Three star players are the target on my MLB prop bets for Sunday.
Today’s MLB props narrative: Ronald Acuna Jr. is back, healthy and on a tear to start his season. His Atlanta Braves have a chance to win their series against the San Diego Padres this afternoon.
Check out the best MLB prop bets for May 25, featuring predictions on Bryce Harper and Bobby Witt Jr.
MLB prop bets
Best Bet: Acuna Jr. over 1.5 total bases (+115)
It’s easy to buy into the hype of a returning player, but Acuna is a legit top-five talent when healthy.
He’s been quick to remind us after hitting home runs in back-to-back games to start his 2025 campaign.
On Sunday, Acuna faces Dylan Cease, who’s capable of shutting down any offence on any day. But I like this matchup for Acuna, so I’ll back him in a market that relies solely on his bat.
Acuna is 3-for-4 in his career vs. the right-handed hurler with two walks. The walks don’t help with this pick, but they demonstrate his ability to see the ball out of Cease’s hand.
The Braves’ superstar bats in the leadoff spot, so that’ll maximize his at-bats in this game, giving him ample opportunity to cash this over for a third straight time.
Key stat: In Acuna’s last healthy season (2023), he led the league with 386 total bases.
Best MLB picks
Harper over 0.5 RBI (+115): The Phillies have the benefit of facing a rookie starter today.
The Oakland A’s send Gunnar Hoglund to the mound for his fifth start in the majors. He’s struggled so far, posting a 5.06 ERA and 1.41 WHIP while giving up nine earned runs over his last two starts (9.3 IP).
That brings me to Harper, who’s on a tear over his past 18 games:
- .348 BA
- .999 OPS
- 14 RBI (11-7 vs. this prop).
Trea Turner bats leadoff for the Phillies, right in front of Harper, and he ranks 10th in the MLB with 58 total bases over the last 30 days.
If Turner can reach base, his 14 stolen bases also come in handy.
The one-two punch should continue rolling in a soft matchup against an inexperienced pitcher.
Witt Jr over 1.5 total bases (-106): Let’s finish with an early-afternoon pick on a big-time slugger.
Witt is a true five-tool player who can hit for power and use his speed effectively on the basepaths.
- He ranks 12th in MLB with 105 total bases.
- He’s gone over 1.5 bases in 29 of 54 games played this season (54.7%).
The other thing working in Witt’s favour is the matchup on Sunday. He faces Bailey Ober for the Minnesota Twins and is 11-for-22 against the righty.
In that 22-at-bat sample, Witt has only struck out twice.
He sees Ober very well, and I want to back him in a market that’s completely in his control.
MLB prop picks made at 10:05 a.m. ET on 05/25/2025.