Steven Psihogios

Stevie’s an avid NFL, NHL, and tennis bettor who has no problem talking himself into the underdog. His previous stops include Yahoo! Sports Canada and Toronto Metropolitan University, where he received a degree in Sport Media.

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs Game 1 best bets: Expect Florida, Bennett to shine in second round series opener

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets

The Toronto Maple Leafs host the Florida Panthers for Game 1 of their second-round series on Monday night.

The pregame narrative: The Panthers appear ready for another deep playoff run and are rightful favourites as well as my pick to win Game 1. Secondly, I’m taking the over with two capable offences doing battle.

Check out my Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets for Game 1 of the second round, featuring Sam Bennett.

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets

Best Bet: Panthers moneyline (-125)

Florida was far more impressive than its second-round opponent.

The Panthers downed a much stronger team in faster fashion than the Maple Leafs. The former only needed five games to oust the Tampa Bay Lightning, while the latter needed six to beat the Ottawa Senators.

The Cats were able to win more convincingly than Toronto. They earned four multi-goal victories in the first round, while the Maple Leafs needed overtime for two of their wins.

Regular season results also favour Florida. It won three of its four contests against Toronto this past season.

Lastly, I expect the Panthers to physically overwhelm the Maple Leafs. Florida found itself in an all-out battle with Tampa Bay, while Toronto’s series with Ottawa didn’t have quite the same intensity.

Expect the Panthers to look sharp in Game 1 and earn a win.

Key stat: Florida has won nine of 13 games versus Toronto since the two met in the 2023 playoffs.

Game 1 picks

Over 5.5 goals (-106): Both these offences can score goals in bunches.

Toronto tied for seventh in the regular season in goals per game (3.26). Florida ranked a respectable 15th (3.00).

The latter was able to light up a very talented Andrei Vasilevskiy in the first round, scoring 19 goals across five contests.

The Maple Leafs scored 19 goals in six contests, notching three-plus markers in five of their games.

One situation to monitor in this series is how Anthony Stolarz holds up against his ex-team. He struggled across three regular-season contests, surrendering nine goals in three games while posting an .886 save percentage.

Bennett anytime goal (+265): There are several reasons why Bennett is my preferred goal-scorer bet for Monday.

Firstly, the Panthers forward is putting plenty of pucks on net. He led the team with 17 shots on goal in the first round.

That translated into offensive production as he tied for the team lead with three goals.

Bennett terrorized Toronto in the regular season, too. The physical forward scored three goals and five points in three games against the Maple Leafs.

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets made at 3:42 p.m. ET 05/03/2025.

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs Game 1 best bets: Expect Florida, Bennett to shine in second round series opener

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets

The Toronto Maple Leafs host the Florida Panthers for Game 1 of their second-round series on Monday night.

The pregame narrative: The Panthers appear ready for another deep playoff run and are rightful favourites as well as my pick to win Game 1. Secondly, I’m taking the over with two capable offences doing battle.

Check out my Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets for Game 1 of the second round, featuring Sam Bennett.

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets

Best Bet: Panthers moneyline (-125)

Florida was far more impressive than its second-round opponent.

The Panthers downed a much stronger team in faster fashion than the Maple Leafs. The former only needed five games to oust the Tampa Bay Lightning, while the latter needed six to beat the Ottawa Senators.

The Cats were able to win more convincingly than Toronto. They earned four multi-goal victories in the first round, while the Maple Leafs needed overtime for two of their wins.

Regular season results also favour Florida. It won three of its four contests against Toronto this past season.

Lastly, I expect the Panthers to physically overwhelm the Maple Leafs. Florida found itself in an all-out battle with Tampa Bay, while Toronto’s series with Ottawa didn’t have quite the same intensity.

Expect the Panthers to look sharp in Game 1 and earn a win.

Key stat: Florida has won nine of 13 games versus Toronto since the two met in the 2023 playoffs.

Quick picks

Over 5.5 goals (+100): Both these offences can score goals in bunches.

Toronto tied for seventh in the regular season in goals per game (3.26). Florida ranked a respectable 15th (3.00).

The latter was able to light up a very talented Andrei Vasilevskiy in the first round, scoring 19 goals across five contests.

The Maple Leafs scored 19 goals in six contests, notching three-plus markers in five of their games.

One situation to monitor in this series is how Anthony Stolarz holds up against his ex-team. He struggled across three regular-season contests, surrendering nine goals in three games while posting an .886 save percentage.

Bennett anytime goal (+225): There are several reasons why Bennett is my preferred goal-scorer bet for Monday.

Firstly, the Panthers forward is putting plenty of pucks on net. He led the team with 17 shots on goal in the first round.

That translated into offensive production as he tied for the team lead with three goals.

Bennett terrorized Toronto in the regular season, too. The physical forward scored three goals and five points in three games against the Maple Leafs.

Panthers vs. Maple Leafs best bets made at 3:42 p.m. ET 05/03/2025.

Blues vs. Jets best bets Game 7: Pick Winnipeg to win a low-scoring game

Blues vs. Jets best bets

The St. Louis Blues and Winnipeg Jets settle their first-round series on Sunday night.

The pregame narrative: Very few people expected St. Louis to push Winnipeg to the brink of elimination. I’m betting on the Jets powering through, however, thanks to a strong performance from Connor Hellebuyck. Additionally, the under on the game total and Jordan Kyrou’s point prop round out my ticket.

Check out my Blues vs. Jets best bets for Game 7 of the opening round.

Blues vs. Jets best bets

Best Bet: Jets 60-minute moneyline (+100)

Home-ice advantage has earned its moniker in this series.

The home team is an undefeated 6-0 thus far, and I expect that trend to continue in Game 7.

Winnipeg has been excellent at Canada Life Place all year long. It went 30-7-4 in the regular season and has outscored St. Louis, 12-7, there in this series.

The Blues were a mediocre 20-16-5 as a visitor in the regular season and haven’t proven they can win on the road in the playoffs.

Hellebuyck has been better at home in this series. The likely Vezina-Trophy winner has posted a sub-.800 save percentage in all three road games in this series, but has topped that mark in all three home games.

I’m also anticipating Hellebuyck having his strongest game of the series. The American netminder hasn’t been as sharp in the playoffs, but he’s capable of stepping up with an absolutely stellar performance at any moment.

Key stat: Winnipeg has won nine of its last 10 home games against St. Louis in regulation.

Embed: #113370

Quick picks

Under 5 goals (+115): I’m expecting Hellebuyck to be at his best in this game, which is a big reason why I’m backing the under.

If Hellebuyck is sharp, then St. Louis won’t contribute much to this total. In the same token, I’m also expecting Jordan Binnington to be stellar.

Binnington has an impressive track record in big contests. He backed the Blues to a Stanley Cup title in 2019, holding the Boston Bruins to one goal in Game 7. He also lifted Canada past the United States of America, 3-2, at the 4 Nations Face-Off.

Mark Scheifele’s injury status also plays heavily into this wager. The Jets centre was electric in this series, notching six points in five contests. Even if he does suit up, he’ll likely be far from fully healthy in this game.

Kyrou to not score 1+ point (-134): I can get behind fading anybody on the Blues with low expectations for their offence.

Kyrou has underwhelmed in this series. He had two points through the first three games but is pointless since. Neither of the winger’s points came at even strength, making him very power-play dependent for production.

St. Louis’ power play has fallen off across the last four games, clicking at a lowly 16.7% rate.

I don’t expect Kyrou to rise to the occasion and will fade him at this price.

Blues vs. Jets best bets made at 2:53 p.m. ET 05/03/2025.

Blues vs. Jets best bets Game 7: Pick Winnipeg to win a low-scoring game

Blues vs. Jets best bets

The St. Louis Blues and Winnipeg Jets settle their first-round series on Sunday night.

The pregame narrative: Very few people expected St. Louis to push Winnipeg to the brink of elimination. I’m betting on the Jets powering through, however, thanks to a strong performance from Connor Hellebuyck. Additionally, the under on the game total and Jordan Kyrou‘s point prop round out my ticket.

Check out my Blues vs. Jets best bets for Game 7 of the opening round.

Blues vs. Jets best bets

Best Bet: Jets 60-minute moneyline (+120)

Home-ice advantage has earned its moniker in this series.

The home team is an undefeated 6-0 thus far, and I expect that trend to continue in Game 7.

Winnipeg has been excellent at Canada Life Place all year long. It went 30-7-4 in the regular season and has outscored St. Louis, 12-7, there in this series.

The Blues were a mediocre 20-16-5 as a visitor in the regular season and haven’t proven they can win on the road in the playoffs.

Hellebuyck has been better at home in this series. The likely Vezina-Trophy winner has posted a sub-.800 save percentage in all three road games in this series, but has topped that mark in all three home games.

I’m also anticipating Hellebuyck having his strongest game of the series. The American netminder hasn’t been as sharp in the playoffs, but he’s capable of stepping up with an absolutely stellar performance at any moment.

Key stat: Winnipeg has won nine of its last 10 home games against St. Louis in regulation.

Embed: #113370

Quick picks

Under 5 goals (+112): I’m expecting Hellebuyck to be at his best in this game, which is a big reason why I’m backing the under.

If Hellebuyck is sharp, then St. Louis won’t contribute much to this total. In the same token, I’m also expecting Jordan Binnington to be stellar.

Binnington has an impressive track record in big contests. He backed the Blues to a Stanley Cup title in 2019, holding the Boston Bruins to one goal in Game 7. He also lifted Canada past the United States of America, 3-2, at the 4 Nations Face-Off.

Mark Scheifele’s injury status also plays heavily into this wager. The Jets centre was electric in this series, notching six points in five contests. Even if he does suit up, he’ll likely be far from fully healthy in this game.

Kyrou to not score 1+ point (-122): I can get behind fading anybody on the Blues with low expectations for their offence.

Kyrou has underwhelmed in this series. He had two points through the first three games but is pointless since. Neither of the winger’s points came at even strength, making him very power-play dependent for production.

St. Louis’ power play has fallen off across the last four games, clicking at a lowly 16.7% rate.

I don’t expect Kyrou to rise to the occasion and will fade him at this price.

Blues vs. Jets best bets made at 2:53 p.m. ET 05/03/2025.

Casper Ruud vs. Jack Draper Madrid Open final best bet and odds: Pick underdog Ruud to win

Ruud vs. Draper best bet

Casper Ruud and Jack Draper square off in what promises to be an excellent Madrid Open final.

The pregame narrative: Ruud and Draper have navigated an unpredictable Madrid Open and enter Sunday’s matchup with a chance at victory. In a tournament that’s been full of upsets, I’m backing Ruud to win as an underdog in the final.

Check out my Ruud vs. Draper Madrid Open final best bet and the odds for May 4.

Ruud vs. Draper best bet

Go to full Ruud vs. Draper betting markets.

Betting marketsOdds
Ruud to win+165
Draper to win-225
Ruud +2.5 games+100
Draper -2.5 games-134
Ruud to win in straight sets+350
Draper to win in straight sets+115
Over 22.5 total games-112
Under 22.5 total games-118

Tennis odds as of 1:32 p.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Best Bet: Ruud to win (+165)

This match feels much closer than the odds suggest.

Ruud has a 35.7% implied probability at this price, which seems a little low even if he’s dealing with a rib injury.

Firstly, Ruud has a very strong track record on clay. He’s 32-9 on this surface since 2024, which is significantly better than his opponent’s mark of 11-8.

This will be Ruud’s second opportunity to win a Masters 1000 on clay. He fell short in the 2024 Monte-Carlo Masters final against Stefanos Tsitsipas.

For Draper, however, this is his very first final appearance at a clay Masters 1000 event.

Both competitors have defeated strong clay-court players at this tournament, but I will give the strength of victory edge to Ruud. The Norwegian has beaten: Taylor Fritz, Daniil Medvedev and Francisco Cerundolo en route to the final.

Draper doesn’t boast the same track record of success on clay that Ruud does. The British tennis star has played just 50 matches on the surface and was a mediocre 24-20 on clay prior to this year’s Madrid Open.

Back Ruud to get it done and win his first-ever Masters 1000 event.

Key stat: Ruud is 244-104 lifetime on clay, notching 20-plus wins on the surface each of the last four years.

Tennis picks made at 1:17 p.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Casper Ruud vs. Jack Draper Madrid Open final best bet and odds: Pick underdog Ruud to win

Ruud vs. Draper best bet

Casper Ruud and Jack Draper square off in what promises to be an excellent Madrid Open final.

The pregame narrative: Ruud and Draper have navigated an unpredictable Madrid Open and enter Sunday’s matchup with a chance at victory. In a tournament that’s been full of upsets, I’m backing Ruud to win as an underdog in the final.

Check out my Ruud vs. Draper Madrid Open final best bet and the odds for May 4.

Ruud vs. Draper best bet

Go to full Ruud vs. Draper betting markets.

Betting marketsOdds
Ruud to win+180
Draper to win-220
Ruud +2.5 games+107
Draper -2.5 games-130
Ruud to win in straight sets+410
Draper to win in straight sets+125
Over 22.5 total games-117
Under 22.5 total games-107

Tennis odds as of 12:59 p.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Best Bet: Ruud to win (+180)

This match feels much closer than the odds suggest.

Ruud has a 35.7% implied probability at this price, which seems a little low even if he’s dealing with a rib injury.

Firstly, Ruud has a very strong track record on clay. He’s 32-9 on this surface since 2024, which is significantly better than his opponent’s mark of 11-8.

This will be Ruud’s second opportunity to win a Masters 1000 on clay. He fell short in the 2024 Monte-Carlo Masters final against Stefanos Tsitsipas.

For Draper, however, this is his very first final appearance at a clay Masters 1000 event.

Both competitors have defeated strong clay-court players at this tournament, but I will give the strength of victory edge to Ruud. The Norwegian has beaten: Taylor Fritz, Daniil Medvedev and Francisco Cerundolo en route to the final.

Draper doesn’t boast the same track record of success on clay that Ruud does. The British tennis star has played just 50 matches on the surface and was a mediocre 24-20 on clay prior to this year’s Madrid Open.

Back Ruud to get it done and win his first-ever Masters 1000 event.

Key stat: Ruud is 244-104 lifetime on clay, notching 20-plus wins on the surface each of the last four years.

Tennis picks made at 1:17 p.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop pick May 3: Fade Williams against Toronto

Blue Jays pick

The Toronto Blue Jays host the Cleveland Guardians for the second game of their weekend series on Saturday.

The pregame narrative: Toronto’s lineup is tough to strike out. Gavin Williams’ inconsistent punch-out skills make him a quality fade candidate in this matchup.

Check out my Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks for May 3.

Blue Jays pick vs. Guardians

Best Bet: Williams under 4.5 strikeouts (-106)

Williams possesses some strikeout skills.

  • 68th-percentile chase rate (30.2)
  • 74th-percentile whiff rate (29.1)

While those are solid numbers, they haven’t translated to elite punchout totals. He has a 56th-percentile strikeout rate (22.8), and he’s topped this total in only three of six games.

I’m skeptical of his chances of doing so in a difficult matchup. The Blue Jays have the second-lowest strikeout rate in MLB (7.09).

Additionally, shorter-than-usual outings are always in Williams’ range of possibilities. He’s pitched five innings or shorter in four of his last six outings, lasting three or fewer twice.

His 5.14 ERA and 4.88 FIP are worrisome in addition to his .275 opponent batting average.

The advanced numbers paint a similar picture, too. Williams enters this contest with a 12th-percentile expected ERA (5.91) and an eighth-percentile expected opponent batting average (.304).

Guardians vs. Blue Jays picks made at 10:49 a.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks May 3: Bet on Santana to deliver at plus-money odds

Blue Jays picks

I’m backing a hitter and fading a pitcher in my Cleveland Guardians vs. Toronto Blue Jays prop picks for Saturday.

The pregame narrative: Carlos Santana boasts an impressive track record against Toronto starter Kevin Gausman and is a solid pick to beat his plus-money bases prop. I’m fading Gavin Williams‘ strikeout prop against a stingy Blue Jays lineup.

Check out my Guardians vs. Blue Jays prop picks for May 3.

Blue Jays picks vs. Guardians

Best Bet: Santana over 1.5 total bases (+163)

This isn’t a line Santana beats with any sort of regularity.

The Guardians slugger has recorded two-plus bases in just seven games this season, and he hasn’t recorded an extra-base hit since April 9.

But there are several reasons to back him on this prop.

The first is his track record against Gausman. Santana has crushed the Blue Jays’ righty across 21 at-bats:

  • Seven hits
  • Five extra-base hits

Secondly, Gausman is having a tough go of things this season. He pairs a 4.50 ERA with a 3.91 FIP, and the advanced numbers suggest he may no longer possess elite stuff.

  • 48th-percentile expected ERA (3.88)
  • 40th-percentile whiff rate (23.8)
  • 47th-percentile strikeout rate (21.2)

Gausman’s most recent outing was his worst of the campaign. The Toronto star lasted just 2.2 innings, allowing six earned runs while walking five batters.

I expect his struggles to continue against a familiar face who has done well against him in the past.

Key stat: Santana has a .364 batting average across his last four games.

Embed: #113355

Quick pick

Williams under 4.5 strikeouts (-115): Williams possesses some strikeout skills.

  • 68th-percentile chase rate (30.2)
  • 74th-percentile whiff rate (29.1)

While those are solid numbers, they haven’t translated to elite punchout totals. He has a 56th-percentile strikeout rate (22.8), and he’s topped this total in only three of six games.

I’m skeptical of his chances of doing so in a difficult matchup. The Blue Jays have the second-lowest strikeout rate in MLB (7.09).

Additionally, shorter-than-usual outings are always in Williams’ range of possibilities. He’s pitched five innings or shorter in four of his last six outings, lasting three or fewer twice.

His 5.14 ERA and 4.88 FIP are worrisome in addition to his .275 opponent batting average.

The advanced numbers paint a similar picture, too. Williams enters this contest with a 12th-percentile expected ERA (5.91) and an eighth-percentile expected opponent batting average (.304).

Guardians vs. Blue Jays picks made at 10:49 a.m. ET on 05/03/2025.

Avalanche vs. Stars prop picks Game 5: Bet on MacKinnon, Makar to top shot props

Avalanche vs. Stars picks

There’ll be plenty of star power on the ice for Game 5 between the Colorado Avalanche and Dallas Stars.

The pregame narrative: Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar are pacing the Avs in shots in this series. Both are solid candidates to top their props at plus-money odds.

Check out my Avalanche vs. Stars picks for Game 5 of the opening round.

Avalanche vs. Stars picks

Best Bet: MacKinnon over 4.5 shots (+115)

Few players can take over a game like MacKinnon.

The forward’s combination of size, speed and skill makes him one of the most dominating forces in the game.

He’s flexing his offensive prowess against one of the NHL’s stingiest defensive squads in Dallas. MacKinnon leads the Avs in:

  • Goals: 4
  • Points: 5
  • Shots: 24

The latter is truly impressive — MacKinnon led all skaters by five shots entering Sunday’s NHL action.

Dallas is really struggling to contain him and the Avalanche as a whole in this series. Colorado leads the playoffs in shots per game (34.5)

The Stars, as a result, are also ceding the third-most expected goals per 60 in the playoffs per Natural Stat Trick (13.86).

It doesn’t seem like Dallas will be able to contain MacKinnon, and betting him to top his shot prop seems like the right play.

Key stat: MacKinnon has five-plus shots in five of his last eight games.

Game 5 prop prediction

Makar over 3.5 shots (+125): A lot of the same reasoning that goes into backing MacKinnon applies here.

Makar is another Avalanche star who isn’t struggling to put pucks on goal. He’s second on the Avs with shots, topping this prop in two of four games during this series.

He, like the rest of the team, should continue peppering Jake Oettinger with shots. Dallas, after all, did cede the ninth-most shots per game in the regular season (29.0).

Makar has taken at least nine shot attempts in all four games of this series. He’ll continue to put a steady stream of pucks towards the goal and be a great pick to cash this wager at plus-money odds.

Avalanche vs. Stars prop picks made at 3:46 p.m. ET on 04/27/2025.

Avalanche vs. Stars prop picks Game 5: Bet on MacKinnon, Makar to top shot props

Avalanche vs. Stars picks

There’ll be plenty of star power on the ice for Game 5 between the Colorado Avalanche and Dallas Stars.

The pregame narrative: Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar are pacing the Avs in shots in this series. Both are solid candidates to top their props at plus-money odds. Thirdly, Artturi Lehkonen is a tremendous value to register a point.

Check out my Avalanche vs. Stars picks for Game 5 of the opening round.

Avalanche vs. Stars picks

Best Bet: MacKinnon over 4.5 shots (+130)

Few players can take over a game like MacKinnon.

The forward’s combination of size, speed and skill makes him one of the most dominating forces in the game.

He’s flexing his offensive prowess against one of the NHL’s stingiest defensive squads in Dallas. MacKinnon leads the Avs in:

  • Goals: 4
  • Points: 5
  • Shots: 24

The latter is truly impressive — MacKinnon led all skaters by five shots entering Sunday’s NHL action.

Dallas is really struggling to contain him and the Avalanche as a whole in this series. Colorado leads the playoffs in shots per game (34.5)

The Stars, as a result, are also ceding the third-most expected goals per 60 in the playoffs per Natural Stat Trick (13.86).

It doesn’t seem like Dallas will be able to contain MacKinnon, and betting him to top his shot prop seems like the right play.

Key stat: MacKinnon has five-plus shots in five of his last eight games.

Embed: #113077

Game 5 prop predictions

Makar over 3.5 shots (+125): A lot of the same reasoning that goes into backing MacKinnon applies here.

Makar is another Avalanche star who isn’t struggling to put pucks on goal. He’s second on the Avs with shots, topping this prop in two of four games during this series.

He, like the rest of the team, should continue peppering Jake Oettinger with shots. Dallas, after all, did cede the ninth-most shots per game in the regular season (29.0).

Makar has taken at least nine shot attempts in all four games of this series. He’ll continue to put a steady stream of pucks towards the goal and be a great pick to cash this wager at plus-money odds.

Lehkonen to record a point (-112): Lastly, Lehkonen is a great target in this market.

The Avalanche winger found the score sheet in the first couple of games of this series, but has been pointless since. Despite not scoring any points, his Game 4 effort was highly encouraging.

Lehkonen finished the contest with six shots on goal.

His deployment in Colorado’s lineup is what makes this wager intriguing. Lehkonen skates on the team’s first line and top power-play unit. He skates with MacKinnon on both units, which is prime point-scoring positioning.

Lehkonen had five points in three games against Dallas in the regular season.

Avalanche vs. Stars prop picks made at 3:46 p.m. ET on 04/27/2025.