Cavaliers vs. Thunder prop picks Jan. 16: Back Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and fade Evan Mobley

Cavaliers vs. Thunder prop picks

The top teams in each conference clash on Thursday when the Oklahoma City Thunder host the Cleveland Cavaliers.

The pregame narrative: The Cavs won the first leg of this matchup, 129-122, in Cleveland on Jan. 8. But I’m expecting a better effort from the Thunder at home and am fading Evan Mobley while backing Shai Gilgeous-Alexander.

Check out my Cavaliers vs. Thunder prop picks for Jan. 16.

Cavaliers vs. Thunder prop picks

Go to full NBA betting markets

Embed: #106394

Best Bet: Mobley under 19.5 points (-112)

Mobley is in the midst of his best scoring season (19.0 PPG) and cleared this number against the Thunder just over a week ago with 21 points.

But I have good reason to fade the Cavaliers’ big man tonight.

This is a number he’s cleared more often than not, though just barely. Mobley is 19-18 against this line and has landed on exactly 20 or 21 points five times.

He’s shooting an efficient 57.7% from the field but doesn’t put up a ton of shots (12.6 per game).

Mobley hasn’t attempted more than 13 field goals in five straight games, which really limits his ceiling as a scorer — especially against a team like the Thunder.

OKC has the best defensive rating (102.9) and lowest opponent effective field goal percentage (49.9%) in the NBA.

I expect Mark Daigneault’s group to dial in defensively at home and limit Mobley tonight.

Key stat: The Thunder give up the second-fewest PPG to power forwards, according to Fantasy Pros.

Quick pick

Gilgeous-Alexander over 1.5 threes (-136): Gilgeous-Alexander is leading the league in scoring (31.4), which has put him in pole position to win MVP.

The Canadian superstar has never been a big 3-point shooter and has reverted to being a mid-range assassin and elite finisher after attempting plenty of deep balls to start the season.

Still, I think this is a fair price to back SGA at tonight.

Cleveland has allowed the eighth-highest opponent 3-point rate (36.5%) in the NBA. It also allows the 12th-most 3s per game to opposing point guards.

Gilgeous-Alexander went 1-for-6 from deep against the Cavs in their last meeting, but that’s the type of volume I like to see.

He’s cleared this number in 23 of 39 starts (58.9%).

Picks made at 9:30 a.m. ET 01/16/2025.

Website | + posts

Avery joined NorthStar Gaming as an intern in 2022 before stepping into a full-time role soon after. He loves betting on and analyzing golf — mainly because it’s easier than actually playing — but is a fan of all sports, from the NFL to the UFC.