Category: MLB

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 7: Back Witt, Nelson and Trout on Sunday

MLB prop bets

Ryne Nelson has been solid all season long for the Arizona Diamondbacks, and he headlines my MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Elsewhere, Mike Trout and the Los Angeles Angels look for a bounce-back against the Athletics. Earlier in the afternoon, look for Bobby Witt Jr. to produce offence for the Kansas City Royals.

Check out my favourite MLB prop bets for Sept. 7.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Nelson over 15.5 outs (-125)

Nelson has been efficiently eating innings all season, and I think this is another chance for the Diamondbacks starter to work overtime.

In 19 starts this season, he’s averaging 5.2 innings per outing.

So on an average night, he’s clearing this line, but he can shove against the Boston Red Sox.

Boston has slowed down significantly since its midseason surge. The ballclub has lost three straight and was outscored 15-6 in the first two games of this series.

It’s a small sample size, but Nelson has dominated this Red Sox lineup. As a total, the offence is 3-for-23 (.087) off Nelson with no walks.

Key stat: Arizona’s starter has gone exactly 6.0 innings in three straight starts.

Best MLB picks

Trout to score (-150): Trout’s .229 batting average this season is far from spectacular, but his .363 on-base percentage is still very good.

He only has three hits in his last four games, but because of his 98th-percentile walk rate (16.3%), he’s 3-1 against this wager during that time.

On top of that, Trout goes against Luis Severino, and he has two hits and two walks in six plate appearances vs. the righty in his career.

Taylor Ward, Yoan Moncada and Zach Neto also each hit above .300 against Severino.

Those three usually surround Trout in the batting order and should be able to drive him home if given the opportunity.

Witt to score (-143): There is juice to pay here, but it’s well worth it with how Witt’s been playing.

  • Over his last 22 games, he’s scored 19 runs and is 16-6 against this wager.
  • Witt ranks 14th in the majors with 90 runs scored this season.

Plus, he has a nice matchup on Sunday vs. Bailey Ober and the Minnesota Twins. Witt has 12 hits in 28 at-bats (.429) against Ober in his career, with just three Ks.

Ober has been getting shelled recently, too. Over his last seven starts, he has a 5.97 ERA while giving up 12 home runs.

Even with the price, there is solid value on Witt in this spot.

MLB prop picks made at 8:20 a.m. ET on 09/07/2025.

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 7: Back Witt, Nelson and Trout on Sunday

MLB prop bets

Ryne Nelson has been solid all season long for the Arizona Diamondbacks, and he headlines my MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Elsewhere, Mike Trout and the Los Angeles Angels look for a bounce-back against the Athletics. Earlier in the afternoon, look for Bobby Witt Jr. to produce offence for the Kansas City Royals.

Check out my favourite MLB prop bets for Sept. 7.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Nelson over 15.5 outs (-125)

Nelson has been efficiently eating innings all season, and I think this is another chance for the Diamondbacks starter to work overtime.

In 19 starts this season, he’s averaging 5.2 innings per outing.

So on an average night, he’s clearing this line, but he can shove against the Boston Red Sox.

Boston has slowed down significantly since its midseason surge. The ballclub has lost three straight and was outscored 15-6 in the first two games of this series.

It’s a small sample size, but Nelson has dominated this Red Sox lineup. As a total, the offence is 3-for-23 (.087) off Nelson with no walks.

Key stat: Arizona’s starter has gone exactly 6.0 innings in three straight starts.

Embed: #117673

Best MLB picks

Trout to score (-108): Trout’s .229 batting average this season is far from spectacular, but his .363 on-base percentage is still very good.

He only has three hits in his last four games, but because of his 98th-percentile walk rate (16.3%), he’s 3-1 against this wager during that time.

On top of that, Trout goes against Luis Severino, and he has two hits and two walks in six plate appearances vs. the righty in his career.

Taylor Ward, Yoan Moncada and Zach Neto also each hit above .300 against Severino.

Those three usually surround Trout in the batting order and should be able to drive him home if given the opportunity.

Witt to score (-137): There is juice to pay here, but it’s well worth it with how Witt’s been playing.

  • Over his last 22 games, he’s scored 19 runs and is 16-6 against this wager.
  • Witt ranks 14th in the majors with 90 runs scored this season.

Plus, he has a nice matchup on Sunday vs. Bailey Ober and the Minnesota Twins. Witt has 12 hits in 28 at-bats (.429) against Ober in his career, with just three Ks.

Ober has been getting shelled recently, too. Over his last seven starts, he has a 5.97 ERA while giving up 12 home runs.

Even with the price, there is solid value on Witt in this spot.

MLB prop picks made at 8:20 a.m. ET on 09/07/2025.

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 6: Back Waldrep, Bader and Langeliers on Saturday

MLB prop bets

Rookie sensation Hurston Waldrep and Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Harrison Bader headline Saturday’s MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Bader has been on a tear since joining the Phillies at the trade deadline, while Waldrep has been nearly untouchable over six starts as a rookie. Both have plus-money value to do damage today.

Check out my favourite MLB prop bets for Sept. 6, featuring a pick on Athletics slugger Shea Langeliers.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Bader to record an RBI (+185)

Bader has been quite the get for Philadelphia, adding more firepower to an already loaded roster ahead of what should be a deep playoff run.

Check out what the outfielder has done for the Phillies since he was acquired at the trade deadline:

  • .304/.375/.500 slash line
  • .382/.452/.673 slash line vs. RHP
  • 52% hard-hit rate

Bader is slated to hit sixth for Philadelphia today behind names like Trea Turner, Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber. That’s an elite spot for run production

Today, the Phillies take on Sandy Alcantara and the Miami Marlins, and I think things could get ugly.

Philadelphia’s current lineup is batting .304 against Alcantara in a massive 286 at-bat sample. Alcantara is also having the worst year of his professional career, with a 5.66 ERA and 1.32 WHIP.

The righty gave up six runs in 2.0 IP when he played the Phillies earlier this year.

Key stat: Bader has four RBI during his five-game hitting streak.

Best MLB picks

Waldrep over 4.5 Ks (-150): Waldrep owned a sparkling 0.90 ERA through five MLB starts, completely shutting down some below-average teams while going 3-2 against this line.

Then came his true test of mettle: A Sunday Night Baseball showdown against the Phillies.

The Atlanta Braves righty answered the bell, striking out nine and allowing just one run in 5.2 IP. This kid is the real deal, and he should have no trouble mowing down the Seattle Mariners.

Seattle has had a top-10 K rate over the season, in the last 30 days, and against right-handers.

The Mariners rank 29th in batting average and 20th in wRC+ since the all-star break, so I trust Waldrep to work deep into this outing.

He threw a career-high 102 pitches his last time out.

Langeliers to score (-118): This price seems too good to be true for the Athletics’ leadoff man.

  • Langeliers is batting .297 with a 1.038 OPS when hitting first, and he has destroyed left-handed pitching all season.
  • He owns a .360/.370/.663 slash line against southpaws, and gets a struggling one in Los Angeles Angels starter Yusei Kikuchi.
  • Kikuchi has a 5.97 ERA in six starts since Aug. 1.

Langeliers has taken the southpaw deep before, and will have plenty of chances to get aboard in front of a sneaky-good offence.

The A’s are 11th in wRC+ and sixth in ISO this season.

MLB prop picks made at 11:00 a.m. ET on 09/06/2025.

Best MLB prop bets Sept. 6: Back Waldrep, Bader and Langeliers on Saturday

MLB prop bets

Rookie sensation Hurston Waldrep and Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Harrison Bader headline Saturday’s MLB prop bets.

Today’s MLB props narrative: Bader has been on a tear since joining the Phillies at the trade deadline, while Waldrep has been nearly untouchable over six starts as a rookie. Both have plus-money value to do damage today.

Check out my favourite MLB prop bets for Sept. 6, featuring a pick on Athletics slugger Shea Langeliers.

MLB prop bets

Best bet: Bader to record an RBI (+188)

Bader has been quite the get for Philadelphia, adding more firepower to an already loaded roster ahead of what should be a deep playoff run.

Check out what the outfielder has done for the Phillies since he was acquired at the trade deadline:

  • .304/.375/.500 slash line
  • .382/.452/.673 slash line vs. RHP
  • 52% hard-hit rate

Bader is slated to hit sixth for Philadelphia today behind names like Trea Turner, Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber. That’s an elite spot for run production

Today, the Phillies take on Sandy Alcantara and the Miami Marlins, and I think things could get ugly.

Philadelphia’s current lineup is batting .304 against Alcantara in a massive 286 at-bat sample. Alcantara is also having the worst year of his professional career, with a 5.66 ERA and 1.32 WHIP.

The righty gave up six runs in 2.0 IP when he played the Phillies earlier this year.

Key stat: Bader has four RBI during his five-game hitting streak.

Embed: #117605

Best MLB picks

Waldrep over 5.5 Ks (+143): Waldrep owned a sparkling 0.90 ERA through five MLB starts, completely shutting down some below-average teams while going 3-2 against this line.

Then came his true test of mettle: A Sunday Night Baseball showdown against the Phillies.

The Atlanta Braves righty answered the bell, striking out nine and allowing just one run in 5.2 IP. This kid is the real deal, and he should have no trouble mowing down the Seattle Mariners.

Seattle has had a top-10 K rate over the season, in the last 30 days, and against right-handers.

The Mariners rank 29th in batting average and 20th in wRC+ since the all-star break, so I trust Waldrep to work deep into this outing.

He threw a career-high 102 pitches his last time out.

Langeliers to score (-117): This price seems too good to be true for the Athletics’ leadoff man.

  • Langeliers is batting .297 with a 1.038 OPS when hitting first, and he has destroyed left-handed pitching all season.
  • He owns a .360/.370/.663 slash line against southpaws, and gets a struggling one in Los Angeles Angels starter Yusei Kikuchi.
  • Kikuchi has a 5.97 ERA in six starts since Aug. 1.

Langeliers has taken the southpaw deep before, and will have plenty of chances to get aboard in front of a sneaky-good offence.

The A’s are 11th in wRC+ and sixth in ISO this season.

MLB prop picks made at 11:00 a.m. ET on 09/06/2025.

MLB home run picks Sept. 6: Bet on Padres’ Machado and Tatis to go yard

MLB home run picks

Coors Field has my attention when looking for MLB home run picks on Saturday.

Today’s MLB HR narrative: Colorado is never a bad place for the long ball. The San Diego Padres visit the Colorado Rockies tonight, putting Manny Machado and Fernando Tatis Jr. in a prime position to mash.

Check out the best MLB home run picks and analysis for Sept. 6, featuring Corbin Carroll.

MLB home run picks

Best Bet: Machado to hit a home run (+255)

It’s impossible to ignore how Coors Field can really boost a home run pick.

Everything is just a little bit different in Denver. The area’s thin, dry air makes it a hitter’s paradise. Here’s how it ranks among several key categories per MLB Park Factors:

  • 1st in overall Park Factor (112).
  • 1st in wOBACon (112).
  • 1st in BACON (113)
  • T-8th in HR (105)

And while the environmental conditions should help San Diego’s offence, so should the pitcher it’ll see.

Rookie McCade Brown will make his third-ever appearance. His numbers thus far aren’t pretty.

Brown enters tonight’s contest with an 8.22 ERA and 6.66 FIP across 7.2 innings pitched. He’s allowed one home run and a pair of doubles in his young MLB career.

Machado hasn’t been hitting the ball well lately, but he does have one homer in his last two games. I’m betting on that being a sign of more to come.

Key stat: Machado has 10 home runs in 56 games at the ballpark in his career, the most he has at any venue he’s played 60 games or less.

Best HR predictions

Tatis to hit a home run (+260): Tatis benefits from all the same Coors Field perks as Machado, but he also experiences a significant platoon boon against right-handed pitching.

The Padres battled lefty Kyle Freeland on Friday to little success. The team scored one run, and Tatis went a disappointing 1-for-3.

But those who know Tatis’ splits know that he struggles mightily against lefties:

  • Tatis has a .281/.376/.470 slash line vs. righties.
  • He has a much worse .209/.343/.317 slash line vs. lefties this season.
  • Tatis has 16 homers vs. righties and three home runs vs. lefties.

Luckily, Brown is a righty.

Tatis has one home run in four games at Coors Field in 2025.

Carroll to hit a home run (+375): Carroll is heating up, and I want in.

The Arizona Diamondbacks star is seeing the ball very well ahead of tonight’s matchup vs. the Boston Red Sox. He has three home runs and five extra-base hits in his last six games.

One of those came in yesterday’s series opener against Boston, and I expect more of the same today.

Lucas Giolito gets the start for the Red Sox, and his 3.38 ERA provides a misleading look at his season results.

Giolito’s advanced numbers are downright brutal:

  • 4.98 xERA (15th percentile)
  • .272 xBA (19th percentile)

The game is at Chase Field, which is fourth in MLB Park Factors (103). Expect a strong showing from the do-it-all outfielder.

MLB home run picks made at 10:32 a.m. ET on 09/06/2025.

MLB home run picks Sept. 6: Bet on Padres’ Machado and Tatis to go yard

MLB home run picks

Coors Field has my attention when looking for MLB home run picks on Saturday.

Today’s MLB HR narrative: Colorado is never a bad place for the long ball. The San Diego Padres visit the Colorado Rockies tonight, putting Manny Machado and Fernando Tatis Jr. in a prime position to mash.

Check out the best MLB home run picks and analysis for Sept. 6, featuring Corbin Carroll.

MLB home run picks

Best Bet: Machado to hit a home run (+350)

It’s impossible to ignore how Coors Field can really boost a home run pick.

Everything is just a little bit different in Denver. The area’s thin, dry air makes it a hitter’s paradise. Here’s how it ranks among several key categories per MLB Park Factors:

  • 1st in overall Park Factor (112).
  • 1st in wOBACon (112).
  • 1st in BACON (113)
  • T-8th in HR (105)

And while the environmental conditions should help San Diego’s offence, so should the pitcher it’ll see.

Rookie McCade Brown will make his third-ever appearance. His numbers thus far aren’t pretty.

Brown enters tonight’s contest with an 8.22 ERA and 6.66 FIP across 7.2 innings pitched. He’s allowed one home run and a pair of doubles in his young MLB career.

Machado hasn’t been hitting the ball well lately, but he does have one homer in his last two games. I’m betting on that being a sign of more to come.

Key stat: Machado has 10 home runs in 56 games at the ballpark in his career, the most he has at any venue he’s played 60 games or less.

Embed: #117601

Best HR predictions

Tatis to hit a home run (+340): Tatis benefits from all the same Coors Field perks as Machado, but he also experiences a significant platoon boon against right-handed pitching.

The Padres battled lefty Kyle Freeland on Friday to little success. The team scored one run, and Tatis went a disappointing 1-for-3.

But those who know Tatis’ splits know that he struggles mightily against lefties:

  • Tatis has a .281/.376/.470 slash line vs. righties.
  • He has a much worse .209/.343/.317 slash line vs. lefties this season.
  • Tatis has 16 homers vs. righties and three home runs vs. lefties.

Luckily, Brown is a righty.

Tatis has one home run in four games at Coors Field in 2025.

Carroll to hit a home run (+390): Carroll is heating up, and I want in.

The Arizona Diamondbacks star is seeing the ball very well ahead of tonight’s matchup vs. the Boston Red Sox. He has three home runs and five extra-base hits in his last six games.

One of those came in yesterday’s series opener against Boston, and I expect more of the same today.

Lucas Giolito gets the start for the Red Sox, and his 3.38 ERA provides a misleading look at his season results.

Giolito’s advanced numbers are downright brutal:

  • 4.98 xERA (15th percentile)
  • .272 xBA (19th percentile)

The game is at Chase Field, which is fourth in MLB Park Factors (103). Expect a strong showing from the do-it-all outfielder.

MLB home run picks made at 10:32 a.m. ET on 09/06/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees best bets Sept. 6: Back New York’s offence, Aaron Judge on Saturday

Blue Jays vs. Yankees best bets

Saturday’s matinee between the Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees should feature fireworks.

The pregame narrative: Toronto extended its AL East lead to four with a convincing win in yesterday’s series opener. But New York is favoured today with 2024 AL Rookie of the Year, Luis Gil, pitching. Chris Bassitt, who has struggled against the Yankees and on the road, gets the ball for the Blue Jays.

Check out my Blue Jays best bets vs. the Yankees for Sept. 6, featuring Aaron Judge and Daulton Varsho.

Blue Jays best bets vs. Yankees

Best bet: Yankees over 4.5 runs (-150)

This isn’t a “must-win” game for New York’s divisional hopes, but it’s pretty close.

The Yankees’ offence is capable of putting up huge numbers, and I expect it to rebound after yesterday’s embarrassing 7-1 loss at home.

  • New York leads MLB in runs per game (5.26).
  • Before Friday, the Yankees were 10-1 against this line in their last 11 games. They averaged 7.45 runs per game in those contests.
  • Since the all-star break, New York is top eight in wRC+, OPS and SLG and first in ISO.

I don’t expect Bassitt to keep this group in check at the hitter-friendly Yankee Stadium.

Toronto’s righty is coming off a quality start on the road in Cincinnati (6.0 IP, 2 ER), but his numbers away from Rogers Centre are still concerning. In 13 starts, he has a 5.82 ERA and a .288 opponent batting average.

On top of that, this Yankees lineup has had his number.

Key stat: New York is batting .285 and slugging .517 against Bassitt in 151 combined at-bats.

Jays prop picks

Judge over 1.5 bases (-112): I took this wager yesterday, and it fell flat when Judge went 1-for-3 with a single.

The AL MVP frontrunner is now slashing .245/.417/.469 since Aug. 1. He’s still getting on base a ton, but the batting average is way down, and so is his power.

Nonetheless, Judge still leads MLB in all three slash categories, ISO, and total bases per game.

He’s going to break out of this rut sooner than later, and Bassitt should be a great slump-buster. The righty doesn’t walk a ton of batters — a plus for this prop — and has a 38th percentile xBA.

Judge is 6-for-21 against Bassitt with two home runs.

Varsho over 0.5 RBI (+115): Toronto’s offence should get its licks in, too, and Varsho has solid value to record an RBI.

He’s slated to hit fifth for the Jays, according to RotoWire, behind George Springer, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette.

That trio has been on fire in the second half and Varsho has capitalized on that with an RBI in four straight games and seven of his last nine.

He’s also slashing an absurd .260/.309/.712 against RHP this year.

Blue Jays best bets made at 8:49 a.m. ET on 09/06/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees best bets Sept. 6: Back New York’s offence, Aaron Judge on Saturday

Blue Jays vs. Yankees best bets

Saturday’s matinee between the Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees should feature fireworks.

The pregame narrative: Toronto extended its AL East lead to four with a convincing win in yesterday’s series opener. But New York is favoured today with 2024 AL Rookie of the Year, Luis Gil, pitching. Chris Bassitt, who has struggled against the Yankees and on the road, gets the ball for the Blue Jays.

Check out my Blue Jays best bets vs. the Yankees for Sept. 6, featuring Aaron Judge and Daulton Varsho.

Blue Jays best bets vs. Yankees

Best bet: Yankees over 4.5 runs (-141)

This isn’t a “must-win” game for New York’s divisional hopes, but it’s pretty close.

The Yankees’ offence is capable of putting up huge numbers, and I expect it to rebound after yesterday’s embarrassing 7-1 loss at home.

  • New York leads MLB in runs per game (5.26).
  • Before Friday, the Yankees were 10-1 against this line in their last 11 games. They averaged 7.45 runs per game in those contests.
  • Since the all-star break, New York is top eight in wRC+, OPS and SLG and first in ISO.

I don’t expect Bassitt to keep this group in check at the hitter-friendly Yankee Stadium.

Toronto’s righty is coming off a quality start on the road in Cincinnati (6.0 IP, 2 ER), but his numbers away from Rogers Centre are still concerning. In 13 starts, he has a 5.82 ERA and a .288 opponent batting average.

On top of that, this Yankees lineup has had his number.

Key stat: New York is batting .285 and slugging .517 against Bassitt in 151 combined at-bats.

Embed: #117598

Jays prop picks

Judge over 1.5 bases (-115): I took this wager yesterday, and it fell flat when Judge went 1-for-3 with a single.

The AL MVP frontrunner is now slashing .245/.417/.469 since Aug. 1. He’s still getting on base a ton, but the batting average is way down, and so is his power.

Nonetheless, Judge still leads MLB in all three slash categories, ISO, and total bases per game.

He’s going to break out of this rut sooner than later, and Bassitt should be a great slump-buster. The righty doesn’t walk a ton of batters — a plus for this prop — and has a 38th percentile xBA.

Judge is 6-for-21 against Bassitt with two home runs.

Varsho over 0.5 RBI (+135): Toronto’s offence should get its licks in, too, and Varsho has solid value to record an RBI.

He’s slated to hit fifth for the Jays, according to RotoWire, behind George Springer, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette.

That trio has been on fire in the second half and Varsho has capitalized on that with an RBI in four straight games and seven of his last nine.

He’s also slashing an absurd .260/.309/.712 against RHP this year.

Blue Jays best bets made at 8:49 a.m. ET on 09/06/2025.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees SGP predictions Sept. 5: Back Toronto, Gausman at +700 in series opener

Blue Jays vs. Yankees predictions

A pivotal AL East series between the Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees begins in the Bronx on Friday night.

The pregame narrative: Toronto heads into the three-game set with a three-game lead over New York, which occupies a wild-card spot. Kevin Gausman gets the assignment and he dazzled when he last saw the Yankees in July. I like both Toronto and Gausman to deliver in the series opener.

Check out my Blue Jays vs. Yankees same-game parlay predictions for Sept. 5, featuring a prediction on Aaron Judge.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees predictions

Parlay: Blue Jays to win | Gausman over 5.5 Ks | Judge over 1.5 total bases (+700)

Toronto ML (+114): There are safer options I like more, but I love the price of this three-leg same-game parlay. And I don’t think it’s a far-fetched outcome by any means.

Would you be surprised if the first-place Blue Jays won behind Gausman tonight? No.

How about if Gausman (5-3 vs. this line in the second half) recorded six-plus strikeouts? No.

Judge, fourth in MLB in games with two-plus total bases, to clear a 1.5 line? No.

Well, if you combine those selections, you get a +700 SGP. Count me in.

  • The Blue Jays were off Thursday, giving their struggling bullpen a much-needed reset.
  • Toronto is 7-3 vs. the Yankees, taking two of three vs. them in July and sweeping a four-game set earlier that month.
  • This is a rare spot to get the Blue Jays as an underdog. They’ve been favoured in 13 of their last 15 games. Toronto hasn’t had a bigger plus-money price to win since Aug. 10 vs. the Dodgers, according to Team Rankings.

The Blue Jays have only won one of Gausman’s last five starts, but that hasn’t been the fault of the right-hander.

Gausman allowed two runs or fewer in four of those outings and was excellent against the Yankees in late July. He spun seven innings of one-run ball in a 4-1 win.

As for Toronto’s offence, it ranks No. 1 in MLB average, on-base percentage, slugging and wRC+ in the second half.

Embed: #117586

MLB SGP legs

Gausman over 5.5 Ks (-141): Sticking with Gausman, there’s plenty to like right now.

His ERA, WHIP and walk rate are all vastly improved in the second half. More importantly for this bet, so is his K rate.

Gausman’s first-half K rate was a respectable 23.1%, but that’s shot up to 27.3% since the all-star break.

  • The veteran is 16-11 vs. this line on the season.
  • He has punched out at least seven batters in five of his last eight outings, including eight Yankees in that July gem.

The way both the righty and Toronto’s bullpen have been throwing, Gausman should have a pretty long leash tonight.

New York is top 10 in MLB in K% over the last 30 days, over the full season, and vs. RHPs.

Judge over 1.5 total bases (+100): Judge doesn’t need much selling.

He leads the majors in all three slash categories, wRC+ and WAR (FanGraphs). And he has pulverized Gausman plenty in the past.

In 58 career plate appearances, Judge has 16 hits (six homers) and a .356/.491/.822 batting line.

If he can’t top this number against Gausman, he’ll get a crack vs. Toronto’s bullpen, which has the worst second-half ERA (5.60) in the AL.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees predictions made at 12:45 p.m. ET on 09/05/2025

Red Sox vs. Diamondbacks SGP predictions Sept. 5: Back rookie pitcher Tolle, Boston at +450

Red Sox vs. Diamondbacks predictions

The Boston Red Sox look to gain ground in the AL East race during their three-game set against the Arizona Diamondbacks beginning on Friday.

The pregame narrative: Boston is 3.5 games back of the Toronto Blue Jays, who are in New York for a pivotal series against the Yankees. The Red Sox, now without Roman Anthony, are a slight favourite with rookie Payton Tolle going opposite Eduardo Rodriguez.

Check out my Red Sox vs. Diamondbacks SGP predictions for Sept. 5, featuring Tolle and Rob Refsnyder.

Red Sox vs. Diamondbacks predictions

Parlay: Red Sox F5 +0.5 | Tolle over 4.5 Ks | Refsnyder 1+ RBI (+450)

Red Sox F5 +0.5 (-162): I want to tap into what I perceive to be a pitching advantage in Boston’s favour.

Tolle has only made one MLB start, and it was solid. He fanned eight Pittsburgh Pirates over 5.1 innings of two-run ball. I’ll circle back on the rookie later, but believe he’s due for another strong outing.

Rodriguez, meanwhile, has a massive MLB sample, and it’s ugly.

The southpaw owns a 5.40 ERA this season and has gotten routinely shelved at Chase Field, MLB’s third-most hitter-friendly environment, according to Baseball Savant’s Park Factors.

Boston’s active lineup has a successful history against Rodriguez over a large sample, too.

The Sox are a collective 22-for-67 against him with a .612 slugging percentage. I expect them to be at least tied through five frames.

Embed: #117573

MLB SGP legs

Tolle over 4.5 Ks (-152): Back to the 6-foot-6, moustachioed 22-year-old southpaw.

Tolle was torching the minor leagues before joining the Sox. He had a 3.04 ERA with a blistering 13.1 K/9 rate in 18 starts this year.

The Texas Christian product has an upper-90s fastball/cutter combo and a 99th percentile “extension,” which essentially measures how far from the rubber he releases his pitches.

That makes his offerings appear even faster for opposing bats.

Arizona is a tough team to put away on strikes, especially for lefties, but Tolle has generated great swing-and-miss at every level and will have the advantage of seeing this lineup for the first time.

Refsnyder 1+ RBI (+170): Refsnyder only has 23 RBI on the season, but this is oozing with value.

He’s slated to hit fifth for Boston tonight, according to Rotowire, behind names like Alex Bregman and Trevor Story.

That duo has reached base safely in a combined 18-of-42 plate appearances against Rodriguez (.428 OBP). Refsnyder is just 2-for-10 against the lefty, but he has a .392 xBA in those at-bats, so I expect some positive regression.

And on the season, Refsnyder has demolished left-handed pitching to the tune of a .304/.395/.559 slash line.

This is a great price for a player in a run-producing spot.

Red Sox vs. Diamondbacks predictions made at 11:26 a.m. ET on 09/05/2025.

Looking to get started? Sign up here.