The American League-leading Detroit Tigers are in Toronto on Friday night to face the Blue Jays at Rogers Centre.
The pregame narrative: Bowden Francis (2-5, 5.40 ERA) worked a quality start in his most recent outing, but it’ll likely be an uphill battle tonight against a Tigers team that is 15-5 in its past 20 games.
Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. the Tigers on May 16, featuring Francis, Jack Flaherty and Riley Greene.
Blue Jays picks vs. Tigers
Best Bet: Flaherty over 16.5 outs (-110)
The Tigers are one of the best early-season stories in baseball, as they’ve built off an unlikely postseason run from last year and currently own MLB’s best record (tied with the Dodgers).
Flaherty, who began 2024 with Detroit before getting traded, hasn’t done much to help the team the second time around.
In fact, he’s 0-5 in his past five starts, allowing 19 runs on 28 hits in that span (6.66 ERA).
This might seem like a good spot to fade him, but I’m going to zag because Flaherty is still seeing a decent innings workload despite his struggles.
- He’s pitched into the sixth inning or deeper in 6 of 8 starts.
- He’s averaging 15.4 outs per start.
In 18 starts with the Tigers last year (prior to the deadline deal to L.A.), Flaherty averaged 17.8 outs and went 15-3 against this prop line.
When he’s in a groove, I know Tigers manager A.J. Hinch trusts him to eat innings.
Toronto’s offence has been fine — 13th in wRC+ (101), 22nd in runs per game (3.98) — but not overpowering.
And though Detroit was off yesterday, its two best relievers had thrown on back-to-back days before that. Some length from Flaherty would be welcomed, and I think the Tigers will get it.
Key stat: Flaherty has held Toronto’s active lineup to 10-for-57 (.175) hitting with a .298 SLG and 20 Ks.
Quick pick
Greene over 1.5 bases (-108): Greene is red hot right now, and he’ll have a platoon advantage against a struggling pitcher on Friday night.
- In his past 19 games, Greene has averaged 2.6 bases while posting a .342/.400/.671 slash line.
- Greene, who bats from the left side, has a .921 OPS vs. right-handed pitchers this year.
- Toronto’s Francis has allowed 28 hits and a .663 SLG in his past four starts (18.2 innings).
Greene’s weakness is that he’s a relatively high strikeout guy, with a 19th-percentile K rate, per Baseball Savant.
But Francis only has a 19th-percentile K rate as a pitcher — to go with a fifth-percentile xBA and xERA — so I’m not worried about him mowing Greene down.
Francis under 16.5 outs (-118): Francis is 4-4 against this outs prop, and I’ll gladly lean on the side of the under in a matchup like this.
Detroit is likely to deploy five or six lefties in its lineup tonight, creating plenty of mismatches for the struggling Francis.
Handedness isn’t a trump card in its own right, but keep in mind that the Tigers have wielded a superb offence so far this season. They rank third in runs per game (5.55) and wRC+ (117).
Francis has a 6.25 xERA while allowing a .311 xBA. He’s also in the 20th percentile or worse in K rate, chase rate, hard-hit rate, barrel rate and ground-ball rate. Woof.
Not a single Jays reliever has pitched on back-to-back days entering Friday, so there should be ample options to look to if Detroit starts roughing up Francis.
Tigers vs. Blue Jays picks made at 9:30 a.m. ET on 05/16/2025.