It’s getaway day in MLB, and Thursday’s most compelling night matchup occurs in the Bronx when the New York Yankees host the Cleveland Guardians.
The pregame narrative: New York’s Max Fried (1.92 ERA) pitches opposite Cleveland’s Slade Cecconi (5.28) in this rubber match. The Yankees are heavily favoured to win behind Fried and their stellar offence.
Check out my Guardians vs. Yankees prop bets, featuring Jose Ramirez and Cody Bellinger.
Guardians vs. Yankees prop bets
Best Bet: Ramirez over 1.5 total bases (+128)
Fried is putting up Cy Young-calibre numbers, but I think Ramirez can tag him on Thursday.
- Baseball Savant’s advanced metrics suggest Fried has been lucky this season. His xERA (3.64) is 1.72 points higher than his actual ERA (1.29), which is the 27th biggest gap among all pitchers.
- Fried has allowed 14 hits across his last two starts (12.1 IP) and two home runs.
A prolonged regression should be coming for the southpaw, and it looks like that’s already begun to happen.
Ramirez has consistently been a top-10 hitter in baseball since 2017 and is putting together one of his best seasons to date, batting .327 with a .932 OPS through 58 games.
If that batting average holds, it would be the best mark of his career.
And not to mention, J-Ram has been destroying lefties this season (.423 batting average, 1.092 OPS).
Key Stat: Ramirez has cleared this line in seven of his last eight games.
Best MLB picks
Bellinger under 0.5 runs (-139): This line seems like a steal to me. If Bellinger were hitting in front of Aaron Judge, as he was earlier this season, I’d have my reservations.
But he’s not, Rotowire projected to bat third tonight — and the first-year Yankee is cold right now.
Bellinger has zero runs in his last five starts. He has just two hits in that span with two walks, and is batting a miserable .167 over his last nine games.
Cecconi is far from a dangerous arm, but the left-hitting Bellinger has struggled against righties this season.
He owns a .227 BA and .313 OBP vs. RHP and .333 and .375 marks vs. LHP.
Guardians vs. Yankees prop bets made at 10:38 a.m. ET on 06/05/2025.