talent is that he eats innings — he’s thrown north of 150 in the last four seasons — and that’s what Texas is asking him to do tonight.

I was originally looking at bigger names like Mike Trout or Jorge Soler, but I believe Ward has the best chance of doing damage tonight.

L.A.’s leadoff man rakes against lefties and will get the most possible plate appearances against Corbin. He also has five home runs in his last six games.

Key stat: Ward is batting .325 with a 146 wRC+ against LHPs since 2024.

Best MLB picks

Witt to score (+105): Bettors should look toward Witt’s run prop anytime it’s at plus money. And I’m ready to pounce on tonight’s matchup against the New York Yankees and Clarke Schmidt.

Last year’s AL MVP runner-up is off to a hot start, batting .313 with 11 runs in 18 games. That sounds pretty good, but the scary thing is that he’s not playing near his ceiling.

Schmidt is making his first start of the season after recovering from a shoulder injury. He posted a stellar 2.85 ERA last year, though the underlying metrics weren’t quite as impressive:

  • 3.78 xERA (58th percentile)
  • 8.5% walk rate (41st percentile)

The righty did have a 26.3% K rate (74th percentile), but Witt is one of the league’s best contact hitters. I expect him to get on board and eventually score.

Kansas City’s current roster is batting .271 against Schmidt in 63 plate appearances.

Story over 1.5 bases (+128): Story started his year off by going 2-for-15 in March with a pair of singles. But since then, he’s been on fire.

  • .356 BA
  • .542 SLG
  • 2+ bases in 8 of 14 games

Boston’s shortstop is on a six-game hit streak in which he’s batting .423 with one home run and one double. Tonight, he goes up against Tampa Bay’s Zack Littell, who’s in a bad place.

The veteran righty has a 6.88 ERA through three starts and has given up 14 hits — and five home runs — in his last two outings.

MLB prop picks made at 1:31 p.m. ET on 04/16/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Best MLB prop bets April 16: Bet on Trevor Story, Taylor Ward and Bobby Witt Jr.

MLB prop bets

I’m targeting three hitters in Wednesday’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Taylor Ward has a plus matchup against one of the league’s biggest punching bags. I’m betting on him to mash alongside Bobby Witt Jr. and Trevor Story.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 16.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Ward over 1.5 bases (-130)

Everyone in the Los Angeles Angels’ clubhouse should be salivating at tonight’s matchup.

Patrick Corbin is on the mound for the Texas Rangers, and it’s a miracle he’s still playing in the big leagues. Check out the lefty’s numbers over the last four seasons:

  • 5.71 ERA
  • .295 opponent BA
  • 4.99 FIP
  • 1.62 HR/9

His 5.71 ERA and .295 opponent BA are the worst among 156 qualified pitchers, according to FanGraphs. Corbin’s talent is that he eats innings — he’s thrown north of 150 in the last four seasons — and that’s what Texas is asking him to do tonight.

I was originally looking at bigger names like Mike Trout or Jorge Soler, but I believe Ward has the best chance of doing damage tonight.

L.A.’s leadoff man rakes against lefties and will get the most possible plate appearances against Corbin. He also has five home runs in his last six games.

Key stat: Ward is batting .325 with a 146 wRC+ against LHPs since 2024.

Best MLB picks

Witt to score (+110): Bettors should look toward Witt’s run prop anytime it’s at plus money. And I’m ready to pounce on tonight’s matchup against the New York Yankees and Clarke Schmidt.

Last year’s AL MVP runner-up is off to a hot start, batting .313 with 11 runs in 18 games. That sounds pretty good, but the scary thing is that he’s not playing near his ceiling.

Schmidt is making his first start of the season after recovering from a shoulder injury. He posted a stellar 2.85 ERA last year, though the underlying metrics weren’t quite as impressive:

  • 3.78 xERA (58th percentile)
  • 8.5% walk rate (41st percentile)

The righty did have a 26.3% K rate (74th percentile), but Witt is one of the league’s best contact hitters. I expect him to get on board and eventually score.

Kansas City’s current roster is batting .271 against Schmidt in 63 plate appearances.

Story over 1.5 bases (+130): Story started his year off by going 2-for-15 in March with a pair of singles. But since then, he’s been on fire.

  • .356 BA
  • .542 SLG
  • 2+ bases in 8 of 14 games

Boston’s shortstop is on a six-game hit streak in which he’s batting .423 with one home run and one double. Tonight, he goes up against Tampa Bay’s Zack Littell, who’s in a bad place.

The veteran righty has a 6.88 ERA through three starts and has given up 14 hits — and five home runs — in his last two outings.

MLB prop picks made at 11:05 a.m. ET on 04/16/2025.

Braves vs. Blue Jays prop picks April 16: Bet on Austin Riley to rake in Wednesday’s matinee

Blue Jays picks

Spencer Strider makes his 2025 season debut Wednesday afternoon in a rubber match between the Atlanta Braves and Toronto Blue Jays.

The pregame narrative: You never know what you’ll get out of a pitcher coming off an extended injury absence, but Strider has shown plenty of positives in his rehab outings. I’m eyeing a pair of hitter prop bets, though, backing Austin Riley and fading Alejandro Kirk.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Braves for April 16.

Blue Jays picks vs. Braves

Best Bet: Riley over 1.5 bases (+105)

Riley is on a heater, and this is a solid price to back him at.

The third baseman is 4-for-8 at Rogers Centre in this series, and three of those hits left the yard.

He’s now riding an eight-game hitting streak, featuring some truly gaudy numbers:

  • 16-for-35 (.457)
  • 1.358 OPS
  • 7 extra-base hits
  • 2+ bases in 7 of 8

Riley is 3-for-11 with a homer against Toronto starter Chris Bassitt, which equates to a .545 SLG. His contact quality has clearly been good in this matchup, as Baseball Savant grades him at a .600 xSLG.

Key stat: Riley ranks in the 92nd percentile or better in xSLG (.593), average exit velocity (93.8 mph) and barrel rate (22.9%).

Quick pick

Kirk under 0.5 hits (+140): Kirk might not contribute much to Strider’s strikeout total, but I think he has a fair chance of going hitless on Wednesday.

Kirk ranks in the 37th percentile in xBA (.233) and in the 25th percentile in xSLG (.331). He’s been hitless in six of 13 starts.

As a right-hitting player, Kirk will have Strider’s elite slider running away from him. In 2023, that slider generated a 55.3% whiff rate (third among all pitches that year).

Strider has held righties to a .188 BA in his career.

Braves vs. Blue Jays picks made at 10:13 a.m. ET on 04/16/2025.

Braves vs. Blue Jays prop picks April 16: Bet on Spencer Strider to dominate in 2025 season debut

Blue Jays picks

Spencer Strider makes his 2025 season debut Wednesday afternoon in a rubber match between the Atlanta Braves and Toronto Blue Jays.

The pregame narrative: You never know what you’ll get out of a pitcher coming off an extended injury absence, but Strider has shown plenty of positives in his rehab outings. I’m backing the right-hander to cash a plus-money strikeout prop, and I also have picks on Austin Riley and Alejandro Kirk.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Braves for April 16.

Blue Jays picks vs. Braves

Best Bet: Strider over 6.5 strikeouts (+133)

Embed: #112580

It’s exciting to have Strider back in the majors, and I expect him to remind everybody just how good he is.

Strider’s last MLB outing came just over a year ago, after which he had season-ending elbow surgery before a long climb back to the Braves.

But unlike a hitter who may need time to adjust to big-league pitching again, I think Strider can get right back to top form on the mound. His stuff plays anywhere.

Strider’s fastball velocity is still a couple of ticks behind its top form, currently sitting at 95.7 mph after three outings with Triple-A Gwinnett. But it still averaged two additional inches of induced vertical break (i.e., rise) compared to the average MLB starter’s fastball, according to MLB.com’s David Adler.

After being essentially a two-pitch starter in his first two full seasons, Strider heightened his deployment of two additional offerings (changeup, curveball) during his rehab assignment.

With Gwinnett, Strider’s changeup had 32 inches of vertical drop — five more than he’d ever averaged in the majors. And his curveball had 12 inches of vertical drop, which was three more than he’d averaged in 2024.

Enough about pitch shapes, though. How has it all been working out for Strider?

I’d say the minor-league outings speak for themselves:

  • March 29: 3.0 IP, 6 Ks, 1 R
  • April 4: 5.1 IP, 8 Ks, 0 R
  • April 10: 5.1 IP, 13 Ks, 1 R

In his final start, Strider stretched out to 90 pitches and fanned 13 of 21 batters.

He’ll obviously face a tougher lineup on Wednesday, but he’s built up nicely and is accustomed to clearing this strikeout total at the MLB level.

In 2023 — his most recent full season — Strider went over 6.5 Ks in 27 of 32 outings.

Key stat: Strider’s 483 strikeouts from 2022-23 were the most among any MLB pitcher in that span.

Quick picks

Riley over 1.5 bases (+123): Riley is on a heater, and this is a solid price to back him at.

The third baseman is 4-for-8 at Rogers Centre in this series, and three of those hits left the yard.

He’s now riding an eight-game hitting streak, featuring some truly gaudy numbers:

  • 16-for-35 (.457)
  • 1.358 OPS
  • 7 extra-base hits
  • 2+ bases in 7 of 8

Riley is 3-for-11 with a homer against Toronto starter Chris Bassitt, which equates to a .545 SLG. His contact quality has clearly been good in this matchup, as Baseball Savant grades him at a .600 xSLG.

Kirk under 0.5 hits (+140): Kirk might not contribute much to Strider’s strikeout total, but I think he has a fair chance of going hitless on Wednesday.

Kirk ranks in the 37th percentile in xBA (.233) and in the 25th percentile in xSLG (.331). He’s been hitless in six of 13 starts.

As a right-hitting player, Kirk will have Strider’s elite slider running away from him. In 2023, that slider generated a 55.3% whiff rate (third among all pitches that year).

Strider has held righties to a .188 BA in his career.

Braves vs. Blue Jays picks made at 9:23 a.m. ET on 04/16/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 15: Bet on Bryce Harper and Kyle Tucker to rake on Tuesday

MLB prop bets

Two all-star hitters and one pitcher are the focus of Tuesday’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Kyle Tucker is on fire and faces a pitcher who is over-indexing, while Bryce Harper gets an A-plus matchup against Justin Verlander. I’m also backing Tampa Bay’s Ryan Pepiot to shove against the Boston Red Sox.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 15.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Tucker to score (-112)

Tucker has the focus of our MLB prop bets a lot this season — and with the way he’s playing, I see no reason for that to change.

The first-year Chicago Cub has been on a tear, hitting .307 with a 1.042 OPS through 19 games. According to Baseball Savant, he ranks in the 90th percentile or higher in…

  • xBA (.313)
  • xSLG (.663)
  • K rate (12.1%)
  • Walk rate (17.6%)

That’ll do. Tonight, he gets to go up against Randy Vasquez, who has had a peculiar start to the season.

The San Diego Padres’ righty has a 1.72 ERA through three starts, but the underlying metrics indicate he’s been incredibly lucky.

Vasquez has a 6.38 ERA (11th percentile) to pair with a 9.7% K rate (fourth percentile) and 19.4% walk rate (fifth percentile).

It’s a borderline miracle he hasn’t gotten touched up yet, and I think Tucker and Co. end that trend tonight.

Key stat: Tucker has scored the most runs (19) and has the 11th-best on-base percentage (.429) in baseball.

Best MLB picks

Harper over 1.5 bases (+120): Harper and Verlander will both be in Cooperstown when it’s all said and done. But right now, the two are in very different stages of their career.

Harper is one year removed from finishing sixth in NL MVP voting, while Verlander is struggling to find form with the San Francisco Giants.

The 42-year-old righty has a 6.92 ERA over three starts, and last year’s stats (5.48 ERA in 90.1 IP) indicate this isn’t a small-sample outlier.

Harper is 6-for-12 lifetime against Verlander and seems due to break out of a mini-slump.

Pepiot over 17.5 outs (-106): I turned to Pepiot frequently last season and want to back him against the struggling Red Sox tonight.

  • Boston has the second-highest K rate in MLB.
  • The Red Sox are 2-6 in their last eight games. In that span, they’re averaging just 1.9 runs per game.

You could make a good argument taking Pepiot over 17.5 outs or over 6.5 Ks. It’s a small sample, but he’s held the Red Sox to a .225 batting average with a 40.0% K rate in 35 plate appearances.

I’ll opt for the former, though. Boston’s offence is anemic, and Pepiot’s pitch count has climbed with every game.

MLB prop picks made at 12:22 p.m. ET on 04/15/2025.

Braves vs. Blue Jays prop picks April 15: Bet on Gausman to rack up strikeouts, fade Bichette

Blue Jays picks

Two aces face off at Rogers Center on Tuesday when the Toronto Blue Jays host the Atlanta Braves.

The pregame narrative: Kevin Gausman is off to a hot start and is a good bet to clear a modest strikeout total. Spencer Schwellenbach, meanwhile, has been borderline unhittable, which has me fading Bo Bichette.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Braves for April 15.

Blue Jays picks vs. Braves

Best Bet: Gausman over 5.5 strikeouts (+110)

Gausman is starting to look like his old self.

Through three games, the righty has a 2.33 ERA and 0.62 WHIP. The latter ranks second in all of MLB and has helped him pitch deep into ball games. I’m not asking Gausman to throw a complete game — though it would certainly help — and am instead banking on his swing-and-miss stuff.

In his last outing, against the Boston Red Sox on April 9, Gausman twirled an 8.0 IP gem where he gave up one run and had 10 strikeouts.

He fanned zero in the game before that against the New York Mets and had four against the Baltimore Orioles in his first start of the season. That’s pretty inconsistent.

So let’s take a look at his numbers, via Baseball Savant:

K rateWhiff rateChase rate
202331.3%28.9%32.6%
202421.4%23.3%29.8%
202520.6%21.3%34.8%

We’re early into the season, but it’s encouraging to see Gausman’s chase rate back near his 2023 numbers.

The Braves have the fifth-highest K rate in MLB so far (25.2%), so I like Gausman’s chances of having a Red Sox-type outing instead of a Mets one.

Key stat: Gausman has a 27.3% K rate against Atlanta’s current lineup (44 plate appearances).

Quick picks

Bichette under 1.5 bases (-150): I was looking for ways to back Schwellenbach, who is off to a Cy Young-calibre start (0.45 ERA, 0.65 WHIP), but wasn’t in love with taking the over on his 4.5 strikeout total.

That’s because Toronto has the third-lowest K rate (18.3%) and lowest whiff rate (21.7%) in MLB.

Then there was Schwellenbach’s outs prop, set at 17.5 with -200 juice toward the over. I think he clears that mark, but don’t want to pay the price.

So instead, I’ll turn to fading Bichette, who’s had quite a power outage to begin the season. Toronto’s shortstop is batting .297 but has just five extra-base hits (all doubles) in 17 games.

Bichette is 8-9 against this line and went 0-for-4 last night.

Braves vs. Blue Jays picks made at 12:23 p.m. ET on 04/15/2025.

Braves vs. Blue Jays prop picks April 15: Bet on Gausman to rack up strikeouts, fade Bichette

Blue Jays picks

Two aces face off at Rogers Center on Tuesday when the Toronto Blue Jays host the Atlanta Braves.

The pregame narrative: Kevin Gausman is off to a hot start and is a good bet to clear a modest strikeout total. Spencer Schwellenbach, meanwhile, has been borderline unhittable, which has me fading Bo Bichette.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Braves for April 15.

Blue Jays picks vs. Braves

Best Bet: Gausman over 5.5 strikeouts (+105)

Embed: #112562

Gausman is starting to look like his old self.

Through three games, the righty has a 2.33 ERA and 0.62 WHIP. The latter ranks second in all of MLB and has helped him pitch deep into ball games. I’m not asking Gausman to throw a complete game — though it would certainly help — and am instead banking on his swing-and-miss stuff.

In his last outing, against the Boston Red Sox on April 9, Gausman twirled an 8.0 IP gem where he gave up one run and had 10 strikeouts.

He fanned zero in the game before that against the New York Mets and had four against the Baltimore Orioles in his first start of the season. That’s pretty inconsistent.

So let’s take a look at his numbers, via Baseball Savant:

K rateWhiff rateChase rate
202331.3%28.9%32.6%
202421.4%23.3%29.8%
202520.6%21.3%34.8%

We’re early into the season, but it’s encouraging to see Gausman’s chase rate back near his 2023 numbers.

The Braves have the fifth-highest K rate in MLB so far (25.2%), so I like Gausman’s chances of having a Red Sox-type outing instead of a Mets one.

Key stat: Gausman has a 27.3% K rate against Atlanta’s current lineup (44 plate appearances).

Quick picks

Bichette under 1.5 bases (-139): I was looking for ways to back Schwellenbach, who is off to a Cy Young-calibre start (0.45 ERA, 0.65 WHIP), but wasn’t in love with taking the over on his 4.5 strikeout total.

That’s because Toronto has the third-lowest K rate (18.3%) and lowest whiff rate (21.7%) in MLB.

Then there was Schwellenbach’s outs prop, set at 17.5 with -167 juice toward the over. I think he clears that mark, but don’t want to pay the price.

So instead, I’ll turn to fading Bichette, who’s had quite a power outage to begin the season. Toronto’s shortstop is batting .297 but has just five extra-base hits (all doubles) in 17 games.

Bichette is 8-9 against this line and went 0-for-4 last night.

Braves vs. Blue Jays picks made at 12:23 p.m. ET on 04/15/2025.