Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets April 10: Fade Realmuto, bet on Witt and Ward to score

MLB prop bets

It’s getaway day in MLB, with five afternoon games and just one evening matchup on tap.

The pregame narrative: In the evening, look for J.T. Realmuto to struggle against an emerging ace from the Atlanta Braves. Earlier on, I like Taylor Ward and Bobby Witt Jr. both to score a run.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 10.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Realmuto under 0.5 hits (+118)

Spencer Schwellenbach gets the ball for the Atlanta Braves tonight, and this pick is a way to back him as much as it’s a way to fade Realmuto.

Let’s give Schwellenbach some flowers first, after the right-hander started Year 2 by torching his first two opponents:

  • 14.0 innings
  • 0 runs
  • 3 hits
  • 14 Ks

Schwellenbach ranks in the 85th percentile or better in xERA, chase rate, whiff rate and walk rate, per Baseball Savant. So his stuff backs up the strong start.

So what chance does Realmuto have to do damage? In my opinion, not a great one.

The catcher is 7-for-31 (.226) with nine strikeouts to start the year, going hitless in four of nine games.

Schwellenbach has six pitch offerings, and I’m hoping he leans on his cutter against Realmuto. Last year, righties batted just 6-for-32 (.188) against Schwellenbach’s cutter.

Realmuto was just 3-for-24 (.125) against cutters in 2024.

Key stat: Schwellenbach has held right-handed hitters to a .187 BA so far in his career (263 plate appearances).

Best MLB picks

Witt over 0.5 runs (-112): My initial instinct was to back Witt over 1.5 bases, but his run prop price is actually a bit better. Both options look like smash plays to me.

Witt hasn’t set the world on fire yet, but he’s off to a solid start with a .255/.340/.426 slash line (122 OPS+). And now he’ll face a pitcher who he’s dominated in the past.

Against Twins right-hander Bailey Ober, Witt is 9-for-19 with two triples and a home run.

As a whole, the Royals’ active lineup has been a nightmare for Ober: 33-for-105 (.314 BA), .600 SLG, 19.5% K rate.

Ober coughed up 14 runs on 19 hits in 13.1 innings against the Royals last season.

From the No. 2 spot in Kansas City’s lineup, Witt is in an excellent position to score.

Embed: #112343

Ward over 0.5 runs (+112): I can’t sugarcoat Ward’s start to the season. It’s been pretty ugly.

But that’s why he has such a compelling price today on his runs prop. And a .523 OPS through 11 games isn’t going to deter me when the matchup is right.

Ward and the Angels face Rays right-hander Zack Littell, who hasn’t fared well against L.A.’s active lineup in the past:

  • 62 plate appearances
  • 19-for-53 (.358 BA)
  • .642 SLG

Ward, who homered last night, is 2-for-5 with a walk against Littell.

His ability to succeed in this matchup, combined with the Angels’ overall success against Littell, gives me faith that the speedy outfielder can get it done.

MLB prop picks made at 9:45 a.m. ET on 04/10/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox prop picks April 10: Back Springer, Devers to drive offence in series finale

Blue Jays picks

After sweeping one NL East team and getting swept by another, the Toronto Blue Jays have a shot at sweeping a four-game set against the Boston Red Sox on Thursday afternoon.

The pregame narrative: George Springer and Rafael Devers are both off to wonderful starts in April. And they both have my attention on some plus-money plays today.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox for April 10.

Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox

Best bet: Devers over 1.5 bases (+107)

Embed: #112340

The sky was momentarily falling for Devers when the season began. But it’s a very long season, and the slugger didn’t need much time to right the ship.

  • March (5 games): 0-for-19, 15 strikeouts
  • April (8 games): 13-for-30, five doubles, one home run

So far this month, Devers has gone over 1.5 bases in five of eight games. He had a pair of doubles in last night’s extra-inning loss.

Devers hits the ball as hard as anyone, and he rarely chases. According to Baseball Savant, he has an MLB-high 71.4% hard-hit rate, as well as a 94th-percentile chase rate (17.1%).

He also has superb numbers against Toronto’s Chris Bassitt: 7-for-14, two doubles, three HRs.

In other words, this is an ideal matchup to see Devers continue his April surge.

Key stat: The left-hitting Devers has crushed right-handed pitching throughout his career. He owns a .286/.357/.553 slash line (138 wRC+) against RHPs.

Prop predictions

Springer over 0.5 RBI (+170): Springer has been a leadoff man for most of his career, but in 2025 he’s transitioned to a heart-of-the-order bat. And I’d say it’s going pretty well.

Through 13 games, Springer is batting .447 with a 1.336 OPS. He has notched an RBI in six of his past eight starts.

Boston starter Walker Buehler is off to a brutal start this season, allowing nine runs on 14 hits through just 9.1 innings. He just might be cooked.

If the Blue Jays can get to Buehler, Springer will have some chances to drive runners home. And with how well he’s mashing right now, this prop price is worth that opportunity to me.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox picks made at 10:28 a.m. ET on 04/10/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox prop picks April 9: Look for Bregman, Santander to cash in RBI props

Blue Jays picks

I’m backing one player per side to drive in a run in Wednesday’s Toronto Blue Jays vs. Boston Red Sox matchup.

The pregame narrative: Alex Bregman and Anthony Santander have both gotten used to batting with traffic on the basepaths, and I expect them to see some RBI opportunities tonight. At notable plus-money prices, I think both sluggers have value in this market.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox for April 9.

Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox

Best bet: Bregman over 0.5 RBI (+145)

Bregman doesn’t have very encouraging numbers against Toronto starter Kevin Gausman (2-for-12, one home run, six strikeouts). But there are some other aspects of tonight’s matchup that I really like.

For one thing, Bregman is seeing tons of RBI opportunities right now — and he’s making the most of them.

  • The third baseman is tied for 10th in MLB in plate appearances with runners on base (28).
  • In those PAs, he has a .357/.357/.714 slash line with 10 RBI.

Bregman bats third for Boston, and the two guys ahead of him have done well to get on base against Gausman. So there should be more RBI chances for Bregman tonight.

Jarren Duran and Rafael Devers are a combined 16-for-49 (.327) with 10 doubles and two walks against Gausman.

Even Boston’s No. 9 hitter, Ceddanne Rafaela, is in a groove. He has a .458 on-base percentage so far this month and will hopefully roll the lineup over successfully on Wednesday.

With all the potential for traffic on the basepaths, I’m buying Bregman’s opportunity over his head-to-head results with Gausman.

And hey, a sacrifice fly would do the trick, too.

Key stat: In 26 career games at Fenway Park, Bregman has 22 RBI and a blistering 1.194 OPS.

Prop predictions

Santander over 0.5 RBI (+162): This pick follows a similar formula to the Bregman one, but it’s not exactly the same.

Santander hasn’t been clutch whatsoever with runners on base, batting just .148 with zero extra-base hits in that situation.

But the opportunities from the No. 3 spot in the Blue Jays’ order have been bountiful. Santander has 32 PAs with runners on, which is tied for the fourth-most in the majors.

So, again, I’m buying Santander’s opportunity over anything else.

He’s been okay against Boston starter Tanner Houck, batting 4-for-14 (.286) with two walks.

And the two guys ahead of Santander, Bo Bichette and Vladimir Guerrero Jr., are a combined 8-for-24 (.333) with two doubles and two walks against Houck.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox picks made at 4:08 p.m. ET on 04/09/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox prop picks April 9: Look for Bregman, Santander to cash in RBI props

Blue Jays picks

I’m backing one player per side to drive in a run in Wednesday’s Toronto Blue Jays vs. Boston Red Sox matchup.

The pregame narrative: Alex Bregman and Anthony Santander have both gotten used to batting with traffic on the basepaths, and I expect them to see some RBI opportunities tonight. At notable plus-money prices, I think both sluggers have value in this market.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox for April 9.

Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox

Best bet: Bregman over 0.5 RBI (+163)

Embed: #112332

Bregman doesn’t have very encouraging numbers against Toronto starter Kevin Gausman (2-for-12, one home run, six strikeouts). But there are some other aspects of tonight’s matchup that I really like.

For one thing, Bregman is seeing tons of RBI opportunities right now — and he’s making the most of them.

  • The third baseman is tied for 10th in MLB in plate appearances with runners on base (28).
  • In those PAs, he has a .357/.357/.714 slash line with 10 RBI.

Bregman bats third for Boston, and the two guys ahead of him have done well to get on base against Gausman. So there should be more RBI chances for Bregman tonight.

Jarren Duran and Rafael Devers are a combined 16-for-49 (.327) with 10 doubles and two walks against Gausman.

Even Boston’s No. 9 hitter, Ceddanne Rafaela, is in a groove. He has a .458 on-base percentage so far this month and will hopefully roll the lineup over successfully on Wednesday.

With all the potential for traffic on the basepaths, I’m buying Bregman’s opportunity over his head-to-head results with Gausman.

And hey, a sacrifice fly would do the trick, too.

Key stat: In 26 career games at Fenway Park, Bregman has 22 RBI and a blistering 1.194 OPS.

Prop predictions

Santander over 0.5 RBI (+170): This pick follows a similar formula to the Bregman one, but it’s not exactly the same.

Santander hasn’t been clutch whatsoever with runners on base, batting just .148 with zero extra-base hits in that situation.

But the opportunities from the No. 3 spot in the Blue Jays’ order have been bountiful. Santander has 32 PAs with runners on, which is tied for the fourth-most in the majors.

So, again, I’m buying Santander’s opportunity over anything else.

He’s been okay against Boston starter Tanner Houck, batting 4-for-14 (.286) with two walks.

And the two guys ahead of Santander, Bo Bichette and Vladimir Guerrero Jr., are a combined 8-for-24 (.333) with two doubles and two walks against Houck.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox picks made at 3:08 p.m. ET on 04/09/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 9: Bet on Yusei Kikuchi, Joe Ryan to thrive

MLB prop bets

A pair of pitcher props from Wednesday’s MLB betting markets have my attention.

The pregame narrative: Yusei Kikuchi’s outs prop is juiced up, but I still think it’s worth backing as he looks to keep the slumping Tampa Bay Rays quiet. If you’re looking for a plus-money play, consider riding with Joe Ryan versus a team he’s excelled against before.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 9.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Kikuchi over 17.5 outs (-143)

If you’re willing to put up with this much juice, I think Kikuchi is well worth backing tonight based on a handful of factors.

  • Kikuchi’s bullpen needs a breather. Things got dicey for the Angels late in last night’s 4-3 win over the Rays. L.A. wound up using five relief arms, and now four of its eight relievers have pitched twice in the past three days.
  • He’s an innings eater. Kikuchi has tossed 6.0 innings in both outings to begin the new season. Dating back to last year, he has cashed this bet in seven consecutive starts.
  • He has strong numbers against Tampa Bay. Having spent his whole career in the American League — including two-and-a-half seasons with Toronto in the AL East — Kikuchi has seen plenty of the Rays. He’s held the active lineup to 17-for-80 hitting (.212 BA) with a .325 SLG and a 33.0% K rate.

It also seems like Kikuchi is catching the Rays at a good time. They’re on a five-game losing streak, scoring just 14 total runs in those matchups.

In the past week, Tampa’s offence ranks 24th in wRC+ (77).

Key stat: Kikuchi has pitched into the sixth inning or later in 12 consecutive starts (since August 2024).

Best MLB picks

Naylor over 1.5 hits/runs/RBI (-118): After a stellar spring training, Naylor has carried his success forward into the regular season.

The Mississauga, Ontario native posted a .375/.456/.542 slash line in 19 spring games with the Arizona Diamondbacks. And now he has an .819 OPS through 12 games in Year 1 with the club.

The left-hitting Naylor will have the platoon advantage today against Baltimore right-hander Dean Kremer, who’s been roughed up in his first two outings: 9.2 innings, 13 hits, eight runs.

Naylor is 4-for-7 with a double and a walk against Kremer.

And against righties so far this season, Naylor is 10-for-27 (.370) with four doubles.

Ryan over 5.5 Ks (+125): Both Minnesota Twins starters preceding Ryan cashed this bet, and I think he can make it three in a row.

Ryan has a 32% K rate against the Royals’ active lineup in 125 plate appearances, per Baseball Savant. Last season, his 27.3 K% as a whole ranked in the 80th percentile.

Hopefully the leash is a bit longer for Ryan tonight after back-to-back starts with a low-80s pitch count. He has 11 Ks through 10.0 innings this season.

In four starts against the Royals since 2023, Ryan has tallied 29 Ks in 24.1 IP, hitting this over three times.

MLB prop picks made at 2:25 p.m. ET on 04/09/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 9: Bet on Yusei Kikuchi, Joe Ryan to thrive

MLB prop bets

A pair of pitcher props from Wednesday’s MLB betting markets have my attention.

The pregame narrative: Yusei Kikuchi’s outs prop is juiced up, but I still think it’s worth backing as he looks to keep the slumping Tampa Bay Rays quiet. If you’re looking for a plus-money play, consider riding with Joe Ryan versus a team he’s excelled against before.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 9.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Kikuchi over 17.5 outs (-148)

Embed: #112327

If you’re willing to put up with this much juice, I think Kikuchi is well worth backing tonight based on a handful of factors.

  • Kikuchi’s bullpen needs a breather. Things got dicey for the Angels late in last night’s 4-3 win over the Rays. L.A. wound up using five relief arms, and now four of its eight relievers have pitched twice in the past three days.
  • He’s an innings eater. Kikuchi has tossed 6.0 innings in both outings to begin the new season. Dating back to last year, he has cashed this bet in seven consecutive starts.
  • He has strong numbers against Tampa Bay. Having spent his whole career in the American League — including two-and-a-half seasons with Toronto in the AL East — Kikuchi has seen plenty of the Rays. He’s held the active lineup to 17-for-80 hitting (.212 BA) with a .325 SLG and a 33.0% K rate.

It also seems like Kikuchi is catching the Rays at a good time. They’re on a five-game losing streak, scoring just 14 total runs in those matchups.

In the past week, Tampa’s offence ranks 24th in wRC+ (77).

Key stat: Kikuchi has pitched into the sixth inning or later in 12 consecutive starts (since August 2024).

Best MLB picks

Naylor over 1.5 bases (+145): After a stellar spring training, Naylor has carried his success forward into the regular season.

The Mississauga, Ontario native posted a .375/.456/.542 slash line in 19 spring games with the Arizona Diamondbacks. And now he has an .819 OPS through 12 games in Year 1 with the club.

The left-hitting Naylor will have the platoon advantage today against Baltimore right-hander Dean Kremer, who’s been roughed up in his first two outings: 9.2 innings, 13 hits, eight runs.

Naylor is 4-for-7 with a double and a walk against Kremer.

And against righties so far this season, Naylor is 10-for-27 (.370) with four doubles.

Ryan over 5.5 Ks (+117): Both Minnesota Twins starters preceding Ryan cashed this bet, and I think he can make it three in a row.

Ryan has a 32% K rate against the Royals’ active lineup in 125 plate appearances, per Baseball Savant. Last season, his 27.3 K% as a whole ranked in the 80th percentile.

Hopefully the leash is a bit longer for Ryan tonight after back-to-back starts with a low-80s pitch count. He has 11 Ks through 10.0 innings this season.

In four starts against the Royals since 2023, Ryan has tallied 29 Ks in 24.1 IP, hitting this over three times.

MLB prop picks made at 1:05 p.m. ET on 04/09/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 8: Look for Kyle Tucker, Jose Altuve to stay hot

MLB prop bets

Kyle Tucker and the Chicago Cubs draw an excellent matchup on Tuesday, which is why I’m backing him in one of my three MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Tucker has been everything the Cubs could ask for to this point, and his run prop looks like it’s oozing value tonight. I’m also buying the dip with Reds slugger Elly De La Cruz and hoping Jose Altuve can stay hot in Seattle.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 8.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Tucker over 0.5 runs (-106)

Happy Patrick Corbin day to all who celebrate.

Corbin has been the pitching version of a meat shield for several years now, and yet he still manages to find work.

Over the past four seasons, Corbin has the highest ERA (5.71) and the highest opponent batting average (.295) in MLB.

For prop bettors, he’s been the gift that keeps on giving.

With that in mind, I felt I had to bet on somebody facing Corbin tonight in his season debut. Tucker looks like a great option, with his absurd .327/.453/.712 slash line through 13 games.

Tucker, in his first year with the Cubs, has batted in the No. 2 or 3 spot in every game and scored 14 runs.

This is a lefty-on-lefty matchup, which typically works against the hitter. But Tucker’s .847 career OPS against southpaws quells that concern.

And if he finds a way on base, there are tons of Cubs who should be able to bring him around.

Chicago’s active lineup is 52-for-148 (.351 BA) against Corbin with a .601 SLG and just a 13.8 K%, per Baseball Savant.

Key stat: Tucker has scored in eight of his past nine games, posting a 1.478 OPS in that span.

Best MLB picks

De La Cruz over 1.5 hits/runs/RBI (+100): De La Cruz hasn’t loaded up many box scores yet this season. But he’s not lacking for pop.

He ranks in the 90th percentile or better in xSLG, barrel rate, average exit velocity, and hard-hit rate.

To put it another way, his .634 xSLG is almost 200 points north of his actual slugging percentage (.442).

I view this as a buy-low spot for one of MLB’s most exciting and toolsy athletes. He’ll bat from the left side — his preferred side — tonight against little-known Giants starter, Landen Roupp.

Altuve over 0.5 runs (+145): I cashed this prop at +160 odds last night, so let’s go back to the well with Altuve against another tough pitcher.

The Astros’ leadoff man doesn’t have stellar numbers against Mariners starter Luis Castillo (3-for-13, five strikeouts), but at least there’s plenty of familiarity in this matchup.

Frankly, this bet is much more about striking at a compelling price while Altuve’s bat is hot.

He has a .357/.400/.571 slash line through 10 games, cashing this bet in six of his past seven.

Yordan Alvarez is 8-for-17 (.471) with three homers against Castillo, so if Altuve gets on, there’s at least one viable candidate to drive him in.

MLB prop picks made at 4:05 p.m. ET on 04/08/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 8: Look for Kyle Tucker, Jose Altuve to stay hot

MLB prop bets

Kyle Tucker and the Chicago Cubs draw an excellent matchup on Tuesday, which is why I’m backing him in one of my three plus-money MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Tucker has been everything the Cubs could ask for to this point, and his run prop looks like it’s oozing value tonight. I’m also buying the dip with Reds slugger Elly De La Cruz and hoping Jose Altuve can stay hot in Seattle.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 8.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Tucker over 0.5 runs (+112)

Embed: #112279

Happy Patrick Corbin day to all who celebrate.

Corbin has been the pitching version of a meat shield for several years now, and yet he still manages to find work.

Over the past four seasons, Corbin has the highest ERA (5.71) and the highest opponent batting average (.295) in MLB.

For prop bettors, he’s been the gift that keeps on giving.

With that in mind, I felt I had to bet on somebody facing Corbin tonight in his season debut. Tucker looks like a great option, with his absurd .327/.453/.712 slash line through 13 games.

Tucker, in his first year with the Cubs, has batted in the No. 2 or 3 spot in every game and scored 14 runs.

This is a lefty-on-lefty matchup, which typically works against the hitter. But Tucker’s .847 career OPS against southpaws quells that concern.

And if he finds a way on base, there are tons of Cubs who should be able to bring him around.

Chicago’s active lineup is 52-for-148 (.351 BA) against Corbin with a .601 SLG and just a 13.8 K%, per Baseball Savant.

Key stat: Tucker has scored in eight of his past nine games, posting a 1.478 OPS in that span.

Best MLB picks

De La Cruz over 1.5 bases (+140): De La Cruz hasn’t loaded up many box scores yet this season. But he’s not lacking for pop.

He ranks in the 90th percentile or better in xSLG, barrel rate, average exit velocity, and hard-hit rate.

To put it another way, his .634 xSLG is almost 200 points north of his actual slugging percentage (.442).

I view this as a buy-low spot for one of MLB’s most exciting and toolsy athletes. He’ll bat from the left side — his preferred side — tonight against little-known Giants starter, Landen Roupp.

Altuve over 0.5 runs (+150): I cashed this prop at +160 odds last night, so let’s go back to the well with Altuve against another tough pitcher.

The Astros’ leadoff man doesn’t have stellar numbers against Mariners starter Luis Castillo (3-for-13, five strikeouts), but at least there’s plenty of familiarity in this matchup.

Frankly, this bet is much more about striking at a compelling price while Altuve’s bat is hot.

He has a .357/.400/.571 slash line through 10 games, cashing this bet in six of his past seven.

Yordan Alvarez is 8-for-17 (.471) with three homers against Castillo, so if Altuve gets on, there’s at least one viable candidate to drive him in.

MLB prop picks made at 11:05 a.m. ET on 04/08/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox prop picks April 8: Garrett Crochet should work deep against Toronto

Blue Jays picks

Garrett Crochet takes the mound for the Boston Red Sox on Tuesday night with the Toronto Blue Jays in town.

The pregame narrative: Toronto won the series opener but should have a tougher task in this game. I like Crochet to work deep and Kristian Campbell to score for Boston, while Ernie Clement has value as a fade candidate.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox for April 8.

Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox

Best bet: Campbell over 0.5 runs (+125)

This was my best bet on Monday, but Campbell had the day off. Assuming he’s back in tonight, I’ll gladly give it another go.

Campbell is one of those unique rookies playing with the comfort of financial stability. He signed an eight-year, $60 million deal with the Red Sox after just one week in the majors, and it’s easy to see why Boston ponied up.

The 2023 draftee has done a remarkable job getting on base. Through 10 games, he’s 12-for-33 with eight walks and a .364/.476/.667 slash line.

  • Campbell has reached safely in all 10 games.
  • He has reached base 2+ times in 8 of 10 games.

One reason this price is available on Campbell’s run prop is that he hasn’t been promoted within the lineup yet. The 22-year-old has been in the bottom half of the order each game, typically slotted into the No. 6 or 7 spot.

Still, his on-base capabilities create enough scoring chances that I’m content to buy in.

Campbell will face left-hander Easton Lucas, who was pushed back a day in favour of Jose Berrios. Lucas carved up the Nationals in his season debut, but doesn’t have a track record that worries me.

In two minor league seasons, the right-handed Campbell batted .340 with a .461 OBP against left-handers.

Key stat: Campbell has scored in seven of his past eight games, with 10 total runs in that span.

Prop predictions

Crochet over 17.5 outs (-150): One of the big knocks on Crochet last year was his inability to work deep into games. But that’s not completely fair.

Crochet was in his first year as a starter, and the White Sox made a midseason decision to curtail his innings workload.

  • First three months of 2024 season: 18 starts, 16.9 outs per start, 11 games with 18+ outs
  • Final three months of 2024 season: 14 starts, 9.6 outs per start, zero games with 18+ outs

I anticipate that being much less of an issue this year, especially since the Red Sox inked their new ace to a $170 million contract extension. Crochet is in Boston to shove.

Last year, prior to the innings restriction, Crochet threw 6.0 innings of scoreless, two-hit ball against the Blue Jays.

Clement under 0.5 hits (+145): Once again, this is a pick I made yesterday before Clement was held out of the starting lineup. But I like the play even more with Crochet on the bump.

Clement is just 2-for-19 (.105) this season. And his batted ball metrics at Baseball Savant suggest he’s earned those unsightly results.

  • 1st percentile xBA (.094)
  • 1st percentile xSLG (.146)
  • 2nd percentile hard-hit rate (12.5%)

Given that Clement also has an 86th-percentile walk rate (16.0%), this is someone who could easily add another hitless day to his ledger.

Clement is hitless in 15 plate appearances so far in April. He’s 1-for-2 off Crochet, but this price for an ice-cold hitter is calling to me.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox picks made at 11:10 a.m. ET on 04/08/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox prop picks April 8: Garrett Crochet should work deep against Toronto

Blue Jays picks

Garrett Crochet takes the mound for the Boston Red Sox on Tuesday night with the Toronto Blue Jays in town.

The pregame narrative: Toronto won the series opener but should have a tougher task in this game. I like Crochet to work deep and Kristian Campbell to score for Boston, while Ernie Clement has value as a fade candidate.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox for April 8.

Blue Jays picks vs. Red Sox

Best bet: Campbell over 0.5 runs (+128)

Embed: #112271

This was my best bet on Monday, but Campbell had the day off. Assuming he’s back in tonight, I’ll gladly give it another go.

Campbell is one of those unique rookies playing with the comfort of financial stability. He signed an eight-year, $60 million deal with the Red Sox after just one week in the majors, and it’s easy to see why Boston ponied up.

The 2023 draftee has done a remarkable job getting on base. Through 10 games, he’s 12-for-33 with eight walks and a .364/.476/.667 slash line.

  • Campbell has reached safely in all 10 games.
  • He has reached base 2+ times in 8 of 10 games.

One reason this price is available on Campbell’s run prop is that he hasn’t been promoted within the lineup yet. The 22-year-old has been in the bottom half of the order each game, typically slotted into the No. 6 or 7 spot.

Still, his on-base capabilities create enough scoring chances that I’m content to buy in.

Campbell will face left-hander Easton Lucas, who was pushed back a day in favour of Jose Berrios. Lucas carved up the Nationals in his season debut, but doesn’t have a track record that worries me.

In two minor league seasons, the right-handed Campbell batted .340 with a .461 OBP against left-handers.

Key stat: Campbell has scored in seven of his past eight games, with 10 total runs in that span.

Prop predictions

Crochet over 17.5 outs (-129): One of the big knocks on Crochet last year was his inability to work deep into games. But that’s not completely fair.

Crochet was in his first year as a starter, and the White Sox made a midseason decision to curtail his innings workload.

  • First three months of 2024 season: 18 starts, 16.9 outs per start, 11 games with 18+ outs
  • Final three months of 2024 season: 14 starts, 9.6 outs per start, zero games with 18+ outs

I anticipate that being much less of an issue this year, especially since the Red Sox inked their new ace to a $170 million contract extension. Crochet is in Boston to shove.

Last year, prior to the innings restriction, Crochet threw 6.0 innings of scoreless, two-hit ball against the Blue Jays.

Clement under 0.5 hits (+140): Once again, this is a pick I made yesterday before Clement was held out of the starting lineup. But I like the play even more with Crochet on the bump.

Clement is just 2-for-19 (.105) this season. And his batted ball metrics at Baseball Savant suggest he’s earned those unsightly results.

  • 1st percentile xBA (.094)
  • 1st percentile xSLG (.146)
  • 2nd percentile hard-hit rate (12.5%)

Given that Clement also has an 86th-percentile walk rate (16.0%), this is someone who could easily add another hitless day to his ledger.

Clement is hitless in 15 plate appearances so far in April. He’s 1-for-2 off Crochet, but this price for an ice-cold hitter is calling to me.

Blue Jays vs. Red Sox picks made at 11:10 a.m. ET on 04/08/2025.