Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets April 27: Pick Contreras to do damage in plus-money prop

MLB prop bets

Three unsung heroes look to cash plus-money picks in my MLB prop bets for Sunday.

The pregame narrative: Dansby Swanson is turning it around at the plate, and a juicy matchup makes him an eye-catching play. William Contreras is playing well and facing a pitcher he’s dominated in the past. Lastly, I’m betting on another big punchout performance from Max Meyer.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 27.

MLB prop bets

Contreras over 1.5 total bases (+125): Contreras started the year with only two hits in his first eight games. He’s been significantly better since the slow start to the campaign.

Contreras is batting .313 across his last 18 games, recording at least one hit in 17 of those contests. He’s cashed this wager in six games during this stretch and is primed for another two-plus base performance on Sunday.

Contreras’ Milwaukee Brewers battle the St. Louis Cardinals with Erick Fedde taking the mound. The catcher has done some significant damage against the Cardinals starter in 11 at-bats:

  • Seven hits
  • Two home runs

Expect Contreras to continue tormenting Fedde on Sunday.

Meyer over 5.5 strikeouts (-150): This is a tall task for most pitchers, but Meyer has been up to the challenge.

The Miami Marlins starter has been excellent in 2025. He’s beaten this prop in four of his five starts this season, totalling 41 punchouts on the year.

His last effort was his most impressive. Meyer fanned 14 Cincinnati Reds in six innings of work.

His Marlins battle the Seattle Mariners, who rank 20th in strikeout percentage (23.2%).

Meyer’s swing-and-miss stuff is elite, as he boasts 93rd-percentile whiff and K rates this year. He should be able to showcase his talents in Sunday’s contest.

MLB prop picks made at 12:40 p.m. ET on 04/27/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 27: Pick Dansby Swanson to do damage in plus-money prop

MLB prop bets

Three unsung heroes look to cash plus-money picks in my MLB prop bets for Sunday.

The pregame narrative: Dansby Swanson is turning it around at the plate, and a juicy matchup makes him an eye-catching play. William Contreras is playing well and facing a pitcher he’s dominated in the past. Lastly, I’m betting on another big punchout performance from Max Meyer.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 27.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Swanson over 1.5 total bases (+180)

These odds are too good to ignore for several reasons.

Firstly, Swanson is heating up as April closes. The Chicago Cubs infielder has a hit in five of his last seven games, with three extra-base hits during this stretch. His average is still a lowly .188, but it has climbed from .169 over the last 10 days.

He’s seeing the ball well and making solid contact. Swanson boasts an 85th-percentile hard-hit percentage (51.3), according to Baseball Savant.

The excellent defender faces off against a pitcher he’s seen plenty of in Philadelphia Phillies ace Aaron Nola. Swanson has 63 at-bats versus Nola, and he’s done the following:

  • 15 hits
  • Five doubles
  • Three home runs

The power he’s shown against Nola, combined with his impressive hard-hit rate, is encouraging for this prop.

I’m betting on Swanson showing off some power against a familiar foe on Sunday Night Baseball.

Key stat: Swanson has cashed this prop in three of his last four games.

Best MLB picks

Contreras over 1.5 total bases (+128): Contreras started the year with only two hits in his first eight games. He’s been significantly better since the slow start to the campaign.

Contreras is batting .313 across his last 18 games, recording at least one hit in 17 of those contests. He’s cashed this wager in six games during this stretch and is primed for another two-plus base performance on Sunday.

Contreras’ Milwaukee Brewers battle the St. Louis Cardinals with Erick Fedde taking the mound. The catcher has done some significant damage against the Cardinals starter in 11 at-bats:

  • Seven hits
  • Two home runs

Expect Contreras to continue tormenting Fedde on Sunday.

Meyer over 6.5 strikeouts (+117): This is a tall task for most pitchers, but Meyer has been up to the challenge.

The Miami Marlins starter has been excellent in 2025. He’s beaten this prop in four of his five starts this season, totalling 41 punchouts on the year.

His last effort was his most impressive. Meyer fanned 14 Cincinnati Reds in six innings of work.

His Marlins battle the Seattle Mariners, who rank 20th in strikeout percentage (23.2%).

Meyer’s swing-and-miss stuff is elite, as he boasts 93rd-percentile whiff and K rates this year. He should be able to showcase his talents in Sunday’s contest.

MLB prop picks made at 12:40 p.m. ET on 04/27/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 26: Pick Grant Holmes to cash plus-money prop

MLB prop bets

A pair of hitters and a pitcher are at the centre of Saturday’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Jonathan Aranda and Gavin Lux are enjoying solid starts to their campaigns. Both are excellent choices to cash the over on their bases props. Thirdly, I’m taking the over on Grant Holmes’ strikeouts prop.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 26.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Lux over 1.5 bases (-108)

Lux is absolutely hitting the cover off the ball heading into this contest.

Here are Lux’s numbers over his last nine games:

  • .484 BA
  • .645 SLG
  • 20 bases

Lux isn’t just a guy on a heater, either; he looks like a player who’s setting the stage for a breakout campaign. The Cincinnati Reds utility man is batting .316 in 2025.

There has never been much power in Lux’s profile, but the hope is he can do repeated damage against a pitcher he’s fared well against in the past.

Lux and the Reds battle the Colorado Rockies with Antonio Senzatela getting the ball. The Reds infielder is a strong 8-for-20 against Senzatela in his career.

Playing at the hitter-friendly Coors Field tonight won’t hurt his chances, either.

Holmes over 4.5 strikeouts (+105): This is a pretty fair line for a pitcher playing as well as Holmes.

The Atlanta Braves starter has been nearly unhittable, limiting opposing batters to a puny .169 batting average this season.

He’s also posted pretty solid strikeout numbers. Holmes has totalled 17 Ks across his last three starts, topping this number twice.

He battles an Arizona Diamondbacks lineup that does have the third-lowest strikeout rate in the majors (18.9%), but his stuff can still play against them.

Holmes’ best out pitch is his slider, which generates a 35.8% whiff rate. Arizona is right around league average in whiff rate against sliders (32.6%, 16th in MLB).

MLB prop picks made at 12:49 p.m. ET on 04/26/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 26: Pick Jonathan Aranda to cash plus-money prop

MLB prop bets

A pair of hitters and a pitcher are at the centre of Saturday’s MLB prop bets.

The pregame narrative: Jonathan Aranda and Gavin Lux are enjoying solid starts to their campaigns. Both are excellent choices to cash the over on their bases props. Thirdly, I’m taking the over on Grant Holmes‘ strikeouts prop.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 26.

MLB prop bets

Best Bet: Aranda over 1.5 bases (+185)

Aranda’s ability to hit for average and power makes him a solid choice to clear this prop on most nights.

The Tampa Bay Rays infielder is dominating to begin 2025. Aranda is batting an impressive .311 and isn’t just relying on weak contact to reach base.

  • 8 doubles (t-10th in MLB)
  • 4 home runs (t-51st)
  • .581 SLG (9th)

Overall, his 12 extra-base hits this season are tied for 15th in the majors. Aranda’s knack for swatting extra-base hits makes him a threat to cash this wager in one plate appearance.

Additionally, a glance at his Baseball Savant pages shows that this success is no fluke. Check out Aranda’s percentile rankings in some key batted-ball metrics:

  • 98th percentile xSLG (.645)
  • 96th percentile average exit velocity (94.8 mph)
  • 99th percentile hard hit rate (61.4%)
  • 90th percentile barrel rate (17.5%)

The reason why his outlook is especially appealing tonight is the pitcher he’ll be facing. The Rays battle Dylan Cease and the San Diego Padres, and the righty has been dreadful to start the campaign.

Cease has a 6.04 ERA and is ceding a .289 batting average to opposing hitters.

Bet on Aranda to take advantage in a plus matchup.

Key stat: Aranda’s 43 total bases are tied for 41st across MLB.

Best MLB picks

Lux over 1.5 bases (+116): Lux is absolutely hitting the cover off the ball heading into this contest.

Here are Lux’s numbers over his last nine games:

  • .484 BA
  • .645 SLG
  • 20 bases

Lux isn’t just a guy on a heater, either; he looks like a player who’s setting the stage for a breakout campaign. The Cincinnati Reds utility man is batting .316 in 2025.

There has never been much power in Lux’s profile, but the hope is he can do repeated damage against a pitcher he’s fared well against in the past.

Lux and the Reds battle the Colorado Rockies with Antonio Senzatela getting the ball. The Reds infielder is a strong 8-for-20 against Senzatela in his career.

Playing at the hitter-friendly Coors Field tonight won’t hurt his chances, either.

Holmes over 4.5 strikeouts (+116): This is a pretty fair line for a pitcher playing as well as Holmes.

The Atlanta Braves starter has been nearly unhittable, limiting opposing batters to a puny .169 batting average this season.

He’s also posted pretty solid strikeout numbers. Holmes has totalled 17 Ks across his last three starts, topping this number twice.

He battles an Arizona Diamondbacks lineup that does have the third-lowest strikeout rate in the majors (18.9%), but his stuff can still play against them.

Holmes’ best out pitch is his slider, which generates a 35.8% whiff rate. Arizona is right around league average in whiff rate against sliders (32.6%, 16th in MLB).

MLB prop picks made at 12:49 p.m. ET on 04/26/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 25: Back Atlanta’s Sale and sluggers Soderstrom, Springer

MLB prop bets

Toronto Blue Jays outfielder George Springer and Atlanta Braves starter Chris Sale highlight Friday’s top MLB prop picks.

The pregame narrative: Springer should deliver in a juicy matchup vs. the New York Yankees and I’m not shying away from Sale, who faces a tough challenge against the Arizona Diamondbacks. I also have a play on Tyler Soderstrom.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 25.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Springer over 1.5 total bases (+115)

Toronto’s offence is abysmal. 

The Blue Jays were held to two runs over a three-game sweep to the Houston Astros in their most recent series and rank 25th in MLB in runs per game. 

Nearly every player is underperforming in the power department, but Springer isn’t one of them. 

The veteran is off to a sizzling start following the worst season of his career. 

He’s in the 80th percentile or better in several key hitting metrics, per Baseball Savant, and has been Toronto’s best hitter through the first month. 

Stat20242025
AVG.220.333
SLG.371.536
OPS.674.956
Hard-hit rate37.4%52.0%
Exit velocity (mph)87.592.0

The Blue Jays’ offence is presented with a good opportunity to bounce back in the Bronx against Yankees starter Carlos Carrasco. 

The 38-year-old has a 6.53 ERA through five appearances (four starts) after two horrific seasons. Carrasco put up a 6.18 ERA and 1.54 WHIP from 2023-24, a span of 41 starts. 

He doesn’t miss bats anymore, and his home park won’t do him any favours. 

While Springer hasn’t had great success against Carrasco (.589 OPS in 26 career plate appearances), he has seen him plenty and will be familiar with his diminished repertoire. 

At a good hitter’s park, Springer is a Blue Jay worth targeting. 

Key stat: Springer has topped 1.5 total bases in 63.2% of his starts, according to Team Rankings. That’s second in MLB to Aaron Judge.

Best MLB picks

Sale over 5.5 Ks (-134): The Diamondbacks were the fourth-most difficult team in the majors to retire on strikes last year. 

This year, they have the second-lowest K rate and by far the lowest vs. left-handed pitchers. 

But Sale isn’t like most pitchers, and there won’t be many times this season to get him at this price on a 5.5 K line. 

  • Sale led all starters with a 32.1 K% last season (10% better than league average). 
  • The southpaw was at 29.4% in 2023 and comes into tonight with a 29.1% K rate. 

Sale is elite at missing bats and has cleared this line in three of five starts despite going no more than five innings. The two times he fell short were five-strikeout outings.

Soderstrom over 0.5 RBI (+137): The 23-year-old enters tonight with a .970 OPS and is tied for the MLB lead with nine homers.

Soderstrom plays at what’s been a hitter-friendly environment (Sutter Health Park) and bats third behind two good bats in Lawrence Butler and Brent Rooker.

As of early Friday afternoon, Butler is -150 to score and Rooker is -134.

Soderstrom’s Athletics face righty Sean Burke and the Chicago White Sox tonight. Burke got the Athletics two starts ago, allowing six hits, five runs and a pair of homers.

One of those bombs was to Soderstrom, who’s demolishing right-handers: .319/.398/.694, eight HR.

MLB prop picks made at 1:14 p.m. ET on 04/25/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees prop picks April 25: Bet on Jose Berrios and Ben Rice

Blue Jays picks

After Thursday’s off-day, the Toronto Blue Jays are in the Bronx for their first matchup of the year against the New York Yankees.

The pregame narrative: It’s been a bumpy ride so far for Jose Berrios, and I think that’ll continue on Friday. That’s why I’ve got my eye on Ben Rice‘s bases prop — but I’m still backing Berrios in some form.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Yankees for April 25.

Blue Jays picks vs. Yankees

Best Bet: Rice over 1.5 hits/runs/RBI (-118)

I wanted action on Aaron Judge tonight. I really did.

But his prop prices to score a run (-195), notch an RBI (-109) and clear 2.5 bases (+107) were just too steep for my liking.

That’s why I’m turning to Rice, who you may never have heard of if you don’t follow the Yankees.

Rice is New York’s leadoff man, which means he bats right in front of Judge. That should offer plenty of protection, given that Judge has a 1.247 OPS through 25 games.

Rice is having his own fun in the early stages of Year 2 as a big-leaguer. He’s batting .288 with a 1.005 OPS through 22 games. And his .315 ISO ranks ninth in the majors — one spot behind Judge.

I’d love to describe Rice’s Baseball Savant page, but I think it’s better just to show it:

He’s tattooing the ball, and I like his chances of keeping that up against the mercurial Berrios.

Berrios has a 5.02 ERA and an .851 opponent OPS through five starts. He’s pitched at Yankee Stadium twice over the previous two seasons, allowing 10 runs on 14 hits in 10.2 innings.

Key stat: The left-hitting Rice has a .340/.468/.680 slash line against right-handed pitchers this year (62 plate appearances).

Quick pick

Berrios over 4.5 Ks (-163): I don’t have high hopes for Berrios in this start, but I do think he can cash this strikeouts prop while probably also getting knocked around the park a bit.

  • This just isn’t a very lofty total for a starting pitcher that consistently tosses 5.0 innings or more (as Berrios has done in all five starts this season.
  • Berrios is averaging 4.8 Ks per outing so far, cashing this bet in 3 of 5 games.
  • In his past five outings against New York (since May 2023), Berrios has 38 Ks in 30.1 IP. He had 6+ Ks in each of those outings.

New York has the third-highest K rate in the majors (25.1%). So again, although I’m not bullish on Berrios to shut down the Yanks, I do expect him to miss a few bats along the way.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees picks made at 2:30 p.m. ET on 04/25/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees prop picks April 25: Bet on Jose Berrios and Ben Rice

Blue Jays picks

After Thursday’s off-day, the Toronto Blue Jays are in the Bronx for their first matchup of the year against the New York Yankees.

The pregame narrative: It’s been a bumpy ride so far for Jose Berrios, and I think that’ll continue on Friday. That’s why I’ve got my eye on Ben Rice‘s bases prop — but I’m still backing Berrios in some form.

Check out my Blue Jays picks vs. Yankees for April 25.

Blue Jays picks vs. Yankees

Best Bet: Rice over 1.5 bases (+160)

I wanted action on Aaron Judge tonight. I really did.

But his prop prices to score a run (-195), notch an RBI (-109) and clear 2.5 bases (+107) were just too steep for my liking.

That’s why I’m turning to Rice, who you may never have heard of if you don’t follow the Yankees.

Rice is New York’s leadoff man, which means he bats right in front of Judge. That should offer plenty of protection, given that Judge has a 1.247 OPS through 25 games.

Rice is having his own fun in the early stages of Year 2 as a big-leaguer. He’s batting .288 with a 1.005 OPS through 22 games. And his .315 ISO ranks ninth in the majors — one spot behind Judge.

I’d love to describe Rice’s Baseball Savant page, but I think it’s better just to show it:

He’s tattooing the ball, and I like his chances of keeping that up against the mercurial Berrios.

Berrios has a 5.02 ERA and an .851 opponent OPS through five starts. He’s pitched at Yankee Stadium twice over the previous two seasons, allowing 10 runs on 14 hits in 10.2 innings.

Key stat: The left-hitting Rice has a .340/.468/.680 slash line against right-handed pitchers this year (62 plate appearances).

Embed: #112980

Quick pick

Berrios over 4.5 Ks (-137): I don’t have high hopes for Berrios in this start, but I do think he can cash this strikeouts prop while probably also getting knocked around the park a bit.

  • This just isn’t a very lofty total for a starting pitcher that consistently tosses 5.0 innings or more (as Berrios has done in all five starts this season.
  • Berrios is averaging 4.8 Ks per outing so far, cashing this bet in 3 of 5 games.
  • In his past five outings against New York (since May 2023), Berrios has 38 Ks in 30.1 IP. He had 6+ Ks in each of those outings.

New York has the third-highest K rate in the majors (25.1%). So again, although I’m not bullish on Berrios to shut down the Yanks, I do expect him to miss a few bats along the way.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees picks made at 1:50 p.m. ET on 04/25/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 25: Back Atlanta’s Sale and sluggers Soderstrom, Springer

MLB prop bets

Toronto Blue Jays outfielder George Springer and Atlanta Braves starter Chris Sale highlight Friday’s top MLB prop picks.

The pregame narrative: Springer should deliver in a juicy matchup vs. the New York Yankees and I’m not shying away from Sale, who faces a tough challenge against the Arizona Diamondbacks. I also have a play on Tyler Soderstrom.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 25.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Springer over 1.5 total bases (+125)

Toronto’s offence is abysmal. 

The Blue Jays were held to two runs over a three-game sweep to the Houston Astros in their most recent series and rank 25th in MLB in runs per game. 

Nearly every player is underperforming in the power department, but Springer isn’t one of them. 

The veteran is off to a sizzling start following the worst season of his career. 

He’s in the 80th percentile or better in several key hitting metrics, per Baseball Savant, and has been Toronto’s best hitter through the first month. 

Stat20242025
AVG.220.333
SLG.371.536
OPS.674.956
Hard-hit rate37.4%52.0%
Exit velocity (mph)87.592.0

The Blue Jays’ offence is presented with a good opportunity to bounce back in the Bronx against Yankees starter Carlos Carrasco. 

The 38-year-old has a 6.53 ERA through five appearances (four starts) after two horrific seasons. Carrasco put up a 6.18 ERA and 1.54 WHIP from 2023-24, a span of 41 starts. 

He doesn’t miss bats anymore, and his home park won’t do him any favours. 

While Springer hasn’t had great success against Carrasco (.589 OPS in 26 career plate appearances), he has seen him plenty and will be familiar with his diminished repertoire. 

At a good hitter’s park, Springer is a Blue Jay worth targeting. 

Key stat: Springer has topped 1.5 total bases in 63.2% of his starts, according to Team Rankings. That’s second in MLB to Aaron Judge.

Embed: #112984

Best MLB picks

Sale over 5.5 Ks (-143): The Diamondbacks were the fourth-most difficult team in the majors to retire on strikes last year. 

This year, they have the second-lowest K rate and by far the lowest vs. left-handed pitchers. 

But Sale isn’t like most pitchers, and there won’t be many times this season to get him at this price on a 5.5 K line. 

  • Sale led all starters with a 32.1 K% last season (10% better than league average). 
  • The southpaw was at 29.4% in 2023 and comes into tonight with a 29.1% K rate. 

Sale is elite at missing bats and has cleared this line in three of five starts despite going no more than five innings. The two times he fell short were five-strikeout outings.

Soderstrom over 0.5 RBI (+138): The 23-year-old enters tonight with a .970 OPS and is tied for the MLB lead with nine homers.

Soderstrom plays at what’s been a hitter-friendly environment (Sutter Health Park) and bats third behind two good bats in Lawrence Butler and Brent Rooker.

As of early Friday afternoon, Butler is -152 to score and Rooker is -162.

Soderstrom’s Athletics face righty Sean Burke and the Chicago White Sox tonight. Burke got the Athletics two starts ago, allowing six hits, five runs and a pair of homers.

One of those bombs was to Soderstrom, who’s demolishing right-handers: .319/.398/.694, eight HR.

MLB prop picks made at 1:14 p.m. ET on 04/25/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 24: Back Angels starter Tyler Anderson, fade Arizona’s Corbin Burnes

MLB prop bets

Two starting pitchers and Dylan Crews make up Thursday’s top MLB prop picks.

The pregame narrative: Crews is getting hot and worth a play in a plus matchup. As for the SPs, I’m fading Corbin Burnes and backing Tyler Anderson.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 24.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Burnes under 5.5 Ks (-143)

The right-hander’s strikeout rate dropped off last season and it’s taken an even sharper dive through the first month of the season. 

Burnes isn’t far removed from a league-best 243 Ks in 2022, but he does seem far removed from being able to produce punchouts at that rate. 

His K% since that career-best mark isn’t pretty: 

  • 2022: 30.5%
  • 2023: 25.5%
  • 2024: 23.1%
  • 2025: 18.5% 

There’s time for the 30-year-old to turn things around, as he did in the final month last season, but this trend is far from encouraging.

Through four starts, 70% of the league has a better K rate than him, and 80% are producing more whiffs, per Baseball Savant. 

Tonight’s matchup is a tough one for Burnes, too.

The Tampa Bay Rays have struck out at a below-average rate versus right-handers, and they are punishing them. 

Only two teams have been better offensively against righties, per FanGraphs’ wRC+ metric, and the Rays’ .275 batting average vs. RHPs is tops in MLB.

Key stat: Burnes punched out eight in his season debut, but has recorded exactly three strikeouts in each of his three starts since.

Embed: #112948

Best MLB picks

Anderson over 17.5 outs (-106): The Los Angeles Angels southpaw has a favourable matchup against the Pittsburgh Pirates. 

Anderson has allowed no runs with back-to-back six-strikeout performances over his last two starts. Taking him to get six again is enticing as a plus-money play against a team that struggles vs. LHPs. 

But taking the over on his outs prop is the way I’m going. Anderson is 1-3 against this line, but his two longest outings have come in his last two starts. 

He cleared this in just over 50% of his outings in 2024 (he topped 5.5 Ks in 26%, for context), and the Pirates rank last in the NL in ISO. 

Only five teams have been worse offensively vs. lefties, per wRC+, and Pittsburgh is near the bottom in walk rate.

That’s especially important as Anderson has walked multiple batters in all four starts.

Crews over 1.5 total bases (+112): Things are finally moving in the right direction for Crews.

The 2023 No. 2 overall pick and consensus top-end prospect got his first taste of the bigs last season and enters tonight as a .209/.264/.342 hitter over 52 MLB games.

He went hitless in his first five games this year and was slugging .106 just 10 days ago. While still rough, it’s up to .325 now.

Crews has hit safely in eight straight, batting .333/.355/.667 with three home runs over that stretch.

With a platoon advantage, he’ll see a juicy matchup when his Washington Nationals take on Cade Povich and the Baltimore Orioles.

Right-handers are hitting .397/.453/.632 vs. the southpaw, who has allowed 30 hits in four starts and sports a 6.38 ERA.

Povich’s splits weren’t as pronounced in his rookie 2024 year, but his OPS was still 100+ points higher vs. RHBs.

MLB prop picks made at 1:30 p.m. ET on 04/24/2025.

Best MLB prop bets April 23: Back Oneil Cruz, Lawrence Butler and Bobby Witt Jr.

MLB prop bets

Oneil Cruz and Bobby Witt Jr. highlight Wednesday’s top MLB prop picks.

The pregame narrative: I like both to clear their total bases prop in juicy matchups, and I also have a play on Lawrence Butler to close out the 15-game slate.

Check out the best MLB prop bets for April 23.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Cruz over 1.5 total bases (+100)

The 26-year-old has stark splits. If he’s facing a southpaw, I’m likely to look the other way. 

Against a right-hander, though, the Pittsburgh Pirates centrefielder has my attention. 

  • 2025: .998 OPS vs. RHP; .441 vs. LHP
  • Career: .829 OPS vs. RHP; .614 vs. LHP

Los Angeles Angels starter Jack Kochanowicz has had no swing-and-miss ability at the MLB level. 

He has struck out 9.9% of the batters he’s faced over 15 starts since making his debut last year.

The league-average rate for starters was 22% in 2024 and is again this season. Cruz has K issues, so Kochanowicz’s lack of strikeouts helps offset contact concerns.

After Kochanowicz, the Pirates’ leadoff man will face an Angels bullpen that’s not formidable. 

Los Angeles relievers rank last in the AL with a 5.45 ERA and sport the third-highest HR/9 rate in MLB.

Key stat: Cruz has topped this line in five of his last eight games, raising his slugging from .391 to .486.

Best MLB picks

Butler over 0.5 runs (-138): Sutter Health Park, the Athletics’ temporary home, has been the second-most hitter-friendly stadium in MLB (according to Baseball Savant’s Park factors) so far. 

Butler is hitting for average, drawing walks at a high clip and striking out at a well-below average rate. 

He’s the leadoff man for the Athletics and has some thump behind him, including Brent Rooker and Tyler Soderstrom, who leads MLB with nine homers.

Here are Butler’s numbers compared to MLB’s league-average rates: 

  • BB%: 13.1 (9.2)
  • K%: 16.2 (21.8)
  • AVG: .279 (.240)

Butler is a threat to run, too, and get into scoring position if he gets on base, swiping 18 bags in 2024 and five through 23 games this season. 

The Texas Rangers are deploying Kumar Rocker, who has been disappointing, particularly his inability to miss bats (14 Ks through four starts, eight of which came in his last outing). 

Rocker is a big prospect who excelled in his limited time in the minors, but the 25-year-old is far from a high-end big league arm at this stage.

Witt over 1.5 total bases (-125): This isn’t a price I venture into often on a total bases prop, but I love the matchup for Witt.

The Kansas City Royals line up with German Marquez and the Colorado Rockies, who are an MLB-worst 4-18 and allowing the second-most runs per game (5.59).

Colorado’s bullpen ranks 30th in MLB with a 5.16 FIP.

Marquez, who barely pitched the last two years, had a good first start but has proceeded to do this:

  • April 5 vs. ATH: 5.0 IP, 5 H, 4 R, 6 BB, 3 K
  • April 11 vs. SD: 4.2 IP, 7 H, 6 R, 1 BB, 3 K
  • April 16 vs. LAD: 0.2 IP, 6 H, 7 R, 1 BB, 1 K

Witt has cleared this line in more than half of his games — only seven players have done so more frequently — and he recorded two-plus bases at the second-best clip last season (per Team Rankings).

The Royals star has logged at least one hit in 22 of his 24 games this season.

MLB prop picks made at 3:51 p.m. ET on 04/23/2025.