Category: MLB

MLB home run picks Aug. 20: Back Giancarlo Stanton and Willy Adames on Wednesday

MLB home run picks

The red-hot Giancarlo Stanton headlines Wednesday’s best MLB home run picks.

Today’s MLB HR narrative: Stanton mashed his 13th and 14th homers of the season last night, and now boasts a near-1.000 slugging percentage in August. The New York Yankee has a tough matchup against Tampa Bay’s Drew Rasmussen, but I still think he can come out on top.

Check out the best MLB home run picks and analysis for Aug. 20, featuring a pick on Willy Adames.

MLB home run picks

Best bet: Stanton to hit a home run (+375)

Stanton has improved month over month after a long IL stint to start the season and is going nuclear to close out August:

  • June: .243/.333/.270, 0 HRs
  • July: .284/.346/.635, 8 HRs
  • August: .417/.512/.944, 6 HRs

The towering DH still strikes out a ton and walks a lot, which isn’t ideal for a play like this. But when he puts bat to ball, the results are undeniable.

Stanton doesn’t have enough PAs to qualify, but his .542 xSLG, 19.8% barrel rate, and 56.3% hard-hit rate would all rank in the 90th percentile or higher, per Baseball Savant.

Now, he’s tasked with cracking Rasmussen, who owns a 2.60 ERA and 0.98 WHIP.

I don’t think a homer from Stanton is such a crazy ask, given Rasmussen’s questionable underlying metrics and the hitter-friendly environment of this game.

  • Rasmussen’s 3.44 xERA is much higher than his standard number.
  • His whiff rate, average exit velocity and hard-hit rate all rank in the bottom-25th percentile.
  • George M. Steinbrenner Field, the Yankees’ spring training facility and Rays’ temporary home, is ceding 33% more HRs to right-handed hitters than average, per Baseball Savant’s park factors.

Key stat: Stanton is slugging .643 against RHP this year and .613 on the road.

Best HR predictions

Adames to hit a home run (+375): It’s hard to get behind anyone on the Giants right now, but Adames checks a lot of the boxes I’m looking for.

  • Opponent: Lefty JP Sears is pitching for the San Diego Padres. His 1.8 HR/9 rate would be the second-highest in MLB if he had enough innings to qualify.
  • Platoon advantage: The right-hitting Adames is slugging .525 vs. LHP since the all-star break with two home runs.
  • Location: Petco Park has been the fifth-most homer-friendly venue for RHHs over the last three seasons.

Sears gives up a ton of hard contact and doesn’t issue many free passes. Adames is slumping big time this month, but still has some pop in his bat and the ability to capitalize on a bad pitch.

MLB home run picks made at 11:03 a.m. ET on 08/20/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Pirates best bets Aug. 20: Back George Springer in Wednesday’s series finale

Blue Jays best bets

The Toronto Blue Jays and Pittsburgh Pirates meet for a Wednesday matinee at PNC Park.

The pregame narrative: Toronto is favoured to win this rubber match behind Chris Bassitt, even though the righty has awful road numbers. Pittsburgh counters with Johan Oviedo, who’s making his second big league start since recovering from 2023 Tommy John surgery.

Check out my Blue Jays best bets vs. the Pirates for Aug. 20, featuring George Springer.

Blue Jays best bets vs. Pirates

Best bet: Over 8.5 runs (-112)

On a good day, Toronto’s offence is capable of clearing this number on its own.

The Jays lead MLB in batting average (.299), slugging percentage (.501), K rate (17.1%) and wRC+ (141) since the all-star break, and rank second in runs per game (5.94).

Unsurprisingly, taking the over during this stretch has been quite profitable.

  • Toronto is 19-12 on overs since the ASG.
  • That includes a 5-0 overs record when Bassitt is pitching.

Plenty of offence has become the norm, and I don’t expect Oviedo to quiet Toronto’s bats.

The righty has a career 4.36 ERA and was lifted after one inning in his return to MLB on Aug. 4, giving up two runs while walking three on 43 pitches.

And while Pittsburgh’s lineup is far from imposing, it should chip in on this effort.

Bassitt has gotten hit hard on the road, posting an unsightly 6.39 ERA across 11 starts.

Opponents are batting .298 against him, and his K rate plummets when he’s away from Rogers Centre (9.6 K/9 at home, 7.0 on the road).

Key stat: Overs are 12-8-1 in games where Toronto is a road favourite. That’s the second-best mark in MLB, per Team Rankings.

Quick picks

Springer over 1.5 bases (-106): Toronto’s leadoff man has picked up where he left off since returning from a 16-game injury absence, going 5-for-16 with two home runs.

The veteran outfielder was having a monster July before getting injured — .371/.451/.640 slash line, seven home runs — and should have plenty of opportunities to get after Oviedo today.

Oviedo relies heavily on a two-pitch mix, throwing a four-seam fastball and slider.

Springer has destroyed four-seamers from righties all season, batting .278 with a .556 SLG against that offering. And his expected numbers (.302 xBA, .676 xSLG) suggest there’s plenty of room for improvement.

On the whole, his numbers against RHP (.313/.397/.530) are much better than his numbers against LHP (.228/.345/.467).

Blue Jays best bets made at 9:02 a.m. ET on 08/20/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Pirates best bets Aug. 20: Back George Springer in Wednesday’s series finale

Blue Jays best bets

The Toronto Blue Jays and Pittsburgh Pirates meet for a Wednesday matinee at PNC Park.

The pregame narrative: Toronto is favoured to win this rubber match behind Chris Bassitt, even though the righty has awful road numbers. Pittsburgh counters with Johan Oviedo, who’s making his second big league start since recovering from 2023 Tommy John surgery.

Check out my Blue Jays best bets vs. the Pirates for Aug. 20, featuring Oviedo and George Springer.

Blue Jays best bets vs. Pirates

Best bet: Over 8.5 runs (-112)

On a good day, Toronto’s offence is capable of clearing this number on its own.

The Jays lead MLB in batting average (.299), slugging percentage (.501), K rate (17.1%) and wRC+ (141) since the all-star break, and rank second in runs per game (5.94).

Unsurprisingly, taking the over during this stretch has been quite profitable.

  • Toronto is 19-12 on overs since the ASG.
  • That includes a 5-0 overs record when Bassitt is pitching.

Plenty of offence has become the norm, and I don’t expect Oviedo to quiet Toronto’s bats.

The righty has a career 4.36 ERA and was lifted after one inning in his return to MLB on Aug. 4, giving up two runs while walking three on 43 pitches.

And while Pittsburgh’s lineup is far from imposing, it should chip in on this effort.

Bassitt has gotten hit hard on the road, posting an unsightly 6.39 ERA across 11 starts.

Opponents are batting .298 against him, and his K rate plummets when he’s away from Rogers Centre (9.6 K/9 at home, 7.0 on the road).

Key stat: Overs are 12-8-1 in games where Toronto is a road favourite. That’s the second-best mark in MLB, per Team Rankings.

Quick picks

Oviedo under 3.5 Ks (-129): This is a small number for a starter, but Oviedo has never been a big swing-and-miss arm and now gets the toughest matchup in baseball.

  • The righty has a career 7.9 K/9 rate, and has never crested the 50th percentile for K rate (per Baseball Savant).
  • Toronto has the lowest K rate in MLB on the season, since the all-star break, and against RHP.

Oviedo did rack up a 15-to-3 K/BB rate over two minor league starts this month, but I won’t put much stock into that.

The 27-year-old relies heavily on a two-pitch mix, throwing a four-seam fastball and slider. Toronto has the eighth-lowest whiff rate vs. four-seamers, and the lowest vs. sliders against RHP.

Springer over 1.5 bases (-120): Toronto’s leadoff man has picked up where he left off since returning from a 16-game injury absence, going 5-for-16 with two home runs.

The veteran outfielder was having a monster July before getting injured — .371/.451/.640 slash line, seven home runs — and should have plenty of opportunities to get after Oviedo today.

Springer has destroyed four-seamers from righties all season, batting .278 with a .556 SLG against that offering. And his expected numbers (.302 xBA, .676 xSLG) suggest there’s plenty of room for improvement.

On the whole, his numbers against RHP (.313/.397/.530) are much better than his numbers against LHP (.228/.345/.467).

Blue Jays best bets made at 9:02 a.m. ET on 08/20/2025.

Best MLB prop bets Aug. 19: Fade Tanner Bibee and back Jacob Lopez on Tuesday

MLB prop bets

Two starting pitchers and Jackson Holliday headline Tuesday’s best MLB prop picks.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Holliday is scuffling but has a great matchup against Walker Buehler and the Boston Red Sox. I expect him to contribute at the top of the lineup for his last-place Baltimore Orioles.

Check out my favourite MLB prop bets for Aug. 19, featuring a best bet on Tanner Bibee and a prediction on Jacob Lopez.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Bibee under 17.5 outs (-125)

The Arizona Diamondbacks’ lineup was left with two massive holes after unloading power bats Eugenio Suarez and Josh Naylor at the trade deadline, but the group has still been competent.

  • Arizona has above-average offence in the second half, sporting a 104 wRC+. 
  • The Diamondbacks have a top-10 slugging mark over that stretch and are 10th in batting average. 

Any lineup featuring Corbin Carroll and Ketel Marte near the top has big potential on any given night (both are top 15 in wRC+ this season), especially in Arizona.

Chase Field is one of the best hitter’s parks in baseball, making this a tough venue for Bibee to put a rough stretch behind him. 

Cleveland has been asking a lot out of its bullpen of late, but Bibee simply hasn’t been delivering. 

The right-hander has allowed four-plus runs in seven of his last eight starts. He has a 6.00 ERA over that span. 

Bibee’s homer rate has spiked this season, and his K rate has plummeted to a below-league-average number. He hasn’t cleared this line with any sort of consistency this season and is a strong fade candidate at this price.

Key stat: Bibee is 10-14 vs. this line, topping it once since the start of July.

Best MLB picks

Lopez over 5.5 strikeouts (-134): The Athletics left-hander is impossible to ignore at this number. 

In the second half, the Minnesota Twins have been a below-average offence with an above-average strikeout rate and they’ve struggled to hit southpaws all season. 

Not only are those conditions favourable to Lopez, but he comes in on fire. 

  • The 24-year-old hasn’t allowed a run in his last four starts.
  • He has gone seven-plus innings in consecutive outings. He struck out nine batters in his last start and 10 in the one before that. 

Lopez has been limited to 84.2 innings but has been one of the game’s best strikeout artists (87th percentile K rate). 

Only eight pitchers who have thrown 80-plus innings have a greater K rate than his 28.9% mark.

Holliday over 0.5 runs (-130): Let’s get this out of the way: Holliday is batting .161 with a .504 OPS this month.

But the second baseman is firmly entrenched as the club’s leadoff man and will bat at a great hitter’s park against a pitcher I don’t trust.

Buehler (5.43 ERA) has been better since July, but still walks way too many, doesn’t strike out enough batters, and has been clobbered by lefties.

Left-handed batters are hitting .317/.402/.458 off Buehler. Holliday will have a platoon advantage and has fared much better vs. righties (.734 OPS vs. .585).

Despite his struggles, Holliday has reached base safely in nine straight, scoring in five consecutive games.

MLB prop picks made at 12:55 p.m. ET on 08/19/2025.

Best MLB prop bets Aug. 19: Fade Tanner Bibee and back Jacob Lopez on Tuesday

MLB prop bets

Two starting pitchers and Jackson Holliday headline Tuesday’s best MLB prop picks.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Holliday is scuffling but has a great matchup against Walker Buehler and the Boston Red Sox. I expect him to contribute at the top of the lineup for his last-place Baltimore Orioles.

Check out my favourite MLB prop bets for Aug. 19, featuring a best bet on Tanner Bibee and a prediction on Jacob Lopez.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Bibee under 17.5 outs (-129)

The Arizona Diamondbacks’ lineup was left with two massive holes after unloading power bats Eugenio Suarez and Josh Naylor at the trade deadline, but the group has still been competent.

  • Arizona has above-average offence in the second half, sporting a 104 wRC+. 
  • The Diamondbacks have a top-10 slugging mark over that stretch and are 10th in batting average. 

Any lineup featuring Corbin Carroll and Ketel Marte near the top has big potential on any given night (both are top 15 in wRC+ this season), especially in Arizona.

Chase Field is one of the best hitter’s parks in baseball, making this a tough venue for Bibee to put a rough stretch behind him. 

Cleveland has been asking a lot out of its bullpen of late, but Bibee simply hasn’t been delivering. 

The right-hander has allowed four-plus runs in seven of his last eight starts. He has a 6.00 ERA over that span. 

Bibee’s homer rate has spiked this season, and his K rate has plummeted to a below-league-average number. He hasn’t cleared this line with any sort of consistency this season and is a strong fade candidate at this price.

Key stat: Bibee is 10-14 vs. this line, topping it once since the start of July.

Best MLB picks

Lopez over 5.5 strikeouts (-120): The Athletics left-hander is impossible to ignore at this number. 

In the second half, the Minnesota Twins have been a below-average offence with an above-average strikeout rate and they’ve struggled to hit southpaws all season. 

Not only are those conditions favourable to Lopez, but he comes in on fire. 

  • The 24-year-old hasn’t allowed a run in his last four starts.
  • He has gone seven-plus innings in consecutive outings. He struck out nine batters in his last start and 10 in the one before that. 

Lopez has been limited to 84.2 innings but has been one of the game’s best strikeout artists (87th percentile K rate). 

Only eight pitchers who have thrown 80-plus innings have a greater K rate than his 28.9% mark.

Holliday over 0.5 runs (-105): Let’s get this out of the way: Holliday is batting .161 with a .504 OPS this month.

But the second baseman is firmly entrenched as the club’s leadoff man and will bat at a great hitter’s park against a pitcher I don’t trust.

Buehler (5.43 ERA) has been better since July, but still walks way too many, doesn’t strike out enough batters, and has been clobbered by lefties.

Left-handed batters are hitting .317/.402/.458 off Buehler. Holliday will have a platoon advantage and has fared much better vs. righties (.734 OPS vs. .585).

Despite his struggles, Holliday has reached base safely in nine straight, scoring in five consecutive games.

MLB prop picks made at 12:55 p.m. ET on 08/19/2025.

MLB home run picks Aug. 19: Gunnar Henderson, Freddie Freeman are worth backing Tuesday night

MLB home run picks

Tuesday’s MLB home run picks feature two big names — Gunnar Henderson and Freddie Freeman — against two woeful pitchers.

Today’s MLB HR narrative: Henderson and Freeman are both swinging hot bats, but these predictions have almost as much to do with the pitchers they’re facing. Walker Buehler and Austin Gomber have been coughing up a ton of home runs in 2025.

Check out the best MLB home run picks and analysis for Aug. 19.

MLB home run picks

Best bet: Henderson to hit a home run (+475)

Henderson homered in last night’s series opener against Boston, building on a really nice run that started in late July.

From July 26 onward, the star third baseman is batting .304 with a .957 OPS. He only has four home runs in that span, but the contact quality has been excellent.

Case in point, Henderson has a .333 xBA during that stretch, per Baseball Savant. So his actual production should be even better.

Tonight’s matchup vs. Buehler should be a good one for Henderson, and that’s definitely a factor with this pick:

  • Left-hitting players are batting .317 with an .860 OPS against the right-handed Buehler this season.
  • Buehler has a 1.78 HR/9, which is the fifth-highest rate among 100 pitchers with 100+ innings of work.

For as rough as things have been at times for Buehler, it could actually be worse. His xERA (5.69) and xSLG (.482) both outpace his actual numbers (5.43 ERA, .462 SLG).

Henderson flirted with 40 homers last year, finishing with 37 en route to a fourth-place AL MVP finish.

He’s nowhere near that HR total this year, clubbing just 15 so far, but I’m buying in on his recent form and the Buehler matchup.

Key stat: Henderson ranks in the 91st percentile or better in bat speed, hard-hit rate, average exit velocity and xBA.

Best HR predictions

Freeman to hit a home run (+240): These odds aren’t particularly exciting, but I felt compelled to highlight someone on the Dodgers’ side against Gomber.

  • It’s not Gomber’s fault that he pitches for the Rockies, but it is his problem. He has allowed 17 extra-base hits (seven HRs) and a staggering 1.010 OPS in just five outings at Coors Field this season.
  • Gomber has allowed multiple HRs in all three starts this month.
  • Freeman is 6-for-16 with two HRs vs. Gomber, including a bomb to centre field in Denver last summer.

Lately, Freeman has powered up against the league as a whole, which is part of the reason he’s my target for L.A.

The first baseman has a .348/.416/.636 slash line and five homers in his past 18 games.

MLB home run picks made at 1:25 p.m. ET on 08/19/2025.

Reds vs. Angels SGP predictions: Bet on Hunter Greene to guide Cincinnati

Reds vs. Angels predictions

Sitting just outside the current MLB playoff picture, the Cincinnati Reds vie for a series win on Tuesday night against the Los Angeles Angels.

The pregame narrative: The Reds have won seven games in a row against the Angels dating back to 2023, including a 4-1 victory last night. Hunter Greene (5-3, 2.47 ERA) gets the start on Tuesday for the visiting Reds in his second outing back from the injured list.

Check out my Reds vs. Angels predictions, featuring a fade of Mike Trout in this +255 SGP.

Reds vs. Angels predictions

Parlay: Reds -0.5 F5 run line | Greene over 6.5 Ks | Trout under 1.5 bases (+255)

Reds -0.5 – first five innings (-106): I have more to say about Greene later on, but he’s also a huge reason why I like this pick.

When healthy, Greene is among the most imposing, dominating pitchers in the sport.

Among 99 pitchers with 200+ innings over the past two years, Greene ranks fifth in ERA (2.67), seventh in WHIP (0.991) and 12th in K/9 (10.33).

This year, he’s allowed two or fewer runs in 10 of 12 outings.

On the flip side of this matchup is Kyle Hendricks, who has a 5.45 ERA in seven starts since July 1. He has allowed three or more runs in 15 of 23 outings.

Also, the Reds have fared well against Hendricks in the past. Their active lineup is 25-for-74 (.338) with an .887 OPS against him.

MLB SGP legs

Greene over 6.5 Ks (-215): No matter what way you slice it, the Angels are the best possible matchup for Greene to rack up strikeouts.

The Halos have MLB’s highest K rate overall (26.0%), in the second half (26.6%) and against righties (25.8%).

Tonight will be Greene’s first start against the Angels, and I don’t think this lineup will enjoy the ride.

Greene sits at 99.3 mph on his fastball, per Baseball Savant, and ranks in the 85th percentile or better in whiff rate, chase rate, K% and BB%.

Backing Greene over 7.5 Ks pushes this parlay to +340, and I thought about it.

But since it’s only his second start back from a two-month injury absence, I’d rather play it safer in case he’s on a shorter leash.

Greene is 7-5 vs. this number this season with a 10.8 K/9.

Trout under 1.5 total bases (-186): Trout is one of the most prominent three-true-outcome hitters, but only two of those outcomes are happening on a regular basis right now.

In his past 17 games, Trout has one home run, 16 walks and 28 strikeouts. That’s a 63.5% three-true-outcome rate, which is nearly double MLB’s average (33.4%).

With so many walks and strikeouts lately, Trout is consistently failing to give himself a chance to collect bases. After all, he’s hardly ever putting the ball in play.

I expect more issues in that regard with the high-strikeout arm of Greene on the mound. Trout has gone 10 consecutive games without an extra-base hit.

Reds vs. Angels predictions made at 1:13 p.m. ET on 08/19/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.

MLB home run picks Aug. 19: Gunnar Henderson, Freddie Freeman are worth backing Tuesday night

MLB home run picks

Tuesday’s MLB home run picks feature two big names — Gunnar Henderson and Freddie Freeman — against two woeful pitchers.

Today’s MLB HR narrative: Henderson and Freeman are both swinging hot bats, but these predictions have almost as much to do with the pitchers they’re facing. Walker Buehler and Austin Gomber have been coughing up a ton of home runs in 2025.

Check out the best MLB home run picks and analysis for Aug. 19.

MLB home run picks

Best bet: Henderson to hit a home run (+475)

Henderson homered in last night’s series opener against Boston, building on a really nice run that started in late July.

From July 26 onward, the star third baseman is batting .304 with a .957 OPS. He only has four home runs in that span, but the contact quality has been excellent.

Case in point, Henderson has a .333 xBA during that stretch, per Baseball Savant. So his actual production should be even better.

Tonight’s matchup vs. Buehler should be a good one for Henderson, and that’s definitely a factor with this pick:

  • Left-hitting players are batting .317 with an .860 OPS against the right-handed Buehler this season.
  • Buehler has a 1.78 HR/9, which is the fifth-highest rate among 100 pitchers with 100+ innings of work.

For as rough as things have been at times for Buehler, it could actually be worse. His xERA (5.69) and xSLG (.482) both outpace his actual numbers (5.43 ERA, .462 SLG).

Henderson flirted with 40 homers last year, finishing with 37 en route to a fourth-place AL MVP finish.

He’s nowhere near that HR total this year, clubbing just 15 so far, but I’m buying in on his recent form and the Buehler matchup.

Key stat: Henderson ranks in the 91st percentile or better in bat speed, hard-hit rate, average exit velocity and xBA.

Best HR predictions

Freeman to hit a home run (+290): These odds aren’t particularly exciting, but I felt compelled to highlight someone on the Dodgers’ side against Gomber.

  • It’s not Gomber’s fault that he pitches for the Rockies, but it is his problem. He has allowed 17 extra-base hits (seven HRs) and a staggering 1.010 OPS in just five outings at Coors Field this season.
  • Gomber has allowed multiple HRs in all three starts this month.
  • Freeman is 6-for-16 with two HRs vs. Gomber, including a bomb to centre field in Denver last summer.

Lately, Freeman has powered up against the league as a whole, which is part of the reason he’s my target for L.A.

The first baseman has a .348/.416/.636 slash line and five homers in his past 18 games.

MLB home run picks made at 11:15 a.m. ET on 08/19/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Pirates best bets Aug. 19: Bet on Varsho to mash, Toronto to lead at F5 mark

Blue Jays best bets

Max Scherzer takes the mound for the Toronto Blue Jays on Tuesday night as they look to even their series with the Pittsburgh Pirates.

The pregame narrative: Scherzer has looked great in August and gives Toronto a good chance to take an early lead. In the prop market, Daulton Varsho and former Blue Jay Spencer Horwitz are worth backing on plus-money plays.

Check out my Blue Jays best bets vs. the Pirates for Aug. 19.

Blue Jays best bets vs. Pirates

Best bet: Horwitz over 0.5 runs (+125)

Scherzer has been solid but not dominant for the Blue Jays. None of his 10 starts have been scoreless, and with that in mind, Horwitz has as good a chance as any Pittsburgh player to score on Tuesday.

The ex-Jay has been the Pirates’ leadoff man for the better part of two months, and he’s put together some strong numbers lately.

Check out what Horwitz has accomplished in his past 25 games:

  • .326 BA
  • .388 OBP
  • .506 SLG
  • 14 runs

There’s a notable platoon advantage for the left-hitting Horwitz, too, as he’s posted a career .803 OPS vs. right-handed pitchers and a .516 OPS vs. lefties.

Scherzer, meanwhile, has allowed a higher OPS to left-hitting players (.753) than right-hitting players (.703) this season.

There’s nothing flashy about this pick, because Horwitz is far from a flashy hitter, but the price is compelling for a top-of-lineup guy with a platoon advantage who’s excelling right now.

Key stat: Horwitz has scored in 10 of his past 21 starts.

Quick picks

Blue Jays -0.5 – first five innings (-118): Toronto was level with the Paul Skenes-led Pirates through five innings yesterday. Tonight, I expect the Jays to pull ahead by the halfway mark.

Scherzer is off to a great start this month, with three quality outings:

  • vs. Royals (Aug. 2): 6.0 IP, 5 H, 1 R, 5 K
  • at Dodgers (Aug. 8): 6.0 IP, 6 H, 2 R, 5 K
  • vs. Cubs (Aug. 14): 7.0 IP, 5 H, 1 R, 3 K

Another performance like that would put Toronto in a great position to cash this bet. Especially considering the Pirates are scoring the fewest F5 runs per game (1.98), per Team Rankings.

Keller has been in much worse shape than Scherzer recently, coughing up 19 runs over his past five outings (7.54 ERA).

Varsho over 1.5 total bases (+125): Varsho has a lot of all-or-nothing in his offensive profile, but he mashes righty pitching pretty routinely.

The stocky outfielder is slugging .692 with 21 extra-base hits (13 home runs) in 35 games vs. RHPs this season.

He also has a .295/.404/.682 slash line this month after missing all of June and July with a hamstring injury.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is dealing with some hamstring tightness of his own, which should bump Varsho up from the heart of the order into the No. 3 or 4 spot tonight. That doesn’t matter much, but it could lead to an extra opportunity at the plate.

Keller has allowed a notably higher OPS to left-hitting players (.752) compared to right-hitting players (.650).

Blue Jays best bets made at 10:10 a.m. ET on 08/19/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Pirates best bets Aug. 19: Bet on Varsho to mash, Toronto to lead at F5 mark

Blue Jays best bets

Max Scherzer takes the mound for the Toronto Blue Jays on Tuesday night as they look to even their series with the Pittsburgh Pirates.

The pregame narrative: Scherzer has looked great in August and gives Toronto a good chance to take an early lead. In the prop market, Daulton Varsho and former Blue Jay Spencer Horwitz are worth backing on plus-money plays.

Check out my Blue Jays best bets vs. the Pirates for Aug. 19.

Blue Jays best bets vs. Pirates

Best bet: Horwitz over 0.5 runs (+125)

Scherzer has been solid but not dominant for the Blue Jays. None of his 10 starts have been scoreless, and with that in mind, Horwitz has as good a chance as any Pittsburgh player to score on Tuesday.

The ex-Jay has been the Pirates’ leadoff man for the better part of two months, and he’s put together some strong numbers lately.

Check out what Horwitz has accomplished in his past 25 games:

  • .326 BA
  • .388 OBP
  • .506 SLG
  • 14 runs

There’s a notable platoon advantage for the left-hitting Horwitz, too, as he’s posted a career .803 OPS vs. right-handed pitchers and a .516 OPS vs. lefties.

Scherzer, meanwhile, has allowed a higher OPS to left-hitting players (.753) than right-hitting players (.703) this season.

There’s nothing flashy about this pick, because Horwitz is far from a flashy hitter, but the price is compelling for a top-of-lineup guy with a platoon advantage who’s excelling right now.

Key stat: Horwitz has scored in 10 of his past 21 starts.

Quick picks

Blue Jays -0.5 – first five innings (-107): Toronto was level with the Paul Skenes-led Pirates through five innings yesterday. Tonight, I expect the Jays to pull ahead by the halfway mark.

Scherzer is off to a great start this month, with three quality outings:

  • vs. Royals (Aug. 2): 6.0 IP, 5 H, 1 R, 5 K
  • at Dodgers (Aug. 8): 6.0 IP, 6 H, 2 R, 5 K
  • vs. Cubs (Aug. 14): 7.0 IP, 5 H, 1 R, 3 K

Another performance like that would put Toronto in a great position to cash this bet. Especially considering the Pirates are scoring the fewest F5 runs per game (1.98), per Team Rankings.

Keller has been in much worse shape than Scherzer recently, coughing up 19 runs over his past five outings (7.54 ERA).

Varsho over 1.5 total bases (+120): Varsho has a lot of all-or-nothing in his offensive profile, but he mashes righty pitching pretty routinely.

The stocky outfielder is slugging .692 with 21 extra-base hits (13 home runs) in 35 games vs. RHPs this season.

He also has a .295/.404/.682 slash line this month after missing all of June and July with a hamstring injury.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is dealing with some hamstring tightness of his own, which should bump Varsho up from the heart of the order into the No. 3 or 4 spot tonight. That doesn’t matter much, but it could lead to an extra opportunity at the plate.

Keller has allowed a notably higher OPS to left-hitting players (.752) compared to right-hitting players (.650).

Blue Jays best bets made at 9:30 a.m. ET on 08/19/2025.