Connor McDavid headlines Thursday’s NHL prop picks.
The pregame narrative: Sometimes you just have to play the hits. McDavid is once again on a torrid pace, sitting top five in points after a monstrous November. Elsewhere, Morgan Geekie has a chance to add to his goal total against a struggling Jordan Binnington.
Check out my NHL prop picks for Dec. 4.
-> Join NorthStar Bets to start betting on the NHL
NHL prop picks
Best bet: McDavid 2+ points (+100)
There are a handful of players in the NHL that bettors can feel comfortable backing at this number, and McDavid is one of them.
The five-time Art Ross Trophy winner really hit his stride last month after a slow start (by his standards):
- October: 14 points in 12 games (4-8 vs. this line)
- November: 22 points in 14 games (8-6 vs. this line)
Edmonton’s offence is heating up again, and now McDavid gets to face a Seattle Kraken team the Oilers just beat on the road, 4-0, last Saturday.
McDavid contributed a goal and an assist in that game while playing a November-low 17:39 minutes.
-> Bet on McDavid and the Oilers tonight
The Kaken are a solid team, but they’ve gotten sketchy goaltending out of Joey Daccord recently.
The netminder posted a sub-.900 SV% in November and ranks a pedestrian 37th in Money Puck’s goals saved above expected.
Edmonton needs to get things rolling, and I expect McDavid to lead the charge at home.
Key stat: McDavid is averaging 1.5 PPG at home this year.
NHL predictions
Geekie to score (+145): Who would have guessed Geekie would be top-five in scoring heading into December? Not me, that’s for sure.
The Boston Bruins centre has 20 goals so far, good for second entering play on Dec. 4. That’s on pace to shatter his previous career high of 33, which he set last year.
-> See Thursday’s player prop markets at NorthStar Bets
Geekie is probably due for some regression given his sky-high shooting percentage (26.7%), but I don’t think it’ll happen tonight.
The St. Louis Blues are basement dwellers for a few reasons, and Binnington is high on that list.
- 3.20 GAA (45th)
- .878 SV% (48th)
Geekie has played his last three games without Davis Pastrnak, who is injured, and that hasn’t slowed him down. He’s scored three goals in those contests
NHL prop picks made at 1:30 p.m. ET on Dec. 4, 2025.